Peter Kirby would agree that children working in factories in Britain during the early Industrial Revolution faced unhealthy conditions and often cruel treatment by adults. However, he would be quick to point out that most children in industrial towns in Britain during this period faced unhealthy conditions and often cruel treatment by adults. In this slender and provocative monograph, Kirby provides a reassessment of the impact of industrial work on children's health between 1780 and 1850, placing his analysis within the broader social and economic context in which these children lived. Kirby assembles evidence from a broad range of sources and interprets it through the lens of modern occupational medicine. He concludes that the health and well-being of working children were more profoundly affected by their household circumstances and the urban disease environment than by the conditions they encountered in the workplace.
Kirby's thesis will be startling to readers familiar with the grim picture of industrial child labor presented by earlier generations of historians. Much of this earlier work drew heavily on the testimony of medical “experts” to Parliamentary committees in the early1800s. These experts claimed that working in confined spaces and engaging in repetitive motions led to poor health, stunted growth, and deformities. Kirby characterizes these claims as “theoretical medical opinion” (p. 152). Many of these medical experts had never visited a factory or practiced medicine in an industrial community. Kirby contends that much of the testimony to these committees, including that of former child workers, was politically motivated. Proponents of shorter work hours and restrictions on the use of child labor secured witnesses who would provide testimony promoting these agendas.
Kirby accepts that many child laborers suffered from poor health and disabilities, but he argues that the causes of these conditions were often external to the factory. Kirby claims that the main threat to working children's health during this period was poverty. Working class households were unhealthy places as evidenced by their high rates of infant and early childhood mortality. The children who survived to working age often carried the scars of malnutrition and childhood disease. Many of the deformities observed in factory workers were the legacies of past illnesses or even congenital conditions which were not well understood at the time. Disabled children may have even been overrepresented in mill work because it was less physically demanding than work in domestic industry and agriculture (p. 77).
Mortality and morbidity data for the period before 1850 are scarce. Kirby relies primarily on qualitative accounts of workers’ health found in the testimonies of doctors who practiced in industrial districts and the results of surveys of industrial workers conducted as part of Parliamentary investigations. Kirby provides quantitative evidence on child health by exploiting data on children's heights collected by government commissions in the 1830s and 1840s. He finds that the real threat to a child's growth during this period was living in an urban area. By age 14, children in large towns were substantially shorter than children in rural districts and small towns (p. 112). The height data further show no stunting of children working in factories relative to children working in other occupations (p. 121). Kirby is careful to point out, however, the selection issues that complicate the use of stature data to assess the health impact of different occupations (pp. 122–3).
Kirby acknowledges that some industrial workplaces posed dangers for children. An important theme throughout the book is that the experiences of child workers varied across industries and establishments. The height data, for instance, reveal that children working in mines were severely stunted relative to children in other occupations. Drawing on modern medical knowledge, Kirby conjectures that this resulted from soft bones caused by lack of exposure to ultraviolet light and the repeated strain of pushing and pulling coal trolleys (p. 120). Kirby also details the plight of pauper children bound out to textile mills. Without the support of family, these children were the most vulnerable to abuse. However, by 1820, pauper apprentices accounted for a small fraction of industrial child labor (p. 27).
Kirby believes that the most significant workplace threat to children's health was industrial accidents. Newspapers provided gruesome accounts of children being pulled into and mangled by machinery. These accidents often led to death or permanent disability. Unfortunately, the regular reporting of workplace accidents did not begin until the Factory Act of 1844. During the first six months the Act was in force, 996 accidents were reported in Lancashire and Yorkshire alone (p. 98). The accident rates were likely even higher 30 or 40 years earlier. Kirby expresses dismay that for all the discussion in the early 1800s of the ill effects of child labor, little attention was paid to the injuries and deaths of child workers due to accidents in the workplace.
Kirby brings a modern perspective to an old debate. Many readers, though, will want to push this research agenda further. Modern occupational medicine could provide insight into a number of questions yet unanswered. For instance, what were the long-run effects of industrial labor on children's social and physical development? What were the functional consequences of the height deficits of urban workers? How did these deficits affect the life-time earnings of these workers and, more generally, the productivity of the labor force? In the concluding chapter, Kirby calls for social historians to develop new methods for studying the connections between the industrial workplace and child development. Kirby's book challenges the traditional view of industrial child labor and establishes a research agenda for the future.
