The title of Robert Whitaker's interesting book does not reveal that it focuses on an instance of interracial violence in 1919 and the ensuing series of events that culminated in the U.S. Supreme Court's 1923 landmark decision Moore v. Dempsey. As history textbooks show, 1919 was a year especially notorious for interracial conflict in the nation. A reorganized Ku Klux Klan was regaining strength in the South and amassing new adherents in the Midwest and other parts of the country. Black veterans of World War I who had fought for democracy abroad were insisting on racial justice at home. Many black men were lynched, some burned alive. About two dozen race riots occurred that year, some in each region of the country. Typically, the violence involved white mobs invading black neighborhoods, with black residents often fighting back. The 1919 violent incidents often discussed in black history texts include those in Chicago; Omaha; Longview, Texas; and in the vicinity of Elaine (Phillips County), Arkansas.
Robert Whitaker's book is an extraordinarily detailed chronicle of the interracial trouble near Elaine in 1919 and the struggle for racial justice that followed. He begins by telling of a meeting of black farmers and their families at a rural church. The sharecroppers present were members of a recently formed agricultural union dedicated to promoting racial equality. They were making plans to press their landlords to accept a fair price for the year's crop. The most prominent businessmen and decision makers in the county seat (Helena) were major landowners in Phillips County. Whitaker relates that they had a prior history of countenancing violence against union organizing by black farmers. A local deputy sheriff and his associates interrupted this planning meeting in the church, gunshots were exchanged, and the deputy was killed.
Claiming that blacks were planning mass murder of whites in the county, white authorities raised a posse, augmented by a U.S. Army unit stationed nearby. Concerned for their lives, agrarian black families hid in remote rural places. Over a period of days, white shooters created terror, firing on scores of African Americans north of Elaine, at least fourteen of whom died of their wounds.
The latter half of Whitaker's book is about the legal proceedings that followed. There were arrests of dozens of African Americans, including women, who were rounded up by the posse and the military. Separate trials of groups of the black men were staged in a criminal court in Helena. Twelve men affiliated with the black farmers' union were sentenced to death by electrocution and sixty-seven others to prison terms as long as twenty-one years. After short trials, all-white juries in each case took only minutes to reach guilty verdicts.
Local and national equal-rights advocates struggled to prevent the execution of the sentences. With the NAACP's New York headquarters providing financial support and legal assistance, appeals and legal moves made in state and federal courts eventually brought about the release of all the convicted black farmers. Whitaker points out that a black attorney from Little Rock, Scipio Africanus Jones, made the most significant individual contribution to the release of the black sharecroppers. A brilliant lawyer, he was the prime mover of the appeals work at the state level. Jones also assembled the factual case that NAACP lawyers used to induce the U. S. Supreme Court to consider whether the black defendants had received a fair trial. Jones, for instance, had learned that black farmers had been repeatedly whipped and tortured with electric shocks in jail prior to their trials until they signed implicating statements that were used against them in court.
The Moore v. Dempsey decision may not have “remade the nation,” as Whitaker concludes (309). Nevertheless, it did usher in important changes in constitutional law when it ordered a district court to test the validity of the argument that the black farmers' trial was not fair. Legal scholars have recognized for decades that this decision set a precedent for federal courts to expand the use of the U.S. Constitution's due process clause to regulate procedures in state courts. Scholars of black history meanwhile have noted that following Moore v. Dempsey, attempts to obtain redress of racial grievances through appeals in the federal judiciary became more successful.
Academic historians are not the book's primary audience. On the Lap of Gods rarely addresses the pertinent historiography. Lacking an introduction and short on analysis, it essentially presents a chronological narrative that is interrupted at many points by paragraphs or pages of biographical or basic contextual information. The book's background material often is familiar to scholars in the field, for instance, its summary account of race relations in the South from Reconstruction through World War I. The book's unorthodox citation style makes source checking problematic. No endnote numbers appear in the text. The endnotes only give citations for its many quotations, listing them by their page numbers. Whitaker consulted some original sources, notably NAACP records, but their bibliographical citations sometimes are incomplete.
Whitaker accurately says that the story that he tells is unknown to Americans, and undoubtedly his aim is to bring it to the attention of the general reader. Whitaker, an accomplished scientific journalist, knows how to interest and keep the attention of the reading public, for instance, by maintaining an air of suspense. He does not reveal until near the narrative's end that the unjustly convicted black farmers did not die in the electric chair.
Scholars who read On the Laps of Gods will be reminded that Arkansas events were significant in the African American past. Some may wish to ask new questions about them and seek the answers through original research and standard historical methodology. Labor historians, for example, may want to study the union-organizing activities of the black sharecroppers. Nevertheless, Whitaker's book constitutes a welcome addition to the popular history of race relations in the United States.
