The first two titles published by the University of Pennsylvania Press's new series, RaceB4Race: Critical Race Studies of the Premodern, successfully expand the materials and challenge the methods of historical analysis, social critique, and archival treatment not only for those investigating and applying premodern critical race theory to history, literature, and culture, but also for scholars and students of the classics, political philosophy, the history of education, economic theory, print technology, contract law, comparative translation, dance choreography, studies of grammar and eloquence, and other fields that have yet—either by circumstantial or willful omission—to acknowledge fully the significance of race in their academic inquiry. Building on a robust scholarly genealogy that has established racial formation as an organizing, structural force of domination, Urvashi Chakravarty and Noémie Ndiaye employ innovative approaches that reveal race craft's ideological and rhetorical strategies, expose racial capitalism as a primary incentive, and link today's injustices to centuries-long agendas that have served white supremacy.
The study of consent, service, and slavery in Chakravarty's Fictions of Consent: Slavery, Servitude, and Free Service in Early Modern England jarringly disrupts our understanding of the social contract, which claims broad consensus to legitimize the establishment of authority and, concurrently, expects obligatory service and obedience from those who have freely consented to that authority. But in revealing the “fictions of consent” that undergird servitude and slavery, Chakravarty shows how “networks of amity, obligation, mutuality, obedience, protection, contract and consanguinity are neither innocent nor neutral, but rather strategic”; these strategic fictions, in turn, “prepare the rhetorical and ideological ground for the frameworks of slavery” (198). Challenging the notion that early modern England was “too pure an Air for Slaves to breath in” (48), Chakravarty locates in sartorial livery and social markings, early modern schoolrooms and Roman plays, intimate households and their rhetoric of kinship, and the legal documentation and literary representation of servitude England's inculcated justifications for the atrocities of color-based slavery.
Chapter 1, “Making Service: Livery, Liberty, and Legal Fictions in Early Modern England,” anticipates the stakes of future chapters by providing a compelling prelude to what will be a study of the “nexus of race and bondage and of the early modern theater's incorporation in a larger system of commerce, corporeality, and commodification” (43). The chapter's emphasis on livery as that which connects a servant's body to his master's social status exemplifies Chakravarty's emphasis on reading master and servant bonds in intimate, quotidian spaces. Moving beyond the commonplace adage of self-fashioning in the Renaissance, Chakravarty investigates servants’ clothing in the context of “credit, identity, and household” in ways that anticipate the markings on the enslaved body (41). Sartorial performance epitomizes the challenge of reading consent in relation to service because “discourses around livery centered on not only the extent to which it marked one's bondage, but whether it registered a capacity for consent at all” (18). Livery is a vexed signifier that proves yet potentially undoes hierarchy, bondage, and class. The theatre is particularly invested in this paradox: signifiers of service flaunt the lack of consent as consensual.
The next three chapters explore the varied forms and far-reaching influence of service in early modern England. Chakravarty curates and investigates an archive of classical school materials, conduct books, captivity narratives, public pamphlets, woodcuts of foreign figures, private letters, royal edicts, prison accounts, and apprenticeship contracts to show how “the conceptual genealogies of slavery were seeded and authorized” (46). Chapter 2's focus on “Race, Slavery, and Pedagogy in the Early Modern Schoolroom” investigates the seeds of enslavement in the schoolroom and provides a haunting look at the abuse and manipulation unleashed on young students and apprentices. The schoolroom's emulation of Roman comedies, as well as its preoccupation with narratives of captivity and escape, rehearse what will be the brutal conjoining of otherness to Blackness. The chapter proves that the English imagination of slavery in the global economy has its pedagogical roots in the schoolroom's rhetorically coercive, and often physically violent, bonds.
It is worth noting that Chakravarty's unflinching look at the demands of service on children—in the classroom and, later in the book, as objects of sale for indentured servitude—is immensely unsettling. Young, vulnerable, and poor people predominated in the inhumane atrocities deployed, repeated, and justified in early modern England. The book provides a haunting investigation of children embroiled in abuse and exploitation in the name of education, family, progress, and prosperity—which, in turn, served race-based enslavement.
