The “condition of England” in the middle of the nineteenth century was, for most Victorians (and is, indeed, for most modern scholars of the Victorian period), about as far removed from desert pirates and neo-Grecian queens as London from Jerusalem. But such was not the case in 1847 for the ambitious novelist-turned-politician Benjamin Disraeli, himself a mixture of political and social incongruities, who chose to conclude his political trilogy with a novel that bore greater resemblance to an Arabian Nights fantasy than to any mid-Victorian reform fiction. Contemporary readers of Tancred, or The New Crusade (1847) were understandably perplexed: “There is no principle of cohesion about the book, if we except the covers,” complained one reviewer (qtd. in Stewart 229). And, while critics have expanded upon this dismissive condemnation throughout the twentieth century, not much has changed regarding the general critical appraisal or thoughtful analysis of what Disraeli regarded as the favorite of his compositions (Blake 215). The least popular of the Young England novels both in its own day and in ours, Tancred has most frequently been viewed as an anomaly – an abandonment of the political manifesto Disraeli began in Coningsby and continued in Sybil.
Contemporary reviewers seem to have been so busy forming jokes that they failed to consider the complexity of Tancred's political agenda. Contributing to this tendency was their obsession with Disraeli's idiosyncratic views on Judaism, which, unsurprisingly, are the focus of almost all contemporary reviews. The anti-Semitism of the period is evident in the number of misreadings of the novel offered by Disraeli's contemporaries. For example, a reviewer for the Times wrote regarding the purpose of Tancred:
We hope we shall not peril Mr. Disraeli's seat at the coming election, and render him an object of hatred to the liberal and enlightened body of Dissenters, when we state the hon. gentleman's purpose to be, as far as we can with difficulty discern it – to make Europe don the graceful and variegated costume of the nations of the East, and – hear it, hall of Exeter! – to convert the whole world, converted Jews and all, back to Judaism!Footnote 1 (qtd. in Stewart 232)
When Victorian reviewers could distinguish any purpose at all in the novel, this was almost invariably the one upon which they settled.
Twentieth-century critics, although inspired by more generous motives, have nonetheless succumbed to the same tendency to dismiss Tancred in their discussions of Disraeli's political fictionFootnote 2 because of the novel's focus on religion. For instance, Rolf Lessenich draws a sharp distinction between the final novel in the trilogy and its predecessors: “The monk and the monarch represent the two means by which Disraeli sought to renew Europe and indeed the World, religion and politics. Coningsby and Egremont are the political heroes, Tancred is the religious hero of Disraeli's trilogy” (35). Enlightenment democracies have long viewed politics and religion as uneasy bedfellows, and this unwillingness to think of the two together has arguably influenced the way this particular novel has been read.
Just because Tancred emphasizes the importance of religion to the well-being of society does not, however, prevent the novel from being political, and Tancred is every bit as concerned with politics and reform as are the other Young England novels. Although Tancred includes no factories, no indigent members of the working classes, and no Chartists, it is nonetheless deeply invested in the social reformation of England. Tancred does not exhibit any of the defining characteristics of the so-called “Condition of England” genre, with which Sybil is often classed, but its apparent failure to meet such criteria reflects, I think, more on the limitations imposed by our own tendency to classify novels rigidly than it does on Tancred's political agenda.
Rather than disregarding reform, Tancred simply takes a different approach to it than do the earlier Young England novels. By actively dismissing the reform politics of the two earlier political novels and proposing instead a much more radical approach to social change – one that requires a fundamental alteration in the assumptions that dictate social operations – Tancred suggests that the problems plaguing England are far greater in scope and infinitely more complicated in nature than the plots of the earlier novels acknowledged. And while the novel presents its social and political insights through the medium of a fanciful quest narrative, Tancred's romanticism is used artfully to present a radical political agenda. By replacing the optimism and complacency of the earlier novels (as well as of Disraeli's earlier Young England ideology) with a recognition of the complexity and deep-rootedness of England's social problems, Tancred ends up being much more practical in its take on reform than either Coningsby or Sybil.
