Understanding Psychoanalysis is a much-needed introductory text that addresses both the dense historical contextualization underpinning psychoanalysis’ genesis as well as the litany of criticism that never ceased tarrying alongside it since its inception. Synthesizing their respective understandings of various moments in the history of psychoanalysis, from both a contemporary and a historical perspective, Sharpe and Faulkner have produced a fecund presentation of the tradition that is ideal for both basic and advanced learning.
Consistent with the ideal for any “introductory” text, no prior knowledge of psychoanalysis is required to aid understanding. However, for those students of psychoanalysis and instructors who are more familiar with the material, it will be most obvious to these individuals how well Sharpe and Faulkner convey the complexity of this tradition (e.g., the of translation of key terms in Freud that are otherwise commonly overlooked (p. 46), Lacan’s concept of the “gaze” (pp. 160-161), Derrida’s sympathies and criticisms of psychoanalysis (pp. 179-180), to name just a few). The authors themselves come well prepared to deliver on all fronts related to psychoanalysis with special interest in the poststructuralist, critical theory, and feminist interpretations. See Sharpe’s article “Psychoanalysis” in Understanding Derrida (2004); Sharpe (Reference Sharpe2002a) on Derrida and Camus; Sharpe (Reference Sharpe2002b) on critical theory and Herbert Marcuse;Boucher et al.’s Traversing the Fantasy: Critical Responses to Slavoj Žižek (2006); as well as Faulkner’s (Reference Faulkner2008) brilliant article on Sarah Kofman and Nietzsche published in “Hypatia.”
After reviewing the literature it is evidently difficult to find such a thorough, well-read introductory text on psychoanalysis under three hundred pages that covers the breadth and substance that Understanding Psychoanalysis achieves. Whether in good company or under derisive criticism, various aspects of psychoanalysis have been usurped by many diverse fields to which the authors allude (p. 173). Many of the texts related to these various fields of study tend to be too narrow in scope and any introduction or background of psychoanalytic theory/history “in general” is either too cursory or biased. See, for example, Karen Kaplan-Solms and Mark Solms (2000), Todd McGowan (Reference McGowan2007), Gabriele Schwab (2007) for a neuropsychoanalytic, film, and poststructuralist interpretation, respectively.
Sharpe and Faulkner begin with the guiding question “What can psychoanalysis have to do with philosophy and other modern movements of thought, if it can have to do with them at all?”(p. 4) Understanding Psychoanalysis is presented in a rather “uncritical” manner concerning its tackling of some of the figures in the tradition only to fulfill the impetus of an introductory text as “primarily exegetical.” However (and this is the first commendable move on behalf of the authors), in their text they have staked a philosophical position with respect to psychoanalysis in general. Readers of this book “can discern an ethical defense of psychoanalysis” (p. 10). Sidestepping the risk of becoming a verbatim text on the history of psychoanalysis, this stance provides for an interesting read.
The main body of the text begins with a thorough introduction to psychoanalysis, taking as its point of departure Freud’s encounter with Anna O under the influence of his mentor Joseph Breuer. As Freud’s corpus can be quite intimidating and difficult to enter Sharpe and Faulkner quickly set a foundation by establishing the difference between the “Pleasure Principle” and the “Reality Principle” (p. 19). This is followed by a development of the resultant effects that the tensions between these phenomena generate with respect to the formation of the Ego, Id, and Super Ego. Rather than sacrifice substance for the sake of the “general picture,” the authors continue on to pursue at considerable depth the distinction between Freud’s two topologies of the formation of the Ego as delimited by his pre- and post-1914 paper “On Narcissism.”
