“An incredible opportunity to hear speakers, read articles, and engage in a diverse range of discussions prior to actually working on the Hill. Great background and fun mid-career opportunity to ‘think’ about government.”
—Marja Verloop, Foreign Service Officer and 2008–09 APSA Congressional FellowLast fall, we had the opportunity to return to the classroom as students. We were invited by the American Political Science Association to take a course titled Congress and the Making of Foreign Policy at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS) in Washington, D.C. The course, which was taught by professor Charles Stevenson, met twice weekly during September and October, prior to the start of APSA's Congressional Fellowship Program in November. The course was designed to give APSA Congressional Fellows and SAIS students an overview of the role that Congress plays in the foreign policymaking process. Since both of us teach a course on Congress, much of the course was an excellent refresher for us. But it also differed in important ways from the courses we teach at our respective schools. It is these differences that deepened our understanding of Congress and the foreign policymaking process and provided an important introduction to our work as APSA fellows on Capitol Hill.
The course covered a wide range of traditional topics including Congress's constitutional underpinnings and institutional evolution, campaigns and elections, the committee system, the perennial struggle to balance competing interests, the budget process, executive-legislative relations, and congressional reform efforts. Broad-brushed though it was, there were plenty of opportunities for in-depth discussions on many of these topics. Many of the readings on the syllabus were familiar to us including Roger Davidson and Walter Oleszek's Congress and Its Members (2008) and Lawrence Dodd and Bruce Oppenheimer's Congress Reconsidered (2007). These books are fundamental to understanding how Congress works and how it has changed, and we use them in our own courses. Stevenson supplemented these with books on foreign policymaking including Rebecca Hersman's Friends and Foes: How Congress and the President Really Make Foreign Policy (Reference Hersman2000) and his own book, Congress at War (2007), both of which provided theoretical and historical context. He also utilized Congressional Research Service reports on specific aspects of foreign policymaking including those on defense authorization and appropriations, the War Powers Resolution, trade policy, foreign aid, and intelligence issues. These reports helped provide the empirical evidence necessary to understand the complexities of foreign policymaking and the relationship between the executive and legislative branches.
While much of the reading material was familiar to us, the course also differed in four significant ways from traditional Congress classes. The most interesting difference was the weekly working-lunch speaker's series held prior to class on Tuesdays. Stevenson invited a variety of experts from the D.C. policy community whose discussions often complemented the subsequent class topic. Speakers included practitioners like a House member's chief of staff, a campaign manager, an OMB budget analyst, a lobbyist, authorizing and appropriating committee staffers, and a trade expert. Speakers also included academics such as Chris Deering, an expert on committees in Congress and a former APSA Congressional Fellow. Exceptionally knowledgeable and candid, all the guest speakers provided a delightfully painless way to get up to date on a wide range of issues having to do with the norms of congressional policymaking and procedures. The discussions provided lots of humorous, real-world anecdotes to illustrate complicated concepts in student-friendly ways.
One funny but true story concerned a campaign worker in Louisiana, who learned first hand how little many voters know about candidates running in elections. The worker called up an elderly constituent and asked her if she was planning to vote for incumbent Democratic senator Mary Landrieu or her Republican Senate opponent, Louisiana state treasurer John Kennedy. The woman replied, “Darling, John Kennedy is dead. He was assassinated.” The diplomatic campaign worker said nothing and simply wrote down that the voter was a “likely Landrieu supporter.” The story illustrates the daunting task that challengers face in unseating incumbent members of Congress. Many voters pay little attention to politics, or have limited information about congressional races, despite the increase in blogs, Internet sites, and cable television stations.
The second major difference between our traditional classes and this class was the type of student in the classroom and the level of discussion it allowed us to have. The class was comprised of 10 APSA Congressional Fellows and five SAIS students. In addition to us, the fellows included three from the State Department, three from the Central Intelligence Agency, one from the Thai Foreign Ministry, and a journalist from Congressional Quarterly. The SAIS graduate students had professional experience working for politicians or lobbying groups including the American Chamber of Commerce. Two were from the Japanese Foreign Ministry. Hence, all the students were professionals in their own right.
The interaction with fellows from the federal government was particularly enlightening. Several of the executive branch fellows have worked for over a decade in their departments or agencies. One was able to share with us his experiences in the Situation Room of the White House. Another, who had worked for the deputy secretary of state, was able to provide insight into the crisis in Darfur. Those with experience in the Intelligence Community were able to explain the composition of the community and the role of Congress in overseeing it.
Several were able to share specific experiences that helped illustrate theoretical points about legislative-executive branch interactions and foreign policymaking. One particularly good example of the fact that a “fractured, issue-based approach to foreign policy can have disastrous consequences, as efforts in one arena tend to have unintended consequences elsewhere” (Hersman Reference Hersman2000, 50) was provided by a State Department fellow. She related a story about the Cuban Medical Professional Parole Program, which was sought by those in government who wanted to encourage Cuban defections to the U.S. The program, which took effect in August 2006 and was not highly publicized, allowed Cuban medical professionals working abroad to walk into the U.S. embassy of their host country and apply for a visa for entry into the United States.
The class was surprised to learn that Cuba has thousands of doctors serving in humanitarian missions in countries around the globe. A large percentage of those doctors provide medical service in Venezuela under President Hugo Chavez's free health care program for the poor. Venezuela has paid for these doctors by providing Cuba with oil. The Cuban Medical Professional Parole Program was designed to try to encourage more Cuban defections, particularly from Venezuela, in keeping with the administration's policy to further isolate Cuba and embarrass Venezuela.
