Maria Cristina García has done a great service for migration scholars (especially those of us focusing on Central Americans) and for a much broader readership. Her book traces the history of refugees, primarily of the 1980s, fleeing the political violence in El Salvador, Guatemala and Nicaragua, as they entered three different national contexts of reception: Mexico, the United States and Canada. García's greatest contribution is to place between the covers of one book an intricately detailed and meticulously documented comparative study in the broadest sense of the word – explicitly comparative in the three contexts of reception, and implicitly comparative regarding the three groups of refugees and migrants. She has also ‘connected the dots’, showing, in the case of each of the receiving countries, the relationship between foreign policy toward the Central American wars of the 1980s and domestic policy toward the refugees from those wars.
The three chapters relating these three contexts of reception are studied here in such detail as to make this book a kind of primer. Because García considers Nicaraguans as well as Salvadorans and Guatemalans, the book has, in a sense, two story lines, one for the treatment by each receiving country of those whom it regarded as bona fide refugees (in the United States, for example, those leaving Sandinista Nicaragua, victims of serious persecution), and one for the treatment of the frivolous or non-refugees from Guatemala and El Salvador, who were presumed to be aligned with the leftist insurgencies against solid pro-US governments. Although this view was primarily that of the US government, it influenced the two neighbouring governments in various ways. The book also does an excellent job of showing the role of non-governmental actors, including NGOs and religious organisations, in pressuring the governments involved, none of which come out looking very solidly committed to pro-refugee or pro-immigrant principles.
The best-known story for readers in the United States and elsewhere is precisely the story of how each group was treated by the US government. I use the word ‘story’ deliberately, to convey the readability of this book. Since it is not weighed down by jargon, it is accessible reading to non-experts as well as scholars of migration and refugee rights. Even in the chapter on the United States, however, García has added something unusual: her case study about the contradictory treatment of Nicaraguans there is a refreshing addition, as the vast bulk of previous literature has focused only on US policies toward Salvadorans, both Salvadorans and Guatemalans, or Guatemalan Maya refugees.
Much less has been written in the English language about the intricacies of Mexican and Canadian refugee policies. The chapter on Mexico as the presumptive ‘country of first asylum’ provides an in-depth look at why Mexico has not, in fact, served in that function, with the exception of the United Nations refugee camps in southern Mexico that provided refuge to around 50,000 Guatemalans in the early 1980s (primarily Mayas fleeing the army's scorched-earth counterinsurgency campaign that cost the lives of over 150,000 unarmed civilians just between 1981 and 1983). Even in this case, Mexican policies were endlessly convoluted, as García demonstrates. Similarly, the chapter on Canada is a fascinating exploration and portrayal of internal/external pressures and compromises.
Precisely because the chapter on Mexico adds so much, it does suffer from García's rather selective inclusion of the very rich body of literature, primarily in Spanish, by experts based in Mexico and Central America, some of whom have been studying Mexican policy toward Central American migration for at least two decades. Examples of such experts are Manuel Angel Castillo of the Colegio de México, and Rodolfo Casillas of FLACSO/México (and more recently, focusing on the Mexico/Guatemala border, for example, work by Olivia Ruíz, Aura Marina Arriola and Silvia Irene Palma in Guatemala). Readers familiar with the situation in Mexico can attest to the importance, indeed, the centrality, of these studies by Mexican and Central American experts. These authors add factual material (as they have access to resources not available to scholars based in North America); but even more importantly, they contribute a very different perspective on issues of migration and development, Mexican refugee and migration policy, and the ever-contradictory roles of Mexico in the region. We live in an era when ‘North-South’ collaboration on migration in the Americas is a necessity.
García's book is regional in scope, as it covers not only the three major sending countries and the three major receiving (or transit) countries, but also, although in less detail, the role of the other Central American countries (Honduras, Costa Rica, Belize, Panama). Despite this major contribution, the regional scope of the book does not translate into a regional analysis. Even the brief conclusion, which brings readers up to date to the early 2000s, is more descriptive than analytical. García herself mentions (p. 8) the need to craft a regional response to the problems of refugees and immigrants, particularly in the era since 9/11. However, she could have given more attention to key non-governmental actors such as Sin Fronteras in Mexico and the region-wide Red Regional de Organizaciones Civiles para las Migraciones which are now focused on doing just that, on a daily basis.
Finally, Central America(n) specialists will find in the introductory chapter some factual and interpretative details to challenge, since García relies on secondary sources to describe the events that gave rise to the massive stream of refugees and the response in the United States. To cite just one example, her discussion in the introductory chapter of the Sandinistas in power in Nicaragua and the Central American Peace Accords signed in Guatemala City in August 1987 implies that the Sandinistas held their first free and fair election in 1990. They had in fact done so well before, in 1984, and those elections had been recognised as free and fair by virtually all international observers, governmental or otherwise, except the Reagan administration. This particular error of omission is not surprising, given that the history of Sandinista Nicaragua in the 1980s has been re-written (or more precisely, distorted) more than perhaps any other case in recent Latin American history, Cuba included. This chapter contains other such examples that are common among authors who did not witness those events (and some who did).
But such details by no means distort the overall picture, nor do they negate the enormous contribution of this book. Both academic readers and the general public, should be grateful to Maria Cristina García for venturing on to regional territory and painting a variegated picture of a central saga in recent refugee history.
