In this award-winning book, Sarah Igo offers a genealogy of the current ubiquity of quantitative information about every facet of daily life. From consumer preference to sexual desire to political inclination, our innermost thoughts, feelings and tendencies have been rendered collective and public through various quantitative techniques. Today the American political process and news media are saturated with these aggregated opinions. Igo highlights the comparative recentness of the high visibility of such measurements, dating their proliferation to the mid-1930s. Ranging across the history of numerous social-scientific disciplines, she seeks to understand how the growing public profile of these fields altered the very self-understanding of ordinary Americans. Her approach can best be described as historical ontology from below as she analyses the social surveyors' tools for constructing the ‘typical’ individual alongside the responses of those measured. Central to her argument about the importance of the social sciences in the remaking of American culture at mid-century is the extended exploration of the agency of those observed as they grappled with what it meant to belong to a national, statistical community rather than the one formerly defined by locality.
She advances her examination of the circulation of statistical knowledge through the American polity with three thoughtfully selected case studies: Robert S. and Helen Lynd's Middletown (1929), the rise of opinion polling championed by George Gallup and Elmo Roper, and the sex surveys led by Alfred C. Kinsey. Rather than offer a complete history of the social survey, she sticks closely to her cases, although, as the narrative progresses, she makes insightful comparisons among her differing survey traditions and situates them well in their intellectual matrices. Where nineteenth-century social surveys focused almost exclusively on populations defined in terms of the social problems they posed, these later examples self-consciously pursued the representative. Starting as a Rockefeller-funded study of religious affiliation in the small, industrial city of Muncie, Indiana, the Lynds' ethnography of the daily habits of a supposedly ‘typical’ town became a surprise best-seller. In an era still marked by ethnic divisions, Middletown seemed to offer a reassuring vision of American unity and stability, even though the study's authors had intended a subtle critique of consumer capitalism. The rapid growth of scientific polling following the successful prediction of the 1936 election built upon people's hunger to situate themselves in relation to the majority. These precedents help contextualize the approach adopted by Kinsey in his sex surveys. His brand of sex research captured the tension between the worries about the kinds of information people were willing to share with social scientists and the fascination of locating oneself along an anonymous spectrum of normality. All contributed to the calling into being of the notion that the United States was best characterized by its undifferentiated, mass culture.
Each case is analysed in two chapters, the first dedicated to the ways of knowing developed by the surveyors and the second tracing the consumption of what they produced and the criticisms levelled against them. To understand the average person, each group of scientists adopted different means of observing and recording human thoughts and behaviour. Igo contrasts the anecdotal Lynds, the quantitative Gallup and the empathetic Kinsey. To accomplish the task of demonstrating how people grow into the categories of the human sciences, she skilfully probes book reviews, editorials and, most importantly, letters sent to the scientists by readers of their work. These sources reveal how people's self-understanding – their conceptions of themselves both as individuals and as part of a collectivity – was redefined through the encounter with the surveys' statistical technologies.
She dedicates much of her analysis to the debates over observing and publicizing private affairs and the question of how representative the samples were. Alongside the new definitions of a statistically constituted mass public, the social sciences transformed the contours of the private realm and its accessibility. While some complained about the propriety of these revelations, others objected that those they knew had been excluded from the aggregate. Albeit often for different reasons, all the surveyors downplayed ethnic diversity in their definitions of the typical. Heralded as the typical town, Muncie was originally selected precisely because its rather unusual ethnic homogeneity for a city of its size made for a simpler study. Opinion pollsters reaffirmed rather than challenged the political status quo, ignoring African American voices because Jim Crow laws largely guaranteed that they would have little voice at the ballot box. Often made on pragmatic grounds, these choices collectively reified a racialized vision of the American norm.
The Averaged American represents the state of the art for the history of the human sciences and deserves a wide readership within the larger history-of-science community. Some readers may wish that Igo had delved more deeply into the technical history of statistical analysis as a means of unpacking the norm as it operated in these sciences. The pitched battle between Kinsey and the American Statistical Association over sampling method, for example, gets a brief mention rather than extended discussion. Overall, though, Igo demonstrates how well attention to reception and social contexts can be combined with investigations into, in Andrew Pickering's phrase, the mangle of scientific practices. While the creation of statistical persons through the avalanche of large numbers has been fruitfully explored by Theodore Porter, Ian Hacking and others, never before have the negotiations that go into actually making people up been so elegantly examined. Igo's book is rich with the testimony of those who consumed social-scientific information and whose self-understanding was altered in the encounter. The result is a seamless integration of the sciences' ways of knowing into broader historical narratives about mid-twentieth-century social life. Not only an excellent model for contextualist histories of science, it is also a major contribution to American cultural history.
