As the introduction to Daniel Schäfer's interesting and insightful new work points out, the historiography of old age has grown massively since the 1940s, to a point where a complete survey is now impossible. Much has recently been written on the subjective experience of old age, including important studies by Pat Thane and Margaret Pelling. Medical concepts of old age have been dealt with to some extent elsewhere, but the overarching Foucauldian concepts of the medicalization of old age through the early modern period have yet to be significantly challenged. This well-written and impressively researched book takes up that task. Rather than exploring the lived experience of old age, Schäfer chooses a counterpoint, taking his lead instead from published medical texts.
The book aims to explore the early modern context for old age, taking in different theoretical, methodological and heuristic viewpoints. In doing so, it takes in a broad view of the range of physiological factors seen as affecting the ageing body, and the notion of old age itself as a disease. While medical historians might not necessarily be surprised to learn that age was viewed by physicians as a slow process of degeneration and loss of essential sprit, it is interesting that while the medical profession certainly recognised old age as a specific state, or stage of life, there was no development of a specific branch within medicine to deal with it. This, Schäfer concludes, provides a solid argument against the medicalization of old age.
The basis of his study is a survey of over 170 medical texts (gerocomies) written by licensed practitioners across Europe between 1500 and 1800. The opening section provides a good overview of the divergent theoretical concepts and classificatory systems of ageing derived from ancient Graeco-Roman texts, before moving on to specific areas such as disease causation and pathology. Such books represent the first detailed codification of old age and, as Schäfer points out, were often written by (and dedicated to) men of middle age and above, and had a limited audience.
Further chapters explore the place of the ageing body in humoural medicine, and of the various strategies for the prevention and treatment of diseases. Schäfer calls on a close reading of a large number of prescriptive gerocomies to explore treatment options in great detail, noting specific types of remedy and regimen specifically aimed at countering the effects of advancing years. There were, for example, a number of age-specific medical conditions and physiological symptoms, from digestive and respiratory ailments to colds, fevers and joint pain. Old age, Schäfer argues, was viewed as a life stage with its own individual phases, as well as constituent effects. As the body aged, it lost essential spirit and vitality, while exogenous effects such as the physical drying and hardening of the body and the lack of replenishment of vital spirits played a part in the process.
The broader concept of longevity is dealt with in some detail, and the author identifies contemporary debates about the maximum possible lifespan for a human body, bringing in evidence from religious and medical texts. Included within this debate are important questions of old age as disease. To briefly summarize a detailed argument, the medical and biological focus on the deleterious effects of age portrays it on the one hand as a negative state. On the other, Enlightenment philosophical toleration of old age, together with a strongly patriarchal society, tended to view age more positively. Questions also surrounded the capability of medicine to reverse (as opposed to simply delaying) its effects. Schäfer does well here in summarizing arguments from Galenic and Paracelsian authors.
The final section of the book explores the place of gerontology in European academic institutions. Drawing on university medical texts, the book charts the changing contexts of age through the early modern period and into the eighteenth century, again bringing in traditional ideas and ‘modern’ alternatives such as iatrochemistry and iatromechanics. Overall, it is Schäfer's contention that, whilst there was certainly increasing attention paid towards old age in both vernacular and professional medical texts during the early modern period, age was not a central theme of medicine. Importantly, he argues that whilst the medical profession recognized old age, it did not redefine it during this time.
The book is doubtless well written and methodologically sound, based on an impressive amount of primary research, although it is not always easy reading. It is replete with esoteric Latin terminology, and it was somewhat surprising to find no glossary of terms, which would have been extremely useful for the non-specialist or, indeed, non-Latin-reading users. Also, some of its findings are perhaps not altogether unsurprising, given what we already know about humoural medicine and life stages. The strength of this book, however, is in its impressive synthesis of a very broad topic and here it makes a very valuable contribution to the already crowded historiography of old age.