Examination of the “theaters of service” (198) continues in the discussion of servants, indentured servitude, and manumission. Chapter 3's focus on the household shows how “slavery is always philologically and intellectually central to how we must understand generation and nativity, kinship and bloodlines” (130). The chapter provides new readings of Ben Jonson's Volpone and Shakespeare's Othello, Comedy of Errors, and Twelfth Night, as well as arguably the most compelling analysis of that sordid blackmailer, De Flores, in Thomas Middleton and William Rowley's The Changeling. Troubling the concept of “recompense” to expand beyond the typical economic exchange between master and servant, Chakravarty proposes that De Flores's demands for recompense “signal the conflicting registers of service: an outstanding obligation and a duty fulfilled, sexual possibility and monetary return” (109). Official documents and legal contracts regarding indentured servitude attempt to codify these conflicting registers. But early modern England's attempts to stabilize the concept only prove the contradictory imperatives attached to service: binding freedom, moneyless payments, and steady precarity. The implications of these paradoxes are pursued in Milton's canonical work, the topic of Chapter 4, “Faithful Covenant Servants and Inbred Enemies: Indenture and Natality in Paradise Lost.” Fictions of consent that emerge from the study of indentured servitude further problematize obligation and obedience in ways that justify England's participation in the racialization of slavery. Embroiling gratitude in toil and liberty in obligation, Adam and Eve serve in ways that anticipate the color-based limits of indentured servitude, with “a curiously insistent and perverse anti-natalist strain that both sutures the family to work and yokes natality to the prospect of slavery” (158).
Chapter 5's emphasis on manumission draws from The Tempest and early American representations of the “freed man” to explicate the role of consent in what Chakravarty encapsulates as “freedom's compulsion to bondage” (172). The investigation draws much from previous chapters through consideration of the cruel humanist schoolmaster (Miranda), misrepresentation of indentured servitude (Ariel), and the violence embedded in the service economy (Caliban) alongside the historical example of Adam Saffin, a seventeenth-century indentured servant whose “‘cheerful’ bondage” (190) turned sour. The chapter argues that “being free” and “being freed” differ not in degree but are rather diametrically opposed, wherein being free to serve is lauded as an ideal, and being freed from service warrants a “stamp” (194) or “stain” (171) as a physical reminder of moral indictment. The mark of the freed servant is one of the many ways that freedom in the social contract is “founded on contingency, revocability, and indeed servitude, even as they press the strategies of epidermal race into their own service” (196). Volitional agency depends upon the vagaries of service in ways that entitle as much as they disqualify. This disqualification in turn continues to justify racial capitalism by naturalizing the abuse and exploitation of the most vulnerable, while obscuring the mechanisms of abuse and exploitation in the guise of mutuality.
Mutuality is itself a fiction reinforced, legitimized, and made binding by service contracts. What the amassed evidence in the form of these contracts makes clear is the facade of transactional labor that veiled human trafficking. This is not the first book to tackle the idea of service in the period, but it strikes me as the most thorough curation of materials on servitude that are the antecedents of slavery. Chakravarty's emphasis on that term—antecedents—indicates something beyond chronological precursors; it signals a precondition. Fictions of consent were essential to the development of England's global contributions to racialized capitalism. Everyone knows the maxim “follow the money”; in early modern England, follow the service and you'll find everything that color-based slavery needed to thrive.
