In Civil Society Exposed: The Politics of NGOs in Egypt, Maha Abdelrahman makes an important contribution to the literature on NGOs, civil society, and Egypt. Scholars who study the developing world, and those working with (or thinking about working with) NGOs that claim to be spreading democracy, will find her research useful. Based on an analysis of Egypt, Abdelrahman examines whether or not NGOs can be a source of political transformation.
Abdelrahman's literature review does a good job of encapsulating major scholars such as Weber, Skocpol, Marx, Hegel, and Gramsci. She demonstrates how scholars have mistakenly assumed that an increase in activity in civil society will necessarily bring democratization. Abdelrahman goes on to divide the history of NGOs into three time periods (1920–50, 1950–70, and the “neo-liberal age”). Much of Abdelrahman's answer to why NGOs have failed to “bring democratization” rests on the fact that they are not nonpolitical entities but are “necessarily political [so] their work cannot be isolated from the wider political context in which they work” (p. 67).
Using Egypt as a case study, Abdelrahman illustrates this point, beginning with a useful history of Egyptian society. As far back as Muhammad Ali, the state did away with civil-society organizations. Along with Nasser's industrialization and nationalization policies, there was an expansion of state bureaucracy and the growth of a new ruling class. Nasser's regime “used the discourse of nationalism and of building a strong country to silence any independent social force and deny civil society any form of autonomy” (p. 93). Civil Society Exposed describes how in 1964 the Law of Associations gave power to the Ministry of Social Affairs (MOSA), permitting it to regulate the work of NGOs. It still holds that power today.
Abdelrahman's argument is nuanced enough to acknowledge that, although most NGOs in Egypt submit to the “State's rules of the game,” Egypt's civil society reflects how social forces are “struggling for a larger share of political power” (p. 136). Scholars interested in learning more about social forces at work in Egypt will find her analysis useful. She provides good descriptions of a range of NGOs, including businessmen's associations (which have the most influence because of the connections between their members and the state bureaucracy) and Islamic NGOs (which, unlike other nonprofits, have not had to rely on regime-approved funding).
The real strength of Civil Society Exposed lies in the analysis of a sample of sixty diverse NGOs in Egypt. By conducting freeform interviews in villages where respondents did not have to directly comment on the work that NGOs were doing, Abdelrahman found a way of highlighting the disconnect between the needs of these people and the programs pursued by NGOs. In many cases, interviewees expressed interest in a new sewage system while NGOs were offering sewing classes.
Foreign aid is limited in its impact, she argues, because the regime, through the MOSA, controls where it can be used. NGOs have to develop projects that meet both the regime's and the funding agencies' needs with the small amounts of funding they are given. “NGOs in Egypt are tightly controlled by the State, represented by the Ministry of Social Affairs (MOSA), which not only limits the autonomy of NGOs but also undermines the very essence of their identity as ‘non-governmental’…” (p. 120). The book clearly demonstrates that MOSA is used as a way for the regime to extend its power into the NGO sector, thereby demonstrating her conclusion that civil society is in no way free from regime control and, therefore, cannot serve as a field for democratic change.
Although Abdelrahman begins her book by saying, “the boundaries between the domains of State and civil society are not clearly demarcated and are hence in a state of flux” (p. 29), at times she appears to be treating the state as a fixed entity (referring to it with a capital S) and conflating it with MOSA. I am left wondering whether regime power is the same as state power and whether or not other organs of the state are working against MOSA's interests.
In addition, much of Abdelrahman's argument revolves around the fact that existing social stratifications (e.g., class, gender, and other power hierarchies) are reproduced in NGOs, thereby limiting real change. We learn a great deal from her descriptions of these hierarchies—MOSA officials even go so far as to tell Abdelrahman that their relationship with NGOs is one of a “father and his children” (p. 166). Her own research, however, shows that, although progress seems to be limited to upper class women in Cairo, some of society's gender hierarchies are not reproduced in NGOs. She writes, “Women's representation on boards of directors, although not high…is different and more genuine” (p. 165). One concern with the analysis is that she may have overlooked what positive changes have come along with NGO activity, however small those changes might be.
However, these issues do not undermine her main point, that in general NGOs both reflect and reproduce the larger political context in Egypt. Scholars who have naively assumed that “civil society” (because it has become a popular buzzword) can solve the problem of democratization in the developing world should pay close attention to Abdelrahman's argument.
Although Civil Society Exposed contains an extensive bibliography that scholars interested in civil society or Egypt would find useful, the reader would have been better served with a bibliography organized by categories with Arabic-language texts listed separately.