The questions Tancred raises, however, are too complex and too subtle to yield to any easy solutions. While the novel's hero searches desperately for a means of combating such a decentralized problem as the widespread moral corruption he feels is at the root of England's national misery, he inevitably fails. Thus, the novel is unable to solve any of the issues it raises. This lack of closure – this refusal to resort to any “Morrison's Pill”-type solution – is not, however, a mark of incompetence on Disraeli's part, but rather evidence of a more mature, nuanced understanding of the Condition of England than is demonstrated in the earlier novels, a point I will illustrate first by looking at the political agendas of Sybil and Coningsby and then at Tancred in comparison.
* * *
Published in 1844, CONINGSBY, or The New Generation marked Disraeli's first real attempt at breaking away from his earlier forays into “silver fork” and autobiographical fiction, as well as his first effort at using his newfound political knowledge to create fiction “with a purpose.” In recent decades, Joseph W. Childers has given a savvy explanation of how Coningsby works as a political novel. He points out the originality of Disraeli's manipulation of genre, arguing, “Coningsby remodels fiction's connection to politics, making the discourse of parliamentary party politics more overtly the object of interpretation than any earlier novel had” (46). While Childers's sophisticated reading of the way in which Coningsby utilizes novelistic and political discourse provides a useful reminder to modern readers of the political nature of what would otherwise be an ordinary Bildüngsroman, Victorian readers, with different assumptions and expectations, seem to have had no trouble identifying the novel as primarily concerned with politics. In fact, contemporary reviewers proved quite uninterested in the Bildüngsroman-aspects of Coningsby, and instead focused most of their attention on either the political agenda espoused in the novel or Disraeli's technique of basing his characters upon prominent members of the aristocracy and the fashionable world.
Shorn of its political trappings, Coningsby is the tale of young Harry Coningsby's path to maturity. Despite his portrayal as a rather lackluster, ordinary sort of fellow in the narrative, Coningsby, we are told, is something special – a political genius in the making. He and his friends at Eton sit and ponder the problems of the nation and decide that the future of England is in their hands. Although they are prevented by their youth from acting to alter British politics, Coningsby and his young followers nonetheless conclude that their elders – both Whig and Conservative – have gotten everything wrong and that it is their responsibility to set things right. Much of the novel, then, becomes devoted to explaining the various ways in which the young men plan to save England – plans that bear a striking resemblance to the ideas espoused by Disraeli and his Young England compatriots.
In 1844, Disraeli was still invested in the coterie of young aristocrats known as Young England, to whom he acted as the older and wiser guide. Although there were never more than a handful of members in the group, they enjoyed a surprising amount of notoriety for their romantic political agenda, which included returning England to a sort of enlightened feudal society in which a generous aristocracy and a loyal peasantry would work together for mutual benefit. Other of their ideas for reforming England included a revival of traditional English festivals and pageantry, as well as a return to more ritualized, High Church practices in the Church of England. As Robert Blake succinctly puts it, “Young England was the Oxford movement translated by Cambridge from religion into politics” (171).
Coningsby was consistently identified by Disraeli's contemporaries as a sort of manifesto for Young England. Thackeray, with his usual caustic wit, provides a surprisingly accurate summary of the novel's political agenda:
Politically, “Coningsby” is an exposure and attack of Whigs and Conservatives. Of Whigs much, but of Conservatives more. The author exposes the cant and folly of the name, and the lies of the practice. He lays bare dirty motives and intrigues . . .; calls upon the elders of the Conservative party to accept the Reform Bill and the new institutions consequent upon it; but calling in vain, and seeing how powerless the old party are to avert from the menaced country the dangers of anarchy, poverty, revolution, hanging over it – intimates that YOUNG ENGLAND is likely to save us from these evils. . . . (qtd. in Stewart 185)
Although Young England is not specifically named in the novel, contemporary readers such as Thackeray had no trouble recognizing the fictional manifestation of Disraeli's real political project at the time. To its Victorian readers, Coningsby was quite clearly a political novel.
Although the bulk of the narrative is devoted to describing Coningsby's personal and romantic adventures, the plot crux is of a political nature. Coningsby's grandfather demands that Coningsby, with all of his Young England ideals, stand as a candidate for the Conservatives, and the young man is disinherited when he refuses to comply. Nonetheless, he is rescued from his poverty through an advantageous marriage and a fortuitous return of his grandfather's fortune. More importantly, Coningsby's manufacturer father-in-law secures him a seat in Parliament, where we are left to presume he will exert the same powerful influence he did at Eton. When the novel closes, he has done nothing to improve the condition of England, and Parliament is still teeming with corruption and incompetence; however, the hero's happy ending functions as a harbinger of political regeneration. With the intelligent and upright Coningsby, as well as many of his Eton friends, in office, the future gleams brightly on the horizon.
