Anne Lambright in Andean Truths: Transitional Justice, Ethnicity, and Cultural Production in Post-Shining Path Peru joins other scholars who have turned to artistic works about the conflict that engulfed Peru from 1980 to the mid-1990s. Lambright considers the ways that cultural memory interventions may both reify and weaken exclusionary modes of knowledge production. In her book consisting of seven chapters, in addition to an introduction, Lambright examines specific cultural products grouped by either artist or genre (such as literature, film, drama and visual arts).
Lambright brings together a rich body of diverse artistic sources, some produced during the conflict and others after the transition, by Peruvians mainly from Lima and the Ayacucho region. Unfortunately, timing is not on Lambright's side as many of these works have been discussed in recent publications, yet not enough time has passed for her to take into sufficient consideration some of these other authors’ insights and to build upon them. Specifically, literary scholars Victor Vich’s Poéticas del duelo (Instituto de Estudio Peruanos, 2015) and Margarita Saona’s Memory Matters in Transitional Peru (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014) cover much of the same ground and art, through their focus on both the political ramifications of artistic works and the role of empathy in the production of collective memory.
Where Lambright wishes to carve out new ground (though not entirely absent in other studies) is by focusing on ethnicity and how these cultural productions speak to ethnic tensions of inclusion and exclusion in Peru's divided society. Drawing upon theories of intercultural communication, decolonisation and epistemological diversity (though not gender), Lambright astutely sees cultural products as advancing our understanding beyond the truth-gathering models of transitional justice and the narratives of reconciliation and healing. Perhaps as a means to highlight more boldly what cultural products can offer, Lambright places the Peruvian Truth and Reconciliation Commission (CVR) as a foil. She perceives the CVR as being ‘timid’ with regard to the ethnic or racial dimension of the conflict (p. 17). Her evaluation of the CVR seems at times a bit harsh, and she does not adequately recognise the effort made to facilitate the construction of a more inclusive society or the actual incorporation of subaltern voices into the CVR's process and its final report, and how this report breaks away from traditional state engagement with Peru's Quechua and indigenous populations. Rather, Lambright compares the cultural works in her book and what they tell us about ethnic dynamics in Peru as a means to see how they reproduce or challenge the dominant coloniality of the CVR narrative. That the CVR narrative is contested by ‘dominant’ groups as well is not mentioned here.
The choice of focusing on the ‘coloniality of power’ as wielded by dominant urban-based society, and the role art can play in post-conflict societies is an intellectually worthwhile endeavour. Lambright interweaves throughout her study the themes of violence, memory, language and trauma. For instance, in Chapter 1, Lambright reads closely three novels by Lima-based authors (Alonso Cueto, Santiago Roncagliolo and Iván Thays) whom she sees as reifying national dichotomies in their fiction, and in so doing ‘commit their own sort of violence’ (p. 59). These authors thus fall short of what Lambright considers ethical witnessing: art that works ‘to incite a deliberate, transformed, and solidarious [sic] ethical consciousness’ (p. 59). The film Paloma de Papel (‘Paper Dove’) analysed in Chapter 2 seems to fall into a similar ‘vertical’ trap, something which she sees as having been akin to CVR's ‘paternalistic stance’ that ‘via a vicarious experience of trauma … uses rather than involves indigenous subalterns’ (p. 60). Her critique of these ‘dominant cultural products’ (an important exception is made here for Claudia Llosa's Fausta) is that they ‘do what has so long been done in Peru: show the audience a Westernized, urbanized Peru, virtually untouched by the country's indigenous cultures’ (p. 61).
In the remaining four chapters Lambright shines light on cultural engagements that do otherwise. The argument of how artistic practice may ‘help the nation move towards a more fully democratic post-conflict society’ (pp. 2–3) is most clearly employed in Chapter 4 on the much-studied theatre troupe Yuyachkani, in Chapter 5 on the work of artist and anthropologist Edilberto Jiménez, and in Chapter 6 on the creative entries about the conflict for a contest called Rescate por la memoria (‘Rescuing/Recovering Memory’). Especially in the chapters on works by Andean artists, Lambright sees cultural producers as succeeding where others have failed as ethical witnesses. The last chapter (Chapter 7) seems an odd appendage, for it lists briefly various memory museums that have sprouted in Peru since the end of the CVR's mandate in 2003.
Despite ethnicity and the coloniality of power being the main intellectual threads of Lambright's book, they are not sustained throughout or evenly engaged with in the chapters. Indeed, in the absence of a concluding chapter the reader is left hanging as to how she sees these themes being resolved more broadly across the cultural products examined. As there is very little historical background, this book would be appreciated more by readers already aware of Peru's recent history, and those interested in the intersection of postcolonial theory and artistic practice.