Scripts of Blackness likewise reveals the preconditions of racist atrocities through Noémie Ndiaye's unprecedented methods of inquiry and critique. What Fictions of Consent reveals via the paradoxes of service embedded in everyday English life—namely, the period's material and rhetorical investments in racial capitalism—Scripts of Blackness conveys in the theatrical practices of European colonial powers. In both monographs’ illumination of new critical frames, assemblage of cultural artifacts from unconventional archives, and ethical approaches to the study of race in the period, they not only decipher racial formation's strategies of inculcation, repetition, and enforcement, but furthermore reveal who these strategies serve. Unburdened by the overrehearsed defense of premodern race formation, they ask not what race means, but how and for whom it is made to mean in the context of European colonial plunder. Racializing hierarchies supporting white nationalism emerged alongside the ideological, rhetorical, and material apparatuses buttressing the global terror of protocapitalism. How do classrooms and contracts, ballets and parades, as well as many other literal and figurative stages, perform the emergence of color-based slavery? Borrowing from Chakravarty's phrasing, what are the collusions that enable racism? Ndiaye offers a resounding answer to these questions by “reconstruct[ing] how early modern Afro-diasporic characters looked, sounded, and moved in various performance settings, in order to reassemble the racializing scripts of blackness that such cosmetic, acoustic, and kinetic impersonation yielded” (16). Through a comprehensive transnational and translingual investigation of the racializing scripts that Europeans performed to cultivate and spread anti-Blackness, the book offers an extraordinary gathering of performance scripts and a revolutionary demonstration of how to analyze them.
Scripts operate as blueprints for performance by conveying prescribed appearances, dialogues, songs, and movements. It is precisely through repeatable and recorded expectations that scripts enable deviation and mutation. They travel well because they stick. And the scripts that have stuck to Blackness have crafted racial hierarchies in formative and enduring ways. This monograph proves how complex power plays of colonial and capitalist agendas were processed in the metropolises of Europe through theatrical “black-up (cosmetic blackness), blackspeak (acoustic blackness), and black dances (kinetic blackness),” thus activating severe prejudices against and lethal abuse of Afro-diasporic people (3). Ndiaye traces the nuances and overlaps, the contradictions and mutations, of these racist scripts through an unparalleled comparative study of the theatrical cultures of early modern England, Spain, and France.
Chapter 1's overview of the cosmetic components and ideological motives of black-up show that the theatrical performance of Blackness is rooted in systems of global exchange and in the fissures of local conflicts. The technologies of black-up are proven to be an early modern metropolitan response to “a new racial climate” (43) heralded by European expansion in the Atlantic world. In one of a handful of comparative analyses across cultures, Ndiaye reads Shakespeare's Titus Andronicus and the French novella La Tragédie françoize d'un More as cautionary tales that establish the depravity and cruelty attributed to Black men, thus “activating the diabolical script of blackness” (54). It might seem, upon comparison to the dominance of the diabolical trope in England and France, that Spain features an alternative: Black saints as figures of redemptive possibility. Yet even in this seemingly new script lies the motives of the old one. Spanish deployments of black-up, the chapter astutely argues, are one of many responses to global exchange. The excavation of the soul from the Black body shunts Afro-diasporic people into a religious framework that ultimately exploits them as soulless commodities: “The Catholic theology that informed this perception of dark skin as immaterial at the end of the sixteenth century was coterminous with a strong investment in the material sub-Saharan body in which Spaniards could indulge guilt-free once that body was separated from its soul” (71–2). Demonic or saved, helpless or agentic, the scripted performances mobilized alongside black-up adapted according to the commodifying demands of a colonial episteme.
The second chapter, “A Brief Herstory of Baroque Black-Up: Cosmetic Blackness, Gender, and Sexuality,” focuses on the “feminization of black-up” (83) to investigate how scenes of interracial desire are deployed to stylize erotic suffering linguistically and to obscure the real, material atrocities unleashed on Afro-diasporic people. In the French context, this obscuring took the form of Black men's willing subjection to the unattainable white woman, thus conjoining enslavement to erotic choice. Ndiaye reveals the falsehood of this narrative by scrutinizing the colonial apparatus it serves and by drawing from a range of materials that showed French efforts to turn “Frenchmen away from Afro-diasporic women . . . [through] a multifronted legal and fiscal campaign” (99). In other words, the poetics of the Black man desiring the white woman partakes in a cultural denial of, and compulsive anxiety about, white men desiring black women. The Spanish context registers the anxieties of imperial ambition through the figure of the mulatta. In the comedias nuevas, the mulatta's proximity to whiteness ultimately attaches her to Afro-diasporic women: “The very existence of that character [the mulatta] tacitly acknowledged and reminded spectators of the desirability of enslaved Afro-diasporic women in early modern Spain, which the peculiar deployment of the commodifying scripts of blackness denied” (125).