While Coningsby concerns “the derivation and character of political parties,” Sybil, or The Two Nations (1845) focuses on “the condition of the people which had been the consequence of them [the political parties]” (qtd. in Smith xi, 1870 General Preface). Of the three Young England novels, Sybil has received by far the most attention from literary critics, mostly because it fits nicely into what, judging from the criticism, one would think to be the only type of nineteenth-century fiction concerned with politics and reform: the “Condition of England” or industrial novel. Sybil has for its hero another young aristocrat, Charles Egremont – a dissipated youth who lacks a purpose to which he can devote himself. He discovers this purpose when he meets Walter Gerard, a common laborer of aristocratic Saxon ancestry, and his daughter Sybil. The novel traces Egremont's growing awareness of the “two nations,” a social education that leads him to recognize the horrific state of poverty imposed upon the working classes by irresponsible aristocrats. At the same time, Sybil and Gerard come to realize the futility of working class-organized movements such as Chartism, and the novel ultimately reaffirms the political message of Coningsby and Young England: resolving the problems of “the people” is the responsibility of the aristocracy.
Like Coningsby, Sybil ends with a marriage, but with nothing having been accomplished towards the regeneration of England: Egremont's irresponsible elder brother is killed, Chartism is quashed, and Sybil is restored her rightful title (she was of noble blood all along), but nothing significant has changed for the better. Egremont and Sybil retire to an idyllic life as enlightened landlords, and Egremont shows promise of an influential Parliamentary career, but no one actually acts to alter the deplorable condition of the working classes highlighted in the earlier part of the narrative. Nonetheless, the novel ends with promises of good things to come, with the author addressing his readers:
A year ago, I presumed to offer to the public some volumes that aimed at calling their attention to the state of our political parties; their origin, their history, their present position. In an age of political infidelity, of mean passions, and petty thoughts, I would have impressed upon the rising race not to despair, but to seek in a right understanding of the history of their country and in the energies of heroic youth, the elements of national welfare. The present work advances another step in the same emprise. From the state of Parties it now would draw public thought to the state of the People whom those parties for two centuries have governed. The comprehension and the cure of this greater theme depend upon the same agencies as the first: it is the past alone that can explain the present, and it is youth that alone can mould the remedial future. (420–21; bk. 6, ch. 13)
He goes on, very much in the spirit of Young England and Coningsby: “That we may live to see England once more possess a free Monarchy, and a privileged and prosperous People, is my prayer; that these great consequences can only be brought about by the energy and devotion of our Youth is my persuasion” (421–22; bk. 6, ch. 13). Once again, Disraeli leaves his readers with only promises of a brighter future – a future to be brought about by turning the welfare of the nation over to the Coningsbys and Egremonts of England.
Coningsby and Sybil thus reflect the optimism of Disraeli's early political views. Although both novels highlight political and social problems that were plaguing the nation, Disraeli turns in both cases to the panacea of Young England: if the nation only would put its trust in the genius and enthusiasm of its young aristocrats, it could be rid of the debilitating political pettiness and moral decay characteristic of the leaders of the two major political parties. Coningsby and Sybil denounce Parliament as teeming with corruption and incompetence, yet both also suggest that solving the problem is merely an issue of replacing corrupt MPs with enlightened ones and enacting specific legislation. Thus, the first two Young England novels espouse a classic liberal and not-at-all revolutionary solution to the “condition of England” problem; when the narratives offer any answers at all to the issues they raise, those answers are firmly grounded in the political process: England simply needs more morally upright, selfless (young) men in positions of power.
But that was in 1845, when Young England had not quite yet become politically irrelevant. By 1847, when Tancred, or The New Crusade was published, Disraeli's political agenda for the trilogy seems to have undergone a dramatic change.
