‘Because it was like a letter, you understand, a letter. Via this letter you were telling people how we were faring here. An open letter, something, which, how can I say, something very personal but which at the same time was going [on] over there and was going to be useful because it was going to say, “This is happening in Chile”’ (p. 220). So describes Natalia, a shantytown resident, the meaningfulness of making arpilleras during the Pinochet dictatorship (1973–90). Arpilleras are colourful, cloth appliqués stitched originally from old clothes and scraps of material sewn by woman whose economic and political situation pushed them to speak out through art both against repression and poverty to Chilean and solidarity communities abroad. Arpilleras are a very well studied art form, considered as representative of resistance and human rights art. Adams approaches arpilleras in a novel way by focusing not on the message of the art form but rather the community that produced, disseminated and consumed them. As a sociologist, Adams is concerned with the networks and flows of this art form rooted in a shared sense of solidarity to help impoverished women, victims to the generalised and targeted political and economic violence of the era.
In ten chapters, Adams takes the readers from the artistic roots of arpilleras and the formation of arpillera workshops and groups of the producers, to local supporters (such as the important Vicaría de la Solidaridad) who found sellers primarily abroad (formed of exiles and human rights activists), and buyers who were moved to purchase the art both for reasons of wanting to financially help these women and of acquisition. Adams employs a broad range of methodologies including participant observation, archival work in the Vicaría, and photography and art ‘elicidation’, by which she means the use of photographs and arpilleras to prompt conversation. Adams tracks through the transformation of arpilleras from works that crudely denounced repression and poverty in the 1970s to more bucolic, cheerful, colourful scenes that their distributors and managers considered more to the taste of the international market by the mid-1980s. In the process, the earlier message of this work as resistance art made way for the neoliberal market which the pieces had originally rallied against.
By the time Adams conducted her interviews (121 individual and group interviews employing a variety of approaches) at two intervals of five and 15 years (1995–96, 2005–06) after the transition to democracy, the solidarity motivation behind these works was a thing of the past. A veil of nostalgia hovers over the descriptions of this pastime of group activism and solidarity that while tragically the result of repression and poverty had given these women a means to seek community and support beyond their homes in ways that gendered codes permitted. Yet, with the return to democracy these women found themselves once again enclosed by ‘four walls’. Nevertheless, Adams asserts that through arpilleras these women gained the benefit of higher self-esteem, though Adams does not tell us how their economic lives have changed over the decades, despite poverty being such a present theme in Adams's analysis of the motivation for these women's work.
Pearls of information come from Adams's interviews, the main source for her study. Yet, because Adams has selected snippets of these interviews with various actors (arpilleristas, Vicaría members, sellers and buyers) that are then organised according to themes, the potential richness of these interviews is somewhat squandered. Adams tends to repeat themes in part because of trawling back and forth between interview excerpts and analysis. But the richness is also lost in a lack of attention to the interviews. We do not know in which years specific excerpts from the interviews took place, what the setting of the interviews were (individual or collective, in a café or a private home) or the framing of the larger conversations. This seems odd, especially given that oral histories have become such a mainstay for academics across the disciplines, including sociology.
Perhaps an even stranger omission in this work is the entire absence of a consideration of the role of memory in her analysis of the interviews. An entire field of study which academics of various stripes have engaged to understand post-Cold War configurations of Latin America's recent past, and in particular Chile, is not once considered. For instance, with a ten-year spread between her interviews, did these shantytown women view the past differently, or does the lack of attention to the year of the interview mean that these women's views of the past remain fixed despite the passage of time and changes within Chile's memoryscape (the end of the Concertación political coalition, the arrest of Pinochet, the creation of memory sites)? I can only imagine that Steve Stern's trilogy (The Memory Box of Pinochet's Chile), not cited in the bibliography, would have helped situate how memory changes over time.
Another major source in Adams's study are photographs of the arpilleras and their producers. They show Chile of a different era. It would have enriched the author's arguments had the publisher made at least some of them available in colour.
Readers may wish for a more detailed account of Chile's recent history, for more context for the interviews and for a consideration of temporal junctures. Nevertheless, Adams's focus on the participants in the trajectory of arpilleras from Chilean soup kitchens to far-away living rooms adds to our knowledge of how art emerges in response to dictatorship, how repressive regimes shape this art, and how art is a node for solidarity; as such this book contributes to our understanding of art in the aftermath of socio-economic and political violence and in the strengthening of international human rights networks.
