Maria Holt and Haifaa Jawad's Women, Islam, and Resistance in the Arab World explores the complexity of the lives of Muslim women living in conflict-ridden regions as well as occupied and refugee zones. The authors focus on Shiʿi women in Lebanon, Iraqi women in exile in Jordan and Syria, and Palestinian women in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. The authors give voice to women who are enduring trying circumstances and are difficult to reach and interview.
Holt and Jawad examine women's strategies for resisting violence from outside and patriarchal structures within their own communities; how women do their best to make sense of their fortunes and misfortunes; and the coping mechanisms they develop to deal with brutality and trauma on a daily basis. “The women in our case studies . . . tend to regard themselves, in some respects, as marginalized; however, rather than identifying marginality as ‘a site of deprivation,’ they . . . re-conceptualize it as ‘the site of radical possibility, a space of resistance’” (p. 6). For many of these women, Islam is a source of “psychological empowerment” and “spiritual sustenance” (pp. 118, 180).
The authors’ challenge the notion of Muslim women as perennial victims and provide them a platform from which to express their resistance. Through a discussion of the concepts of power and empowerment, the authors conclude that while men might be the formal holders of power in the contexts under study, women exercise agency and “negotiate violence and patriarchal structures in order to make sense of an otherwise fearful situation” (p. viii). In the midst of the havoc surrounding them, they find direct and indirect strategies to “counter the pressures of conflict” (p. viii), and “their stories raise questions about the meaning of resistance in conflict situations” (p. 2). The women voice a strong sense of pride in their “contribution to the struggle,” with many indicating they have no choice but to be involved (p. 9). According to the authors, the women understand resistance to include not only fighting the “enemy” in the battleground, but also other forms of active involvement. Holt and Jawad point to the trauma of displacement experienced by many of these women and their families when they have to make difficult decisions about whether to support resistance groups in order to protect their families. As the authors describe, “[d]isplacement, especially outside the country, traumatized Iraqi women; for them, home was no longer safe because occupation forces were pursuing them; hence they supported the resistance to regain their lost spaces . . . women were kidnapped, raped, and killed by militias, including government militias . . . Women were also killed randomly during house raids or at checkpoints” (pp. 130–31). Many of these women were professionals in the medical and humanitarian sectors, such as doctors. Trafficking of women in the sex trade, kidnapping, rape, and disappearance were familiar themes in the interviews.
Many of the Iraqi women in exile opposed the 2003 U.S. invasion and “opted for resistance.” As Holt and Jawad state, “most of the women were sympathetic toward, or part of, the resistance movement against the U.S. occupation and subsequent governments, which were established on the basis of collaboration with the U.S. authorities” (p. 4). The authors explain that, “[f]or ordinary Iraqi women, life during the occupation and civil strife involved different forms of struggle: surviving their daily lives, meeting their basic needs (food, water . . . medicine), keeping their families together, and coping with the status quo were all forms of resistance to the mayhem of political and social instabilities” (p. 127). For example, Umm Anas (an Iraqi woman in exile) described the difficult task of caring for her handicapped son. Lack of electricity in the refugee camps made life unbearable, especially in the summer. The mother indicated that she kept her son in a bucket of water all day because “otherwise he would not stop crying.” (p. 127).
The authors then expose the inherent contradictions faced by women as both victims and agents. These women actively search for strategies to deal with their oppression and improve their situation, such as providing cooked meals for frontline units, selling their jewelry to help buy a combat jeep (p. 68), or supporting and encouraging their sons and husbands to join the resistance groups. The women's contribution to the collective is a mechanism for dealing with the conflict while defining their resistance.
The authors conclude that in most cases “the Islamization of the struggle has led to a greater involvement of women in violent conflicts; this happens through personal choice but also through coercion when they have no other alternatives” (p. viii). Women's testimonies suggest that, ironically, their involvement in violent conflicts makes them feel empowered and included, leading some of them to “claim they have been able to expand the spaces in which they feel comfortable operating.” (p. 179). While some women in the study described surviving, protecting, and caring for their families as empowering (p. 81), others saw their participation in the resistance parties (e.g., Hamas and Hizbullah) as the source of their of empowerment. As party members, they attend lectures and discussion groups and are educated about their rights as women in Islam, particularly through the legacy of Fatima (the Prophet Muhammad's daughter, Imam Ali's wife, and one of the most influential female figures in Islamic history).
Overall, the book is engaging, thought provoking, and well written. I have only two minor criticisms. First, while each chapter is rich in theory and detailed information, continuity between chapters is lacking. Second, while the authors describe methods of data collection and the number of respondents for one case (Iraqi women in exile, p. 104), they do not provide them for the other two cases. Nevertheless, the authors have made an invaluable contribution to an area of research that is seriously underrepresented in the literature: women-centered narratives about daily life in conflict-ridden regions as well as occupied and refugee zones. The book provides a deep understanding of gender politics and resistance movements in the Middle East, and will therefore be valuable in advanced undergraduate and graduate level courses.