* * *
TANCRED begins with a setting characteristic of Disraeli's society fiction – a lavish coming of age celebration for Tancred, Lord Montacute, a protagonist who shows promise, even before he formally enters the narrative, of becoming the next great Young England hero (he is of even nobler blood than either Coningsby or Egremont, and he has the ideal upbringing for fostering the kind of romantic idealism characteristic of Young England). However, when Tancred does enter the narrative, we discover that this novel will not follow the model of its predecessors. Immediately following his coming of age celebration, Tancred is offered a seat in Parliament, but this path to political power – one that both Coningsby and Egremont would have envied at the time of their majority – is not to be his. To his parents’ astonishment, Tancred declines the offer, explaining that he simply cannot devote himself to a government in which he has no faith. In what should be at least moderately surprising to anyone who has read Coningsby or Sybil or who knows anything about Disraeli's career, Tancred denounces Parliament, which he sees as completely ineffective in bringing about social change. When Tancred's father, the Duke of Bellamont, attempts to explain to his son that his duty is to act as a “pillar of the State,” Tancred replies, “Ah! if any one would but tell me what the State is. It seems to me your pillars remain, but they support nothing” (47; bk. 2, ch. 1).
In an attitude most uncharacteristic of a Young England hero, Tancred dismisses Parliament as a useless antiquity. He says to his father: “You have proposed to me to-day to enter public life. I do not shrink from its duties. On the contrary, from the position in which I am born, still more from the impulse of my nature, I am desirous to fulfil [sic] them. I have meditated on them, I may say, even for years. But I cannot find that it is part of my duty to maintain the order of things. . . .” (49; bk. 2, ch. 1). Gone are the self-confidence and optimism of Coningsby and Egremont, as well as the general promising expectation of better things to come if the current political structure were enlivened. Tancred, the new hero, sees only a bleak future for England. He recognizes many of the same problems denounced by his predecessors – materialism, venality, selfishness – but he has no hope in a practical, political solution. Moreover, he identifies the British political and social system itself as one of the primary sources of social problems. “The people of this country have ceased,” he laments, “to be a nation. They are a crowd, and only kept in some rude provisional discipline by the remains of that old system which they are daily destroying” (51; bk. 2, ch. 1).
By refusing to enter Parliament, Tancred effectively dismisses the mild liberal political ideology of the earlier novels and replaces it with a philosophy that has revolutionary implications. In Tancred, a brilliant young aristocrat in a position of political power is no longer the answer to England's problems, for, according to the novel's hero, the nation's social problems are much too deeply rooted to be altered by anything so insignificant as Parliament or the aristocracy. Instead, England must look to God for a means of regenerating the nation. After explaining his reason for not entering Parliament and his views on the condition of England, Tancred exclaims to his father “in a tone almost of anguish,” “If an angel would but visit our house as he visited the house of Lot!” (51; bk. 2, ch. 1). But, alas! Tancred, despite his spiritual devotion, has been deprived of such a divine visitation. Thus, he decides that, in order to have a positive impact on his nation (the goal of any Disraelian hero), he must journey beyond England to Jerusalem. Because God will not speak to him in England, and convinced that he can improve his odds of receiving divine notice in God's chosen land, Tancred decides that he must travel to the Holy Land in order to receive his celestial inspiration. Only there can he ask the questions that torment him and expect to receive an answer: “I, too, would kneel at the tomb; I, too, surrounded by the holy hills and sacred groves of Jerusalem, would relieve my spirit from the bale that bows it down; would lift up my voice to heaven, and ask, What is DUTY, and what is FAITH? What ought I to DO, and what ought I to BELIEVE?” (55; bk. 2, ch. 1). Plagued by a profound sense of doubt and crippling uncertainty, Tancred sets his eyes on Jerusalem and places all of his hope for his future and England's in a direct response from God.
I would like to pause for a moment to explain that I am not arguing that Tancred's rather peculiar views are synonymous with Disraeli's – far from it. In fact, I think it would be a mistake even to say that Tancred and the narrator share the same viewpoint; as Nils Clausson has pointed out, the narrator is generally much more witty and worldly-wise in tone than is the almost comically naïve Tancred (2). Moreover, it is possible to read Tancred as a political novel without reading it as autobiographical. While Tancred is connected to the earlier novels in the trilogy through its illumination of some of the same social problems and its exploration of ways to regenerate the nation, it does not function as a direct manifesto for a corresponding real political group in the manner of Coningsby and Sybil. Rather, Tancred can be read as an articulation of a more complex and radical understanding of politics and the “condition of England” without offering any explicit program for reform. It would be foolish to assume that Disraeli was ready to give up his Parliamentary career in 1847, but I do not think it so far-fetched to read Tancred as evidence of Disraeli's waning optimism in any simple Parliamentary solution to vast social problems.