Unlike the effacement of Black women in French and Spanish scripts, England's theatrical impersonation of the Black female servant takes the form of the terrifying figure of a succuba. The chapter displays Ndiaye's astute readings of well-studied plays such as The Knight of Malta, The Island Princess, The Tempest, The Merchant of Venice, The White Devil, and The Fair Maid of the West, Parts 1 and 2 alongside drama not frequently included in the early modern canon: The Wonder of Women, The Spanish Mandeuile of Miracles, Monsieur Thomas, An Evening's Love, Tarugo's Wiles, The Women's Conquest, The Empress of Morocco, and The Atheist. As a devil impersonating a Black woman in order to trick a white man into sexual depravity, the succuba represents sin, witchcraft, trickery, and lust. Analysis of The White Devil, for instance, provides a new way of assessing John Webster's participation in the trope of the enamored Black servant. Zanche is one of English drama's iterations of “the black succuba, who, as a reproductive vehicle for another race's seed, was always positioned simultaneously inside and outside of the economy of sexual familial reproduction” (117). For England, therefore, the scopic titillation of the bed-trick demonizes the blackened woman as an evil rapist and violent aggressor at a time when Black women were the ones disempowered and dehumanized, thus conveying a version of hypocritical cruelty that served England's self-proclaimed status as a land free of slaves.
Whether in the slave-to-love trope of the French court, or the inculcation of colorism in Spanish comedies, or the villainization of Black women in the English bed-trick, Ndiaye weaves her readings through transnational contexts, displaying a facility with these juxtapositions that is as insightful as it is poignant. When scripts convey Black men lusting over white women, or depict Black women tricking white men into sleeping with them, what they obfuscate in the European imagination is the irrefutable fact and documented frequency of white men's exploitation of the Black women they desire. The chapter is a disturbing intervention on a crucial feature of European theatre: performative Blackness in scenes of interracial desire had little to do with Blackness or desire and everything to do with what white people told themselves about themselves. The color-based slavery of the European colonial episteme exonerated this violence through denial and lies. Theatrical scripts have recorded those lies and, through Ndiaye's curation of new materials across cultures and beyond the canon, they can no longer be denied.
The auditory resonances of racism are the subject of the next chapter, “Blackspeak: Acoustic Blackness and the Accents of Race.” Elements of accent, intonation, and syntax were deployed to depict colonized subjects as inferior to the European norm. With careful theoretical scaffolding and an array of performance contexts, Ndiaye reveals how scripts of artificial “ethnic conjuration” (144) are “a major performative technique of racialization essentializing difference in the service of power to locate Afro-descendants at the bottom of social orders” (143). The conjuration of racially inflected performances primed audiences to conjoin Blackness to error, insufficiency, and savagery. The chapter not only gathers a range of materials across Europe that are rarely studied together; it forces us to hear the ideological damage of colonial powers. Whether depicted as senseless warbling, or foreign gibberish, or hyperbolically accented European vernacular, or “broken English” (167), blackspeak was deployed to “infantilize and animalize Afro-Europeans” (143). By providing different examples of the auditory markers of racial impersonation, the chapter uncovers a pattern of intertwined ethnic impersonation meant to infantilize, belittle, and dehumanize. Though fictional, the function of blackspeak in the making of white nationalism is real. Acoustic cues are not merely a way to peg racialized characters as the opposite of the civilized norm and thus a threat to national purity; they also reinforce social positions and racially inflected subjectivity. Ndiaye demonstrates how the sounds of racism compel, trap, classify, force, oppress, and linger beyond any singular, ephemeral iteration or scripted sound.
