On October 12 to 14, 2006, Willamette University hosted an international conference, “Cultural Heritage Issues: The Legacy of Conquest, Colonization and Commerce.” Some 30 distinguished panelists addressed five themes: the legacy of indigenous conquest, the legacy of international conquest and colonization, the legacy of commerce, avoidance and resolution of cultural heritage disputes, and issues related directly to museums and sites. Papers drew on the panelists' expertise in a broad range of disciplines, from archaeology to law enforcement. Topics included, for example, Repatriation of First Nations' Material Culture in Canada, the UNESCO Convention on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage, Recovery of Art Looted During the Holocaust, and The Effect of Colonization on the Cultural Property of Libya.
Two evening lectures explored, respectively, the ownership of culture from a philosophical perspective (Kwame Anthony Appiah) and the recovery of objects stolen from the Iraq National Museum (Matthew Bogdanos). On the final day the luncheon speaker, Richard M. Leventhal, presented a lively exchange with another museum director whose videotaped remarks were projected on a screen. The constructed dialog centered on the responsibilities of museums to preserve both objects and their archaeological contexts, as well as the ethical implications of museum acquisitions whose origins lie in colonized, war-torn or impoverished source countries.
Breakout discussion groups considered the following topics in light of the prin-cipal themes: Toi Iho, Copyright Protection for Maori art; the Amber Room; the Dead Sea Scrolls; the R.M.S. Titanic; the Elgin Marbles; and the Restitution of a Holocaust-related Matisse from the Seattle Art Museum. These more informal sessions supplemented the speakers in accomplishing the overall purposes of the conference: to generate fresh ideas; offer a good sense of the nuances and complexities of cultural heritage issues; and reveal how culture, law, and ethics can interact, complement, diverge, and contradict one another. The program was deliberately structured to enhance productive discussion and avoid the crude dichotomies, such as “cultural nationalism” versus “cultural internationalism,” that have inhibited collaborative dispute resolution and progressive development of norms and law.
Conference papers will be edited by the undersigned for publication in 2008 by E. J. Brill (Brill Academic Publishers) under the imprint of Martinus Nijhoff. Four of the papers, on the topic of avoiding and resolving disputes related to cultural heritage issues, will be published as a symposium issue of the Willamette Journal of International Law and Dispute Resolution. The conference was organized with the active support of the Archaeological Institute of America and its Salem Society, as well as contributions from numerous national and international benefactors.