In addition to offering a new evaluation of the state of the nation and the means required to improve that state, Tancred quite explicitly rejects the political agenda lauded in the two earlier novels. Disraeli creates this connection to the politics of the earlier novels by introducing his new hero to characters from the previous volumes of the triology. In making plans for his trip to Palestine, Tancred is referred by a family friend to Sidonia – the mysterious Jewish sage who acted as a mentor to Coningsby in the first Young England novel. Just as he saw something remarkable in Coningsby, Sidonia immediately identifies Tancred as someone worthy of his attention: “He recognised in this youth not a vain and vague visionary, but a being in whom the faculties of reason and imagination were both of the highest class, and both equally developed. . . . [H]e possessed all the latent qualities which in future would qualify him to control society” (123–24; bk. 2, ch. 11). That Tancred receives the endorsement of Sidonia, who is always presented as the sagacious expert on the world and its workings whenever he appears in the trilogy, suggests that the hero is not to be dismissed as just a silly young man in need of some life lessons.
In order to help his new young friend blossom into the political savant he knows Tancred will eventually become, Sidonia introduces Tancred to the heroes from the earlier novels. Thus, at a dinner party, Tancred meets Coningsby, Egremont (now Lord Marney), and Lord Henry Sidney (Coningsby's friend from the first novel). However, the former heroes are not shown to have fulfilled the expectations set up by their narratives. Coningsby, we learn, spends a great deal of time in Westminster but owes much of his success to his wife, Edith, who, after having developed into a brilliant society wit, functions as her husband's social representative. Lord Marney, despite the promising beginning to his political career outlined in Sybil, remained “[a] man of fine mind rather than of brilliant talents, [who] found, in the more vivid and impassioned intelligence of Coningsby, the directing sympathy which he required” (139; bk. 2, ch. 13). Coningsby and Marney “were both men entirely devoted to public affairs, and sitting in different Houses, both young, and both masters of fortunes of the first class, they were indicated as individuals who hereafter might take a lead” (137; bk. 2, ch. 13, emphasis added). Despite at least a year having passed since the conclusion of the second novel (Sybil, we are told in Tancred, is in her second season of mingling with the fashionable world), Coningsby and Marney are still suspended in a state of inaction. They are not said to have done anything to affect their lofty goals, and instead are only “indicated” (by whom, we are not told) as men who might eventually lead the nation. Their actions are defined by the future and the conditional, never the past tense. For Young England, the regeneration of the nation is still just over the horizon.
Tancred, skeptic that he is, is quick to point this out. He says to Sidney, “If a Parliamentary career could save this country, I am sure you would be a public benefactor. . . . But Parliament seems to me to be the very place which a man of action should avoid. . . . In this age it is not Parliament that does the real work . . . Parliament has become as really insignificant as for two centuries it has kept the monarch” (136–37; bk. 2, ch. 13). And although Tancred is still the naïve political ingénue, nothing in the narrative exists to contradict his evaluation. For instance, Sidney is shown to have been more active than both Coningsby and Marney, but he too has not yet made a lasting or palpable impact on the nation. His name was “significant of a career that would rescue public life from that strange union of lax principles and contracted sympathies which now form the special and degrading features of British politics” (134; bk. 2, ch. 13, emphasis added). Although he “seemed to possess all the qualities of a popular leader” (136; bk. 2, ch. 13, emphasis added), Sidney had not yet demonstrated his ability to lead.
Judging from the careers of the earlier Young England heroes, Tancred's view of Parliament as being a place of inaction seems quite valid. Thus, the last novel in the trilogy dismisses the path to reform espoused by Coningsby and Sybil – in Tancred, Parliament cannot solve the nation's problems. Moreover, this dissatisfaction with the more traditional method of affecting change (Parliament) is what prompts the hero of the third novel to set out on his quest for divine inspiration. The fact that Disraeli includes this scene with the protagonists from the earlier novels – a scene that is unnecessary to the basic plot of Tancred – emphasizes the connection between the politics of the first two Young England novels and those of the last while simultaneously highlighting the political nature of Tancred's mystical religious faith. Tancred does not venture to Jerusalem as a means of seeking (just) personal inspiration; he leaves England in search of a way to help his country.