For anyone who has studied Freud for the first time, the terms neurosis and psychosis are sometimes carelessly used interchangeably. The authors do a good job of isolating these as two separate phenomena with the help of two tables in serial arrangement to help understand the etiology, mechanism, and symptoms respectively. Likewise in chapter 2, “Sexuality and Its Vicissitudes,” the authors navigate the dense yet fragile terrain of the Oedipus complex. Through a detailed reading of Freud’s account of the development of infantile sexuality, the authors place the Oedipal phase of development within the context of the other phases of infants’ development (Oral, anal, . . ., latency, and adult). However, and this ought to be help in high esteem, the chapter begins with a critical reading of Freud’s concept of the Drives. The authors make sure the reader does not become lazy by conflating the meaning of “Drive” as Freud meant it, with something more readily familiar to the modern reader: “Instincts.” They point out that “The drives are not the same things as natural instincts, as Strachey’s deceptive translation of Triebe as ‘instincts’ conceals” (p. 46). This is very helpful in understanding the full implications of the infamous Oedipal phase.
Scattered appropriately throughout Part 1 are brief yet rich synopses of important Freudian “case histories”; for example, Little Hans, the Ratman, and the Wolfman. These are placed strategically in order to help the reader understand relevant concepts as they appear in the text. For example, on p.77 there is a schematic diagram of the Wolf Man’s dream that allows the reader to grasp the meaning of the Freudian concepts of Displacement and Condensation and how these work in the Unconscious and in Dreams.
The second part of the text addresses the followers and dissenters of the tradition after Freud, beginning with Melanie Klein and her theory of “Object relations” as it pertains to the sense of Self, or Ego, of the developing child. The authors quickly and effectively introduce Klein’s modus operandi “Play Technique” to show how she analyses the psyches of children in order to discover what she call their “Schizoid positions” and “Depressive positions.” Without getting too entrenched in explaining the technicalities in this review, I do want to make it known that when needed, throughout the remainder of the text the authors include summaries of Freud’s major works and concepts in “Key Point” dialogue boxes intercalated with the running text. This feature shows how subsequent developments in the history of the psychoanalytic tradition are made possible by their relationships to what Freud originally put forth. For example, in the section on Melanie Klein, the authors include a synopsis of Freud’s Mourning and Melancholia to help contextualize and make sense of what Klein is talking about when she emphasizes the importance of the “Depressive phase” (pp. 86-8).
Jacques Lacan is the second of “Freud’s Children” whom the authors examine. Anyone who has had any experience with Lacan knows that he is, as the authors admit in a refreshingly humble tone, “notoriously difficult.” Nonetheless, his contribution to the tradition is done considerable justice. By emphasizing Lacan’s contribution to the tradition as being indebted to the structural linguistics of his time (for example: Saussure and Jakobsen), the authors make clear his strong opposition to Ego psychology. By carefully walking through Lacan’s seminal article on “The Mirror Stage” and introducing and explaining what Lacan means by his rather esoteric “Imaginary,” “Real,” and “Symbolic” (p. 111), the authors break through Lacan’s tendency to remain internal to his own cryptic nebulous terminology. Personally, my favourite part of this book is the absolutely excellent way “Jouissance,” “the object petit a,” and “Fantasy” are explained on pages 113-114. From reading this book, “S ◊ a” (the structure of fantasy) becomes remarkably clear and easy to understand.
Turning to the chapter on feminism’s relationship to psychoanalysis, I admire the authors’ pointing out that “given feminism’s fraught relation to psychoanalysis, it is perhaps surprising that many of the early adherents and practitioners of psychoanalysis were women”(p. 127). This is essential to introduce to newcomers to the field who have passively received the view that “Feminists are anti-psychoanalytic!” The chapter begins with Freud’s posing of “the question of femininity,” the basis from which the majority of feminist writers depart. Penis Envy is introduced but not dwelled upon to any great extent, as the authors are conscious of not wanting to let this one popular topic dominate the discourse. This introduction leads into a survey of all three “waves” of feminism, beginning with Helen Deutsch and moving through the existentialist criticism of psychoanalysis from Simone de Beauvoir then culminating in a tripartite delivery from the “French Feminist” front represented by engaging exegetical presentations of Julia Kristeva, Luce Irigaray, and Sarah Kofman. After digressing into a short summary of the “Dora” case study to explain the concept and problematization of “Hysteria” as it was regarded in Freud’s time, the authors spend considerable time discussing the feminist criticisms of and engagement with Lacan (over and above Freud), showing how the feminists engage with the tradition’s relationship to symbolic structure and linguistics, among other topics.