The chapter also overcomes the perils of translation through an ethical, antiracist methodology that future researchers and translators should heed. Ndiaye directly confronts the challenge of translating a glaringly brutal archive of racist scripts without turning into a “modern producer of blackspeak” (29). In the English translation of French blackspeak, for instance, she uses symbols to convey racializing slurs: “the phonetic distortions of blackspeak are signaled with a hash symbol immediately preceding the phonetically accented word or word group” (29–30). Glosses like these signal blackspeak without reproducing and potentially reessentializing racist scripts. Scripts of Blackness conveys a thoughtful justification for, as well as ethical model of, transnational comparative race work. It is also an invitation. Ndiaye's methodology challenges the field to study networks of performance and representation in consultation with a broader archive of racecraft. The book ends with an impressive appendix of theatrical scripts from European metropolises, heralding a more inclusive investigation of texts across borders and outside canons.
Although structured to distinguish between the cosmetic, the auditory, and the kinetic, Ndiaye notes the overlaps across theatrical contexts: “There was a fundamental mutual dependency between the scopic and the acoustic regimes in early modern racecraft” (185), evident in the study of Black dance as “the love child of the scopic and acoustic regimes” (186). Chapter 4, “Black Moves: Race, Dance, and Power,” considers the performativity of Blackness in French ballet, English masques, Spanish street processions, and other iterations of “kinetic power dynamics” (188). Ndiaye clarifies that these performances are not representative of Black power or African authenticity, but rather a tool of white supremacy and “indissolubly attached to the practice of slavery in lands begging to be colonized” (190). Therefore, what the chapter tackles is not just the analysis of movement as an element of theatrical performance but the imposed meaning of movement in the depiction of those fundamentally denied movement—enslaved people who were kidnapped, constrained, and shackled. The hyperanimated, sexualized, kinetic energy attached to Blackness is an index of power relations lodged in choreography. I was unfamiliar with almost every Spanish and French sample offered—from the religious processions of the Black Seville confraternities to the elaborately choreographed French ballets—and yet Ndiaye brilliantly displayed the conflicting stakes of these scripted movements. On the one hand, these white scripts could be appropriated by Afro-diasporic people in community celebrations or as a means to livelihood; on the other hand, dehumanizing dance routines were a means to assert white supremacy in the guise of entertainment.
The vast implications and significant findings emerging from these two monographs stem from the diversity of materials consulted and the innovations in archival research. In order to address the inherent whiteness and vested interests of European archives, Chakravarty and Ndiaye break out of methodological limits previously considered unsurmountable. New archives require new interventions unimpeded by the disciplinary politics of boundaries such as those between the canonical and the quotidian; between global studies and Black studies; between pedagogy and practice; between social critique and affective empathy; between what we do with our research and how we live our lives. They force us to look at the hauntings of terror lodged, obscured, and codified in the production of early modern culture in Europe and, in doing so, historicize racializing apparatuses that continue to undergird the injustices of our modern world. Ndiaye's emphasis on the racist scripts of early modern transnational performance and Chakravarty's analysis of fictions of consent in the bonds that oppress represent something fundamental about premodern critical race studies. They reach beyond the conventional paradigms of academic research because those paradigms were designed to protect and obscure the very apparatuses this research seeks to dismantle. In this way, their scholarly contributions exemplify the interventions of the RaceB4Race initiative, which seeks to nurture a “community of scholars, students, researchers, theater practitioners, curators, librarians, artists, and activists who are looking to the past to imagine different, more inclusive futures” [https://acmrs.asu.edu/RaceB4Race/Sustaining-Building-Innovating]. These two books are part of an intellectual revolution committed to racial justice: curation that critiques, historicity that matters, and race work that is antiracist.
