Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:58:50.954Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Global linear instability analysis of thermal convective flow using the linearized lattice Boltzmann method

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 June 2022

Hao-Kui Jiang
Affiliation:
School of Energy Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, PR China
Kang Luo*
Affiliation:
School of Energy Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, PR China
Zi-Yao Zhang
Affiliation:
School of Energy Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, PR China
Jian Wu
Affiliation:
School of Energy Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, PR China
Hong-Liang Yi*
Affiliation:
School of Energy Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, PR China
*
† Email addresses for correspondence: luokang@hit.edu.cn, yihongliang@hit.edu.cn
† Email addresses for correspondence: luokang@hit.edu.cn, yihongliang@hit.edu.cn

Abstract

Modal global linear stability analysis of thermal convection is performed with the linearized lattice Boltzmann method (LLBM). The onset of Rayleigh–Bénard convection in rectangular cavities with conducting and adiabatic sidewalls and the instability of two-dimensional (2-D) and three-dimensional (3-D) natural convection in cavities are studied. The method of linearizing the local equilibrium probability distribution function that was first proposed by Pérez et al. (Theor. Comp. Fluid Dyn., vol. 31, 2017, pp. 643–664) is extended to solve the coupled linear Navier–Stokes equations together with the linear energy equation in this work. A multiscale analysis is also performed to recover the macroscopic linear Navier–Stokes equations from the discrete lattice Boltzmann equations for both the single and multiple relaxation time models. The present LLBM is implemented in the framework of the Palabos library. It is validated by calculating the linear critical value of 2-D natural convection that the LLBM with the multiple relaxation time model has an error less than 1 % compared with the spectral method. The instability mechanism of the flow is explained by kinetic energy transfer analysis. It is shown that the buoyancy mechanism and inertial mechanism tend to stabilize the Hopf bifurcation of the 2-D natural convection at Pr < 0.08 and Pr > 1, respectively. For 3-D natural convection, subcritical bifurcation of the Hopf type is found for low-Prandtl-number fluids (Pr < 0.1).

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Grid independency test for 2-D natural convection for Pr = 7 and Ra = 5 × 106.

Figure 1

Figure 1.(a) Neutral stability curve of RBC compared with that of Bergé & Dubois (1984). (b) The critical value of the natural convection: Pr = 7 at Rac = 5 588 857; Pr = 0.71 at Rac = 2 109 003.

Figure 2

Table 2.Comparison of critical Rayleigh number Rac for Pr = 0.71 and Pr = 7.0. The results of DNS by SRT and MRT models and linear instability analysis by LLBM are compared with those of Xin & Quéré (2001).

Figure 3

Figure 2.Linear stability criterion Rac versus A for Pr = 0.71 with (a) conducting and (b) adiabatic vertical sidewalls. The numbers m on every branch are the number of convective cells of the eigenfunction.

Figure 4

Figure 3.The patterns of the most unstable mode for (a) adiabatic walls at Ra = 2250, Pr = 0.71 with A = 1.2 and (b–d) conducting walls at Ra = 4000, Pr = 0.71 with A = 1.2, 1.4, 1.6.

Figure 5

Table 3.Energy budget for modal instability of RBC for different values of A with conducting walls. The parameters are Pr = 0.71, Ra = 4000.

Figure 6

Table 4.Energy budget for modal instability of RBC for different values of A with adiabatic walls. The parameters are Pr = 0.71, Ra = 2250.

Figure 7

Figure 4.Time-evolution series for two Prandtl numbers: (a) Pr = 0.71 with Ra = 2.14 × 106 and (b) Pr = 7 with Ra = 5.69 × 106. The enlarged plots of (b) with non-zero IC illustrate (c) the initial developing flow, (d) the multimodel oscillation in the initial development flow and (e) the dominant mode of oscillation at full development.

Figure 8

Figure 5.(a) The linear critical Rayleigh number Rac with Prandtl number Pr compared with the result of Xin & Quéré (2001). The shaded zones represent the symmetry leading mode (S-mode), which are Pr = [0.47,0.61] and Pr = [2.6,8.8], and the other zone represents the anti-symmetry leading mode (A-mode). (b) The critical frequency f represented by the DNS result and linear stability analysis. The numbers (i.e. 3, 4, 5, 6 and 8) represent the number of wave structures.

Figure 9

Figure 6.The spatial distribution of the mean flow and corresponding most unstable mode at (a,d) Ra = 1.54 × 106 and Pr = 0.3; (b,e) Ra = 2.108 × 106 and Pr = 0.71; and (c,f) Ra = 5.573 × 106 and Pr = 7.

Figure 10

Figure 7.(a) The development of the perturbation quantities θ and w at x = 0.11. (b) The phase differences δ between u and θ at Ra = 5.573 × 106 with Pr = 7, Ra = 2.108 × 106 with Pr = 0.71 and Ra=1.54 × 106 with Pr = 0.3 are plotted against the horizontal location at the vertical location, y = 0.5.

