This is an extremely engaging book which challenges many assumptions that are taken for granted around begging, gender and childhoods in Ecuador. It is presented in a lively manner, using rich examples and providing a clear overview of begging as a livelihood strategy. It is based on in-depth fieldwork conducted over 19 months at multiple sites (Quito, Guayaquil and Calhuasi), which included over 125 interviews with women, children, politicians, community leaders, teachers, police officers and other relevant stakeholders.
The book outlines many key changes which face a new generation of young people in Ecuador, including the development of a new road to Calhuasi in 1992, which has led to increased levels of rural-to-urban migration for both work and education, as well as changing constructions of childhoods, gender and sexuality. Swanson highlights many benefits that the new road has brought to rural Calhuasi, including better access to medical care; more opportunities for cash income generation through both migration and the ability to take agricultural goods to markets; better communication; and access to consumer goods. Paradoxically, even though the road has increased migration opportunities for women, the greater access to the outside world has also contributed to growing gender inequality within their community. Furthermore, it has led to an array of intergenerational changes in identities, culture and patterns of kinship with which many young people are now grappling; these changes include a desire for fewer children and no longer considering agriculture as a future livelihood, the latter also due to the decreasing size of land plots passed through the generations and competition with cheaper imports from Colombia and Peru.
The book usefully provides a range of perspectives on begging, including the issue of mothers ‘renting’ their children to others to use during the begging encounter. Whilst social workers, urban planners and religious leaders interviewed criticised them for bad parenting, exploiting their children and manipulating the public, the mothers themselves argued that it was ‘a practice integrally connected to notions of redistribution, reciprocity, kinship and skill building’ (p. 83). This is one of several moments in the book where Swanson demonstrates how (often westernised) discourses, such as those which construct beggars as lazy, dirty or delinquent, are used inappropriately in this Ecuadorean context. Furthermore, such unhelpful labels lead to a persistent veiling of some of the underlying issues such as extreme poverty, unemployment and agricultural decline. As Swanson illustrates, negative stereotyping can also result in exclusionary or harmful ‘solutions’, such as taking children away from their parents or displacing beggars by cleaning up the streets for the sake of global tourists.
On the whole the book presents quite a positive view of begging as a survival, as well as an accumulation, strategy, and it would have been interesting to hear a little more about those who are less successful or unable to accumulate. It is not totally clear, but is it the case that perhaps no one ‘fails’ as a beggar, even in a highly competitive context on the streets of urban Ecuador? Negative experiences of begging are discussed to some extent, such as traffic accidents, health risks, harassment and the threats of urban clean-up campaigns, yet despite these downsides, Swanson insightfully suggests that these risks are likely to be substantially lower than those that girls would face if they were working as domestic workers behind closed doors.
Whilst the book covers many dimensions including gender, age, generation and ethnicity, I would have liked to have seen a closer look at the dynamics of the begging encounter, such as exploring the nature of the interactions between beggars and those who give (and those who do not). It could have been interesting if Swanson had been able to include some interviews with those who interact with beggars regularly in the streets, such as tourists. Furthermore, although the importance of informal networks for coping with life on the streets is highlighted, more could have been discussed in relation to siblings and birth order. In a majority world context where rural households have up to twelve children, birth order is likely to be extremely important in shaping children's opportunities for education, work and migration.
In this book Swanson emphasises the mismatch between minority world conceptualisations of childhood and indigenous understandings of childhood practices. She illustrates the dangers of imposing minority world discourses onto majority world realities such as neoliberal urban policies, of begging discourses with a hidden morality, and of decontextualised understandings of children's rights. Begging as a Path to Progress will not disappoint, for it pushes the reader to consider multiple perspectives and aspects of begging which unravel myths and reveal racist and sexist attitudes towards indigenous girls and young women in Ecuador.
