A major portion of Jacques Waardenburg's publications has focused on the cultural and historical encounters of Islam and the West, with an insistent critique of any essentialist or monolithic assumptions of those notions. The volume under review adds to that larger body of work. Its announced intention is to focus on “… encounters and interactions that have taken place between Muslim and non-Muslim peoples, between the worlds of Islam and the worlds of other cultures and religions” (p. v). The range of material under consideration is as broad as possible, attending both to the premodern history of the Islamic world and the modern period, including contemporary encounters outside of that world, primarily in Europe. In all this Waardenburg is interested in surveying the historical record and understanding contemporary developments, as well as taking “into account the imaginary dimension that is so rich in Muslim cultures” (p. v). He does break this frame twice. First, in the initial two chapters he presents phenomenologically structured comparative treatments of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Second, in some later chapters he focuses as much on Western and Christian phenomena as he does on Muslim ones. Neither of these is distracting, however.
The book consists of an introduction and nineteen essays, fourteen of them published previously, and three delivered as lectures. As is inevitable with such a collection, there is a level of repetition, duplication, and occasional inconsistency that can frustrate a reader, for example the characterization of Muhammad ʿAbduh's work on Islam and Christianity (p. 121–22 and 205). The richest chapters, 3–7, deal respectively with the religious context of the rise of Islam, dialogues, polemics, and the study of religion by Muslim scholars in both the premodern and modern periods. These chapters show Waardenburg at his best, carefully assembling and illuminating a wide range of scholarship on these issues.
The remaining chapters deal primarily with the modern period. Chapter 9, “Some Muslim Reflections on the West,” is especially useful. It surveys many of the issues that are repeated in the remaining chapters. Three themes recur in these chapters: dialogue, minority/majority status, and identity. Waardenburg has been a sympathetic participant in Muslim–Christian dialogues. He provides a survey of issues, institutions, and occasions of dialogue enlivened by his own accounts of his experience of participation in such events (chaps. 10 and 16). Much of the discussion of Islam in contemporary Europe—limited primarily to the United Kingdom, France, and Germany—is unfortunately rather schematic. The chapter on Islam in the Balkans (chap. 14) is rich in detail and therefore contrasts with the remaining chapters. This is disappointing, since Waardenburg insists that study of Muslims in Europe must move between lived realities and ideal norms, focusing on specific cases to gain deeper insight (p. 329). The theme of minority status, which is structured by a comparison with Christian minority status in the Middle East, does not seem to provide much analytic traction. More useful is Waardenburg's insistence on avoiding overemphasis on the “religious” as the most relevant aspect for understanding the complicated social reality of Islam in Europe. This leads to a problematizing of the notion of identity itself. Waardenburg insists that “no tradition is absolute and no authority infallible; no religion is inflexible and no identity without change” (p. 486). Identity is not a thing but a project, “something potential to be realized” (p. 485). It would have been wonderful to see this point more fully illustrated with attention to some cultural expressions arising in the European context from Muslims, especially in film and literature. Equally desirable would have been a fuller treatment of why rigidification of identity occurs so often in history, as Waardenburg laments. For Waardenburg, such rigidification is the product of “politicization,” the operation of or quest for power. It would be helpful to see this further elaborated and his suggestion that there is strong religious resistance to the political use of Islam more fully developed.
In its largest ambition this volume is a call for the constitution of a new field of impartial research on Muslim–Christian encounters (p. 442) as a way that might lead to cultural rapprochement. This collection might best be characterized as a handbook for that field, providing thorough surveys of scholarship on various topics, thoughtfully organized and indexed bibliographies, and a regular indication of topics and questions requiring further research. The objective of this field is to lay the groundwork for greater understanding between Muslims and Christians, especially in this era of significant hardening of attitudes on both sides. Users of this volume will hopefully take up those suggestions for further research to achieve this essential goal.
