The involuntary resettlement and enslavement of West Africans in Latin America and the Caribbean left an indelible imprint on that part of the world. From the 1760s to the 1860s, large contingents of the hapless victims were taken to western Cuba. Many were forced to work on the sugar plantations, which helped transform the once stagnant colony's agricultural sector into a leading world supplier of the sweetener and its by-products. African slavery also altered the island's social structure and its relationship to Spain, especially during the Cuban struggle against Iberian colonial domination in the last third of the nineteenth century. Undoubtedly for these reasons, economic and institutional-political themes dominate the study of the African Diaspora in Spanish colonial Cuba.
Manuel Barcia's book Seeds of Insurrection pursues a different line of inquiry, focusing on the dynamic interaction between domination and resistance. Domination in a slave-based plantation society was implicit in law and custom and had a clear punitive or deterrent purpose. Resistance was not so clear-cut. It spanned a continuum from non-violent to violent, and some of it was hard to detect. Planters and colonial officials, pressed to preserve their lives and properties, put a great deal of stress on stamping out the troublesome manifestations of slave resistance, but were powerless to curb it entirely. The author maintains that the study of slavery in Cuba has tended to follow this general pattern. Consequently, armed insurrections and group escapes have dominated the field of slave resistance at the expense of other, less obviously unruly acts that sought to lessen, disrupt or overturn the institution of slavery. Resistance has also been studied piecemeal, arbitrarily splitting apart what may have been components of an interconnected universe of counter-hegemonic practices.
Barcia also notes that the domination-resistance binomial has been examined almost exclusively from a Caribbean or New World perspective, thus privileging factors that arose on this side of the Atlantic. The socio-cultural background of bozales and the specific political state of affairs of their places of origin in Africa are seldom considered important variables worthy of serious contemplation. While Barcia's work is geographically grounded in western Cuba, he approaches it diasporically in that both the American experience and African provenance of the captives are taken into account. For instance, some of the captives' artisanal skills, religious values and military experience in Africa were often played out in Cuba, enabling Barcia to evaluate the potential material resources, worldviews and options (fight, flight, suicide, ‘accommodation’ and so forth) that the enslaved had, and how they went about acting on them while being held captive in Cuba.
Methodologically, Barcia uses two additional interpretive tools to round out his investigation. The first, summed up in the concept of ‘everyday forms of resistance’, captures the previously mentioned wide range of responses to bondage in which enslaved men and women engaged. When this important advance in slave studies was first introduced in 1941, the author notes, it debunked the long-held view that captives who did not forcefully defy the slavocratic system must have tacitly accepted it. Since then, researchers have uncovered ample evidence of enslaved individuals and groups who relied on non-confrontational tactics, such as short- and long-term escapes, legally contesting violations of slave ordinances, feigning illness and ‘accidentally’ damaging equipment, to name just a few. To this kind of resistance, Barcia adds oppositional expressions cleverly disguised as cultural performance, including music, sacred rituals, dance, lore and gossip. This last category fits neatly with his second analytical instrument: James C. Scott's notion of ‘hidden transcripts’. Unlike public displays of insubordination, the latter often involved subtle, ‘behind-the-scenes’ verbal and unspoken communication, manners and other patterns of behaviour critical of enslavement and other oppressive conditions.
The author probes a variety of primary documents on domination and resistance found in Cuban, Spanish and English archives, including official colonial dispatches, newspapers, letters and diaries. Separate chapters are devoted to homicides, conspiracies and revolt, to marronage, to suicides, to slaves' use of the colonial legal framework, and to disguised and non-violent forms of resistance. He carefully examines the extant sources for each subject, the events they purportedly recorded and their end result. Rather than transcribing the information verbatim, he pays special attention to the processes and constraints under which most of them, especially criminal proceedings, were created. Not all of them, he observes, were faithful renditions of the reputed incidents reported by planters, slave catchers and public functionaries. Since the stakes were high for both the alleged offenders and for the persons who presented the cases against them, some of the parties interviewed might have slanted their declarations or provided biased, incomplete, contradictory and even linguistically inaccurate testimony.
All in all, Barcia's book offers a refreshing new look at African/black agency in the western Cuban plantation world. Its suggests that while bozales might have operated on the basis of some West African influences carried over to the New World, they did so in a Cuban environment that required making adjustments. In some cases, this meant taking oaths of allegiance to certain African-based secret societies or naciones, or following leaders into the battlefield. In other instances, it required building cross-ethnic alliances with Cuban-born counterparts and free people of colour. Sometimes, slave owners were surprised to learn that even the so-called esclavos mansos (submissive slaves) kept communications with or supplied provisions and weapons to cimarrones (escaped slaves/maroons) on a regular basis. Such role playing, duplicitous comportment, collaborations, adaptations, survival strategies and surreptitious activity, which often went on under the very noses of colonial overseers, call for a reconsideration of the role of resistance in helping to dismantle the systems of control that sought to keep captives and free blacks in check.