Tancred arrives in Jerusalem with his mind full of spiritual musings and his heart set on receiving the sort of divine inspiration he felt could not be granted back in worldly, corrupt England. Instead of recognizing Jerusalem as a nineteenth-century city with political ties to England and the major European powers, Tancred sees the Holy Land only as the romanticized biblical vision he had dreamed about back home. He fails to consider the material ramifications of his residence in Jerusalem and quickly finds himself embroiled in what amounts to a criminal political scheme. News of his wealth circulates upon his arrival, and with this information, rumors of his political influence (he is mistakenly thought to be the brother of Queen Victoria). The Emir Fakredeen, a conniving and debt-plagued prince of the Lebanon, decides to take advantage of Tancred's presence by holding the English aristocrat for ransom. Although Tancred remains blind to it, his idealized land of mysticism and spirituality shows an uncanny resemblance to the politically-corrupt England he left behind.
Fortunately for Tancred, Fakredeen exists in a perpetual state of inconstancy and soon becomes enamored of the young English lord and his strange ideas. Tancred, in turn, becomes fascinated by Fakredeen's position as a Christian prince of the Lebanon and envies the possibilities his title and race bestow. When Fakredeen relates the history of his “combinations” with France and England, Tancred responds: “If you wish to free your country, and make the Syrians a nation, it is not to be done by sending secret envoys to Paris or London, cities themselves which are perhaps both doomed to fall; you must act like Moses and Mahomet” (258; bk. 4, ch. 3). Instead of recognizing the outlandishness of Fakredeen's schemes, Tancred takes the fanciful young prince seriously and encourages him to approach his political problems at their roots. Fakredeen also sparks in Tancred an interest in a new approach to reforming England: for the first time, Tancred begins to ponder ways in which he could go about reinvigorating England and Europe with the spiritual fervor of the Middle East.
When Tancred finally comes to understand, rather to his disappointment, that his captivity does not represent an opportunity for martyrdom, he resumes thinking about his reason for venturing to Jerusalem. Having won the heart of his captor, Tancred is allowed to travel to Mount Sinai, where he prays:
O lord God of Israel . . . I come . . . to pour forth the heart of tortured Europe. Why art thou silent? . . . Faith fades and duty dies. A profound melancholy has fallen on the spirit of man. The priest doubts, the monarch cannot rule, the multitude moans and toils, and calls in its frenzy upon unknown gods. If this transfigured mount may not again behold Thee . . . at least, of all the starry messengers that guard thy throne, let one appear, to save thy creatures from a terrible despair! (289; bk. 4, ch. 7)
Tancred's prayer emphasizes his commitment to social change – he does not seek personal consolation from above. Instead, his individual plea to God is made on behalf of “the multitude” and “tortured Europe.” His quest is not for personal development or spiritual favor, but for mass regeneration. Because he sees no one else in Europe seeking aid from the only source he believes capable of providing sufficient assistance, he takes the social burdens of Europe upon his own shoulders and carries them before God.
And God does not ignore his plea. In what is likely the strangest episode in the novel, Tancred actually receives a divine visitation. And, quite significantly, the angel who visits Tancred responds to the social dimension of his plea:
Yet again, and Europe is in the throes of a great birth. . . . But the eternal principles that controlled barbarian vigour can alone cope with morbid civilization. The quality of man can only be accomplished by the sovereignty of God . . . In the increased distance between God and man have grown up all those developments that have made life mournful. Cease, then, to seek in a vain philosophy the solution of the social problem that perplexes you. Announce the sublime and solacing doctrine of theocratic equality. Fear not, faint not, falter not. Obey the impulse of thine own spirit, and find a ready instrument in every human being. (290–91; bk. 4, ch. 7)
The angel's message is disappointingly oracular – Tancred journeyed to the Holy Land assuming that if he received divine communication, his heavenly messenger would give him particular instructions on how to change the world. While the angel does provide advice, that advice is not exactly of the practical nature Tancred had expected. The angel's command to “[a]nnounce the sublime and solacing doctrine of theocratic equality” is as good as saying, “Just put your faith in God.”
This message, while surprising to Tancred, does not seem all that unusual for a Victorian novel, considering that Christian brotherhood and a belief in things being better in the hereafter were, at the time, common responses to social problems. What makes Tancred so remarkable, however, is the way in which the novel rejects this philosophy. Tancred does not return to England to devote himself to charitable projects; he receives no solace from the “doctrine of theocratic equality” and is left in a state of greater confusion than when he departed England. He deems the angel's plan for social reform inadequate and begins to formulate his own scheme for affecting the change he desires.