The program was promoted by the Department of Homeland Security without apparent coordination with the State Department, and the program had much wider effects than promoting defections of Cuban medical personnel from Venezuela. U.S. Congress members with large numbers of Cubans in their districts, such as Rep. Lincoln Diaz-Balart (R-Miami), helped spread the word about the program. Word of it has reached rural areas worldwide to include African countries like Namibia and South Africa, which have large numbers of Cuban doctors.
The State Department fellow, who was stationed in Namibia at the time this program was announced, said that one day, a number of Cuban doctors showed up at the American embassy asking for a visa to the U.S. Not only were the embassy officials unaware of the program, but the loss of medical personnel in places like Namibia posed problems for U.S. policy. The U.S. has invested millions of dollars in Namibia for HIV/AIDS and many of those patients rely on Cuban doctors for treatment. Thus, the case illustrated in a clear way that fractured policymaking can have far-reaching implications and may even go so far as undermining other priorities that the government holds.
A third difference between this class and the ones we teach is that here we were the students. Being a student reminded us of the importance of hands-on learning and simulations. Prof. Stevenson was adept at creating these exercises, drawing on his intimate knowledge of the policy process and his professional experience working on Capitol Hill. These simulations illustrated that there is no such thing as a “simple” decision in the Congress and also just how versatile simulations can be.
One particularly interesting simulation illustrated the difficulties in staffing a Hill office, a member's first challenge once elected. Students were given an $831,000 budget and instructed to staff a congressional D.C. and district office with no more than 18 staff members between the two. The highest salary could be $158,000. We had to determine how many people would be hired, what their positions and responsibilities would be, how much each would be paid, how many would serve in Washington and how many in the district, and the qualifications for each position. Determining salaries was particularly difficult because it required balancing the need for expertise and experience with the budgetary caps set by each chamber. Moreover, salaries of congressional staff members are public, and hence, the legislator has to consider how this will affect staff morale.
In another exercise, students had to create a generic weekly calendar for a House member. This included meetings with committees, party leadership, lobbyists, and constituencies; votes on the House floor; political fundraising events; and family time. After completing the exercise, we realized how few of us would want the schedule that an average Congress member has!
In a third, and very different exercise, Prof. Stevenson gave us a set of amendments and asked us to decide as a group how we would vote on each amendment. One group of students had to imagine themselves as a Democratic House member; the second group as a Republican House member. One of the amendments would have required the U.S. government to sell air and missile defense weaponry to Taiwan on the same terms and conditions as to NATO members. Students had to balance the conflicting interests of the administration, Chinese government, business community, and interest groups such as the America-Taiwan Friendship Council, while at the same time thinking about the security needs of the country. While both groups voted against the amendment, they had lively discussions as they sought to balance the desires of various actors in the policy process. These hands-on exercises provided insight into the challenges that legislators face in the legislative process.
The fourth, and final, difference was the location of the class in Washington, D.C., which helped bring the political process to life. The class met on Tuesday and Thursday afternoons, so many of the fellows had the rest of the week free. While we were required to do the readings for class and give two short oral presentations, the APSA fellows were not required to take exams or write research papers. This provided some of us with opportunities to go to Senate and House hearings. We were also able to attend lectures and panels on the presidential and congressional elections at places like Brookings, SAIS, the Wilson Center, the Center for American Progress, and the National Press Club. Those activities provided opportunities to talk with academics and commentators whose works we regularly read, including E.J. Dionne, Thomas Mann, James Thurber, Larry Bartels, John Aldrich, and Stephen Wayne.
We also had a front-row seat when the financial meltdown occurred in September and October. We were able to see the variety of pressures brought to bear on members of Congress, and the compromises reached, before the final passage of the financial rescue package. Members of Congress wished to pass legislation addressing the crisis, but they were also concerned about the impact of their vote with the election just weeks away. Staffers kept Hill offices open late to handle the huge increase in mail and phone calls, most reflecting overwhelming opposition to the plan. This led to the initial failure of the bill in the House, which in turn led to some changes in the bill's language, and prompted House leaders to add sweeteners in order to persuade some members to switch their votes. Several examples included tax exemptions on wooden arrow shafts, tax breaks to movie and television production companies, and the ability of plaintiffs in the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill case to average out their punitive damage awards over several years. The final plan underscored the dual nature of Congress, discussed by Davidson and Oleszek in Congress and Its Members, in which members of Congress seek to balance the desires of constituents and the long-term needs of the nation.
In conclusion, participating in this seminar has benefited our teaching in a variety of ways and better prepared us for the challenges we face as Congressional Fellows. It reminded us of the realities faced by policymakers and gave us a host of real-world examples for our lectures. First-rate academics enriched our understanding of topics like the committee process. Simulations provided an interesting and interactive way in which to teach a variety of topics and prompted us to use more of these in our own classes. Fellow students shared enlightening insights from within their own areas of expertise. Class discussions provided us with greater insights into the policymaking process, the motives and incentives of legislators, and the difficulties Congress faces as its members have become more polarized and fragmented. This has encouraged all of us to think about ways of bridging the partisan divide in Congress to enhance the ability of members to address serious national problems. We remain optimistic about Congress because of the dedication and efforts of many of the experts we met and the importance of the institution in the country's system of checks and balances. When we asked fellow students for their evaluation, one said she could not imagine going to work on Capitol Hill without this course. ■