The final two chapters of the book, “Civilization, Art, and Religion” and “Science, Society, and Ethics” are where the authors bring together all the history they have covered in order to substantiate the claim they staked in the introduction; that is, their “ethical defense” of psychoanalysis. “Psychoanalytic practice has declined. . . . Psychoanalytic theory, meanwhile, has largely migrated into the film and cultural studies departments in universities (Chapter 7). Here stripped of its clinical clothing, it competes with other philosophical and interpretive theories of ‘discourse’ or ‘representation’ ”(p. 173). We cannot escape the influence (positive or negative) psychoanalysis has had on culture and as such have to face it and find ways of living in its wake.
This final section begins by articulating the process of “Sublimation” and how artists channel their Drives into great works of art (architecture, for example). The fact that for Freud this mechanism is essential for the development and propagation of higher forms of culture and society as well as the fact that it pertains to men exclusively are touched upon since, according to Freud, women are not subject to castration anxiety and as a result do not participate in culture. Elaborating on the Freudian notion that all higher forms of culture are born out of dissatisfaction and personal pain, the authors briefly discuss the Freudian “Uncanny” before proceeding on to a discussion about the “Gaze” in Lacanian film/aesthetic theory. Considering Professor Sharpe’s experience studying Žižek, an interesting example from a text by Žižek that looks at the composition of Holbein’s Ambassadors of 1533 is used here to help flesh out the details. Bringing this chapter to a close is a discussion of both of Freud’s accounts of the origins of western religion as realized in monotheism. This is accomplished by analyzing Freud’s “The Future of an Illusion” (1927) and “Civilization and Its Discontents” (1930) alongside “Totem and Taboo” (1913), and the conclusions Freud draws are interlaced with engaging criticisms from Paul Ricoeur.
At this point the authors move into the final chapter wherein the reader finds, amongst other areas addressed, a rather exciting and entertaining dialectical intertwining of Freudian and Lacanian psychoanalyses with the poststructuralism of French philosopher Gilles Deleuze and “antipsychiatry” psychoanalyst Félix Guattari. Deleuze and Guattari focus on the “positive” productions that Desire produces within psychoanalytic theory, rather than dwelling upon the concept of Negation as Freud and Lacan do. Deleuze and Guattari try to show in their work that “there is no transcendent ‘outside’ ” (p. 184) such as the traditional Freudian “Unconscious” or Lacanian “Real” might serve as. “Desire,” according to Deleuze and Guattari, “creates ‘reality’ . . . and not only representations (fantasies)”(ibid.) that would serve to “fill” the lack left by the moment of castration (Negation) or the “Mirror Stage” (Lacan). But (and here I commend the authors for defending psychoanalysis against the powerful arsenal of poststructuralism) the authors reference a text by Žižek in which the authors endorse the belief they have that “Deleuze and Guattari arguably oversimplify the part of fantasy within psychoanalytic theory” for “fantasy . . . provides the means by which reality can appear for us, phenomenologically”(ibid.). This objection to the poststructuralist criticism not to write with “General Freud” leads the authors to declare their ethical stance with respect to psychoanalysis in modern thought in the conclusion. Psychoanalysis can be used, and maybe ought to be used, as a model for “reflectively coming to terms with this [our] finitude – and making this achievement the basis of an ethical life” (p. 196; some editing).
Everything considered, Understanding Psychoanalysis is by far one of the best sources for both undergraduate as well as graduate students wanting to learn about psychoanalysis, whether that be for the purpose of pursuing film studies, feminism, or linguistics. Appended with a “Chronology of Life and Events”(pp. 197-199) as well as stimulating “Questions for Discussion and Revision” (pp. 200-204) and a substantial “Guide to Further Reading,” this is a teaching resource that no one in the field can afford to pass up.
