The author of this book has for years been director of the Campaign for the Welfare State in Norway. He has had various positions in trade unions. The main argument of the work is that the Norwegian welfare state has been subject to longstanding assaults, and that the resulting neo-liberal restructuring of the welfare state has been possible due to the diminishing effort by the trade union movement to combat these assaults.
His implicit theoretical perspective is the power-resource model, developed by the well-known Swedish sociologist Walter Korpi. This model aims at explaining the expansion of social democratic welfare states in Scandinavia. According to Wahl, a shift in the balance of power between labour and capital has reversed this trend. Wahl's assertion is that the awareness of structural power has disappeared from the ongoing social debate. This lack of awareness represents in itself a threat on the welfare state. Even social-democrats are caught up in the current model of neo-liberal thinking. Wahl is using this perspective when explaining global restructuring and deregulation of markets.
The aim of this book is to build broad social alliances and to organise resistance against the perceived onslaught on the welfare state. He is defending the idea of a universal welfare state, where individual risks are seen as collective responsibilities resulting in a high degree of economic and social security. Freedom and equality were secured through mutual solidarity. He reminds us that class compromise historically must be understood in the light of the Soviet revolution and the existence of a rival economic system. Redistributive policies were in many countries used to counteract the threat from communism. The capitalists were ready to accept a ‘tactical’ class compromise in order to prevent a radicalisation of the labour movement. The end result was the welfare state. A core of the Nordic model is the tripartite cooperation between the trade unions, employers and public authorities, in itself the result of trade union's structural power.
According to Wahl, the alleged dismantling of the ‘core’ of the welfare state resulted from neo-liberal deregulating of the markets that aimed at restoring profitability and economic growth during periods of crisis, started in the 1970s. Wahl is (rightly I think) critical of using globalisation as an explanatory factor – often described as an inevitable process, as a law of nature. Global actors and massive ideological and political pressures lay behind it. With unlimited right to move freely across borders, (financial) capital has gained a powerful position. Financial assets have expanded much faster than GNP globally. This means a surplus of financial capital desperately hunting for profitable investments. The trade unions were badly prepared to meet the neoliberal offensive, resulting among other things in market-oriented adjustments of public sector, i.e. privatisation. The class compromise, dependent on a specific historical situation, could not be sustained when circumstances change, ended in the 1970s. According to Wahl, the shift in the balance of power between labour and capital is due to an institutionalisation of neo-liberalism.
By using anecdotal evidence attacks on the welfare state and its consequences are demonstrated. According to Wahl, the consequences are social exclusion, inequality, poverty as well as increased commodification of labour. An example of commodification is workfare and the policy of ‘making work pay’, which mostly is destructive and inhumane. Due to workfare a growing number of people are excluded from participation in work and society. Its causes are individualised. The result is also brutalisation of work. A formidable polarisation is taking place. Despite its oil, even Norway is said to be moving in the wrong direction. Well, everything is not bad and I would have preferred a more balanced picture. I am critical to his three theses about ‘polarisation’, ‘exclusion’ and the ‘brutalisation of work’. These concepts are not clearly theoretically defined. Is polarisation the same as widening differences within health, education and work? I think not. A good example of polarisation would be the accumulation of wealth taking place in many countries resulting in a concentration of ideological and political power. Besides, the empirical data are mainly from Norway – which for obvious reasons should not be generalised from. Recent studies (not yet published) using a quantitative index of job quality for all twenty-even EU countries, show a rather mixed picture with job quality levels in Europe remaining rather diverse. The decline in measured job quality has in fact been rather small. The alleged crisis is mostly linked to increased incidence of involuntary part-time and fixed-term contracts.
The challenges from a trade union point of view are as follows: fewer and fewer workers are member of trade unions. Besides, organised employees do not vote for left-wing parties. The crisis of the left is thus part of the problem. Right-wing parties have ideological power, with the left-wing parties being hostages for a soft neoliberal policy. It will be a difficult task to turn this tendency and change the balance of power in favour of employees.
His tentative solution is rather vague: the power structure must change in favour of labour through collective action of trade unions in alliance with popular movements across borders. One has to move beyond the welfare state ‘towards social and economic emancipation and a deeper and extended democratization of society’ (p. 65).
I think that the power analysis would have benefited by including the mass-media. They are selling the neo-liberal perspective to the general public, shaping their perceptions, and legitimating attacks on welfare, which is benefiting the interests of the rich and powerful.
In conclusion: a thought-provoking book, with lots of insights, but a somewhat conspiratorial presentation of the power relationship between labour and capital.