The new plan Tancred advocates more closely resembles revolution than reform. He determines that he must unite the different countries and factions of “the Persian and Mesopotamian plains” through “a great religious truth” in order to “revivify Asia” (303; bk. 4, ch. 9). This, he believes, would set off a political and religious chain reaction: “The peninsula of Arabia, when in action, must always command the peninsula of the Lesser Asia. Asia revivified would act upon Europe” (303; bk. 4, ch. 9).Footnote 3 Tancred invents a plan that is expansive enough to address England's widespread problems, but the scope of his design dooms it to failure even before he attempts to put it into action. Tancred views the only solution to England's troubles as a complete revolution in the nation's (and Europe's) moral constitution that, because he is the only one who has the clarity of vision to see what needs to be done, he must single-handedly orchestrate. His plan is indeed heroic – the stuff of myths and legends – but what makes it heroic is also what makes it utterly impracticable.
Tancred, however, fails to understand that he is not the hero of an epic. He explains to the queen of the desert kingdom he visits: “We wish to conquer the world, with angels at our head, in order that we may establish the happiness of man by a divine dominion, and, crushing the political atheism that is now desolating existence, utterly extinguish the groveling tyranny of self-government” (422; bk. 6, ch. 3). Tancred's plan is far more radical and ambitious than that of his Young England predecessors. Instead of calling for gradual, liberal reform, he condemns liberalism and proposes a theocratic, anti-liberal revolution. The result of this scheme is fantastic and surprisingly un-English: “[A]nd then, when the East has resumed its indigenous intelligence, when angels and prophets again mingle with humanity, the sacred quarter of the globe will recover its primeval and divine supremacy” (428; bk. 6, ch. 4). Tancred's solution to “political atheism” is to eliminate European politics altogether, to give Europe a fresh start by restoring the power and influence of a presumably pure and “primeval” Asia.
But just as Tancred becomes fully immersed in his own delusions, his idealism is brought to an abrupt end as he is forced to recognize the political reality of his own existence. Through a convoluted detour in the romantic plot that ends in Fakredeen's betrayal of Tancred, the English lord is made to see the impracticality of his international plan. His dream of saving Europe through Asia crumbles as he is forced to recognize that Asia, too, is full of moral corruption.
Although Tancred is stripped of his romantic delusions, he does not recognize his mistakes in a way characteristic of what Clausson terms the ironic Bildüngsroman (such as Scott's Waverley, for example) (1). Unlike in Waverley, the point of the narrative has not been to teach the hero a lesson and transform him into a functional member of society. Rather, the novel traces a socially-conscious young man's efforts to remedy the problems that plague his nation. Tancred is not simply a silly young man who views the world through a comically romantic lens. Instead, he is shown throughout the novel to be of nobler and more genuine sentiment than anyone around him (save Sidonia and Eva, the novel's heroine); the problems with England and Europe he identifies are taken seriously by the narrative (and are emphasized and developed in Coningsby and Sybil), and the novel offers no contrasting view in order to suggest that Tancred's social diagnosis is incorrect. His disillusionment – however necessary – is tragic rather than comforting, for his failure to find a means for regenerating England is not simply a personal loss.
As the final Young England hero, Tancred's failure also represents the failure of his predecessors and of reform more generally. More significantly, his narrative ends without providing any hope or validation for the hero, suggesting bleak prospects for the future. No longer is the success of the nation just beyond the horizon; all the glimmerings of hope offered by the endings of the other Young England novels are lost in the murky grayness of uncertainty that permeates the conclusion of the final novel.