Figure 11

Figure 8.(a) Comparison of the critical frequency (eigenvalues) of the LNS result and the critical oscillatory frequency of the DNS result. The red line represents taking the mean flow as the baseflow and the blue line is unstable instantaneous baseflow. (b) The results of increasing rate ωi over Ra at Pr = 0.71 and Ra∈[2 × 106, 6 × 106].

Figure 12

Figure 9.The time evolution of the nonlinear energy analysis at Pr = 0.71 and Ra = 2.2 × 106. (a) First-order terms and (b) second-order terms.

Figure 13

Figure 10.Contributions to the local growth rate of the perturbed kinetic energy through mechanisms of various budget terms at Ra = 2.2 × 106, Pr = 0.71 (red, destabilizing; blue, stabilizing). Asymptotic energy analysis with (a1) dK/dt; (b1) Kb; (c1) Kv. Turbulent energy analysis of the total contributions of the perturbed kinetics with (a2) $\textrm{d}\tilde{K}/\textrm{d}t$; (b2) ${\tilde{K}_b}$; (c2) ${\tilde{K}_v}$. Second-order term with (a3) $\textrm{d}{\tilde{K}_\textrm{2}}/\textrm{d}t$; (b3) ${\tilde{K}_{b\textrm{2}}}$; (c3) ${\tilde{K}_{v\textrm{2}}}$.

Figure 14

Figure 11.(a,b) Contributions to the local growth rate dK/dt of the asymptotic perturbed kinetic energy through mechanisms of various budget terms with Pr: (c) at Ra = 2.108 × 106 and Pr = 0.71; (d,e) at Ra = 5.573 × 106 and Pr = 7.

Figure 15

Table 5.Comparison of Palabos solver, Nek5000 solver and OpenFOAM solver for 3-D natural convection in cubic cavity with Courant number of 0.005 at Pr = 0.71 and Ra = 1 × 105.

Figure 16

Figure 12.Subcritical bifurcation of 3-D natural convection represented by the Nusselt number Nu at A = 1 and Pr = 0.015. Upward-pointing triangles show the continuous increase in Ra, while the downward-pointing triangles present the case of continuous decrease. The blue line represents the one-roll solution, and the red line is the two-roll solution. The dashed line shows the mean Nusselt number of the oscillatory state. Three instability criteria are numerically predicted: Rac1 = 8059, Rac2 = 17 350 and Raf = 3768.

Figure 17

Figure 13.The Q-criterion isosurfaces (a) Q = 0.001 and (b) Q = 0.003 coloured by the y component of the vorticity ranging from −0.2 to 0.2 for the same parameters: A = 1, Pr = 0.015 and Ra = 8000. (c) The Q-criterion isosurface Q = 0.05 coloured by the y component of the vorticity ranging from −0.6 to 0.6 with A = 2, Pr = 0.05 and Ra = 50 000. (d) The isosurfaces θ = 1, −1 of the first unstable mode corresponding to the baseflow of (a).

Figure 18

Figure 14.(a) The neutral instability curve of 3-D natural convection with periodic boundaries in the y direction for Pr = 0.71. The most unstable wavenumber kc is 7.86 with critical Rayleigh number Rac = 1.77 × 106 and critical frequency fc = 0.263. (b) The distribution of the eigenfunction with perturbation temperature at kc = 7.86.

Figure 19

Figure 15.The spatial distribution for the results of DNS, LNS and energy analysis for the same parameters: A = 1, Pr = 0.71 and Ra = 2.44 × 106 (Rac). (a1,a2) The temperature isosurfaces at θ = 0.3 and θ = 0.7 coloured by the velocity magnitude ranging from 0 to 0.4 and the Q-criterion isosurfaces Q = 0.02 coloured by the y component of the vorticity ranging from −0.4 to 0.4, respectively. (a3,c1,c2,c3) Distributions of the energy budgets of dK/dt, Kb, Kv and Kd, respectively. (b1,b2,b3) Three direction views of the isosurfaces at θ = 1 and −1 of the first critical eigenmode.

Figure 20

Figure 16.(a) Energy analysis for Pr = 0.71 with the period boundary and the A = 1 case. (b) Total budget for the kinetic energy along the y direction for Ra = 2.4 × 106 and Pr = 0.71.

Figure 21

Figure 17.(a–c) Time evolution of the perturbation using the FDM, SRT model, regularized LGBK model and the MRT model for 2-D square lid-driven flow at Re = 1000. (d) Eigenvalue calculated for the case of Re = 2000 using the MRT model.

Figure 22

Figure 18.Eigenfunction of the 2-D square lid-driven flow at Re = 1000: (a) ux and (b) uy amplitude functions of the leading mode using the LLBM with MRT model.

Figure 23

Table 6.Lid-driven flow in a 2-D cavity at $Re = 1000$.