One of the fastest growing fields of Ottoman history over the last generation has been urban history. Ebru Boyar and Kate Fleet have offered a colorful contribution to this historiography with a social history of Istanbul, the Ottoman capital, covering the entire period from the Ottoman conquest of the city until the demise of the empire after World War I (1453–1923). The authors make a somewhat unusual choice in telling their history from the direct and mostly unmediated perspective of Ottoman and European literary sources: chronicles, travel accounts, memoirs, biographies, and poetry. This strategy of giving free rein to contemporary observers carries its own mixture of opportunities and risks that can make this study entertaining and rewarding and yet somewhat difficult to follow and interpret, particularly for readers who are unfamiliar with the byways of Ottoman history.
The book has a rather idiosyncratic structure insofar as there is no central thesis or argument. It consists mainly of an eclectic series of snapshots from Istanbul life in streets, markets, gardens, and neighborhoods. A condensed timeline of Ottoman political history (Chap. 1) leads into a long discussion of the relationship between the Ottoman court and the urban population (Chap. 2). The authors recount imperial ceremony and pageantry, the organization of official prayers and celebrations, and the pressure that the people of the capital could bring to bear on the state and its monarch. The book then shifts (Chap. 3) to a history of attitudes toward violence, death, and insecurity. Readers learn about natural and man-made hazards like plagues and fires, episodes of political and social upheaval, and measures taken by the state and local neighborhoods to maintain order.
Subsequent chapters look more closely at patterns of social interaction. The authors highlight (Chap. 4) religious foundations (vakıf) and key mechanisms of charity and welfare and explore the many forms that these arrangements took in the life of the city. They emphasize that, as the imperial capital, Istanbul benefited from an unusually large number of these endowments. Its status as capital also ensured, as they observe in Chapter 5, that it had a massive appetite, requiring constant provisioning from a state nervous about law and order, and that it possessed the empire's most sophisticated consumer culture, subject to an endless string of decrees and regulations. Receiving their own separate sections are the craze for gardens (Chap. 6) and the culture of the bathhouses (Chap. 7).
The authors have managed to comb through a substantial collection of fascinating literary and historical sources stretching from the 15th to the 20th centuries. All of these different voices bring the city alive and infuse it with the vividness of personal experience. The resulting narrative is fun and engaging and brims with striking color and anecdote on nearly every page. These voices, of course, do not represent a cross section of Istanbul society. With few exceptions, they belong to Istanbul's voluble (Turcophone) literati or to European travelers—that is, to observers from relatively affluent and privileged social circles. A very helpful list at the beginning of the book identifies most of these primary sources, but throughout much of the text the reader hears little about their social prejudices related to class, origin, and education. A more self-conscious handling of these prickly and opinionated witnesses—who, by turns, were fond of speaking on behalf of the entire city or passing judgment on it—would have further corrected for the eagerness of chroniclers and travelers to fasten on eye-popping and spectacular reports. As a consequence, the book is susceptible to distortions of perspective. Following the primary sources, one section presents Istanbul in somewhat lurid shades as “a violent city where life was precarious and death lurked just around the corner,” most evidently in the earthquakes, storms, fires, and riots, which were the standard fare of chronicles and travelogues (p. 72). Receiving far less space are the microbes, rudimentary medical care, and unsanitary living conditions that routinely claimed far more lives. In the dramatic scenes that contemporaries favored, and that the book delights in repeating, the pedestrian realities of markets and backstreets, which were more representative of everyday social experience, tend to recede into the background.
The very wealth of episodic detail that the authors marshal from their sources tends to mask underlying social trends. Only Chapter 8, dealing with the disruptions unleashed by modernity in the 19th century, confines itself to a specific period with its own historical characteristics. In contrast, early modern social transformations, which were no less significant in their own right, receive spotty coverage. To take two examples: the state's concern with sartorial laws and the popularity of new consumer goods like tobacco (among other early modern controversies) appear without much probing of their timing or origin. The unwary reader can too easily get the impression of a “traditional” society prone to sudden convulsions and disturbances that came and went according to their own mysterious logic.
These historiographical lapses are dismaying because the book contains important observations and helps to deflate pernicious stereotypes about Ottoman society. It shows how Muslims and non-Muslims partook of the same urban culture as their neighbors and had more or less the same tastes and habits. Countering one of the most enduring stereotypes about Ottoman society, it emphasizes the visibility of women, Muslim and non-Muslim, who ventured regularly into public space. At other moments, the narrative slyly underlines the futility of many economic and religious regulations promulgated by the state, even in the capital itself.
Readers of this book will come away with a tour of Ottoman Istanbul that is interesting, far ranging, and full of arresting detail. But the very primary materials that furnish all this charm and immediacy can, when allowed to speak too freely and directly, inadvertently obscure the social history of the city over the long term. In spite of their success and thoroughness in gathering such an impressive body of firsthand evidence, the authors never manage to address key questions about methodology, organization, and interpretation that loom throughout their study.