This uncertainty is highlighted by the novel's lack of closure for the marriage plot, a narrative refusal that marks a sharp distinction between Tancred and its predecessors. In Coningsby and Sybil, the hero's romantic success confirms his potential for political success. The conclusion of Tancred appears to head down the same narrative path, as the novel's heroine, Eva, is the only character who recognizes the tragedy of Tancred's failure. She perceptively remarks, “I have a vague impression that there have been heroic aspirations wasted, and noble energies thrown away; and yet, perhaps, there is no one to blame. Perhaps, all this time, we have been dreaming over an unattainable end, and the only source of deception is our own imagination” (485; bk. 6, ch. 12). She goes on to lament the loss of Tancred's heroic innocence: “Your feelings cannot be what they were before all this happened; when you thought only of a divine cause, of stars, of angels, and of our peculiar and gifted land. No, no; now it is all mixed up with intrigue, and politics, and management, and baffled schemes, and cunning arts of men. . . . You no longer believe in Arabia” (485; bk. 6, ch. 12). As a Jewish woman whose family has both Arab and European ties, Eva has been at the center of religious and political conflicts her entire life. Like Sidonia, Eva offers a more practical and informed view of the world than does Tancred, which makes her sympathy for his cause and her sorrow at his disillusionment all the more significant. Because Eva takes Tancred seriously, we are encouraged to do so as well. She seems to offer the wisdom and grounded perspective that Tancred needs to get beyond his loss of political and religious faith, and as marriage functions as the springboard for political action in the earlier Young England novels, Eva presents the potential for Tancred's political salvation.
This marriage plot is not, however, as simple as those in Coningsby and Sybil, for Tancred and Eva are divided by national, religious, and ethnic barriers. Tancred attempts to disregard these difficulties, pleading, “Talk not to me of others, of those who have claims on you or on myself. I have no kindred, no country, and, as for the ties that would bind you, shall such world-worn bonds restrain our consecrated aim? Say but you love me, and I will trample them to the dust” (486; bk. 6, ch. 12). Tancred's claims of having no country and no kindred are of course untrue, and his belief in his ability to conquer “world-worn bonds” is as quixotic as his former political plan. Eva responds by saying, “Oh! this is madness!” (486; bk. 6, ch. 12) before fainting, leaving Tancred's proposal unanswered. Unlike Coningsby and Egremont, Tancred is denied even the comfort and solace of a happy marriage.
As if this were not enough to wrench the rose-tinted glasses from our hero's eyes, Tancred's meeting with the now-unconscious Eva is interrupted by his servants, who come to inform him of the arrival of his parents in Jerusalem (487; bk. 6, ch. 12). And it is with this contradiction of Tancred's claim of having no kindred that the novel ends. England in effect follows Tancred to Jerusalem, and he is unable even for a few moments to ignore his familial and national ties. What is to become of him, we do not know, but it seems highly unlikely that his relationship with Eva, who shows no sign of abandoning her religion or her family, could continue. Thus, the hero's final disillusionment – his failure to have his love reciprocated or validated – ends his narrative. Much like his Cervantean ancestor, the end of his quixotic adventures must also be the end of his tale.
Perhaps more significant, however, is the fact that this abrupt ending also functions as the conclusion of the entire trilogy. All of the social problems illuminated in Coningsby and Sybil remain at the close of Tancred, and the final, most promising hero is thwarted in every one of his plans. Contrary to Clausson's argument that the end of Tancred is very similar to that of Waverley, Tancred concludes by refusing to resort to the superficial fusion of opposing political views characteristic of Scott's works. Tancred has no Rose Bradwardine with whom to set up house and live the happy, carefree life of an English nobleman. Instead, he is haunted by his awareness of the nation's problems, doomed to a future of uncertainty and unease, and then deprived of the one source of consolation he sees available to him – Eva. Europe and Asia cannot be so easily joined in a disregard for difference as England and Scotland are at the end of Waverley. The later hero must, then, remain alone, without romantic, spiritual, or political solace.
This lack of closure for the novel and the trilogy as a whole is, however, both logical and appropriate. The recognition that there are no simple answers to England's tremendously complex and deeply-rooted social problems and the refusal to offer any simplistic solutions reflect a more mature, sophisticated understanding of the “condition of England” than the idealistic political agenda of Coningsby and Sybil. Tancred belongs to a different tradition of reform literature than do its predecessors – one that places Disraeli more in line with Carlyle and the later Dickens than with the “industrial” writers such as Gaskell and Kingsley, with whom he is usually categorized. Moreover, Tancred shows that a novel does not need factories or grime in order to be political and that exotic queens and desert pirates can be just as relevant to politics and reform as prime ministers and MPs. By reading Tancred as a political novel, we are able not only to gain a fuller sense of the complexity of Disraeli's nearly-tragic views on the condition of England in the 1840s but also to reevaluate and expand our notion of what counts as political or social fiction.
