With Brazil Imagined, Darlene Sadlier has produced a comprehensive review of the cultural themes shaping Brazilian identity from its ‘discovery’ by Europeans through to the present day. Acknowledging the varied methods utilised by scholars who locate identity as a central question in Brazilian society, the author diverges from traditional anthropological, historical, economic, political or legal approaches and underscores cultural references in the shaping of national identity. Images of Brazil are continually changing, and this evolution contributes to Brazilian senses of self and outside assessments of the country and its people. Sadlier asserts that European explorers, gazers and colonisers heavily influenced identity and shaped Brazilian artistic inclinations. However, Brazilians now possess the necessary self-confidence and skills to construct expansive works of art that consider individual and collective experience. Examining valuable visual, literary and artistic materials, Sadlier investigates Brazilian identities in the context of globalisation over five centuries in order to enhance our insight into this influential society.
National identity has long preoccupied scholars of Latin America, and Brazil is no exception. The publication of Benedict Anderson's Imagined Communities in 1983 spurred scholarship in multiple disciplines. Anderson explored the social attitudes and material circumstances that influenced conceptions of nationhood; he argued that print capitalism encouraged a sense of comradeship in which people envisioned a community despite limited contact with others. Critics of Anderson, such as François-Xavier Guerra, argued that Imagined Communities excluded Brazil, while William Rowe and Vivian Schelling highlighted the omission of popular culture, oral traditions and iconography in Anderson's study. Brazil Imagined is a unique addition, addressing a lacuna in the literature on Latin America by concentrating on Brazil, and offering a comprehensive study of the principal artistic and literary influences that were in play during prominent historical moments.
Contrasting images of Brazil as a tropical paradise troubled by barbarism and misery constituted artistic and literary images during the colonial period. In asserting culture as a place to measure senses of self, Sadlier's study predictably begins with the early imagery of natives produced by Europeans. Concerned with the opposing archetypes of Eden and barbarism, Sadlier outlines early perceptions of Brazil as a natural paradise that were followed by descriptions of the country as a swampy and oppressive environment. Evoking the sentiment of Portuguese exploration and imperialism, Pero Vaz de Caminha's descriptions of the land and people confirmed a sense of founding, discovery and aesthetic delight that evoked imagery of peaceful bliss. Gradually, sixteenth-century ethnographers advanced the notion of barbaric natives in Brazil, and Sadlier highlights the remarkable work of Johann Theodor de Bry and the artist's influential promotion of beast over paradise. Chapter 1 examines multiple fifteenth-century images from the Lilly Library collection at Indiana University.
According to Sadlier, the nineteenth century witnessed a transition in the imaginary of Brazil, bringing to light Brazilian artists and writers who sought a ‘national’ literature. A pivotal shift in the book, chap. 4 underscores the gradual development of a national literary imaginary through the incorporation of topics and protagonists specific to Brazil. Brazil Imagined charts the recordings of various European artists and literary figures into the nineteenth century, and reveals the problematic issues of race and ethnicity that troubled Brazilian novelists. Expounding upon the contributions of Doris Sommer, who traces the noble savage in works by José de Alencar in Foundational Fictions, Sadlier identifies European romanticism as a fundamental influence on Alencar and the poet Antônio Gonçalves Dias, among others. The second half of the nineteenth century marks a shift in literary trends, and Sadlier underscores an urban, proto-modern awareness. Joaquim Manuel de Macedo, for example, wrestled with slavery and abolition, while Machado de Assis satirised late nineteenth-century order, progress and reliance upon scientific empiricism.
The images of twentieth-century Brazil are contradictory, with the tension between progress and its antithesis – poverty, violence, corruption, illegality – constituting the major theme. Modifications of artistic, literary, architectural and musical productions aimed at making them more ‘Brazilian’ culminated in a modernist movement that peaked during the 1922 Modern Art Week held in São Paulo. The modernist trend was a significant shift in cultural invention, emphasising an endemic national refinement capable of absorbing, rather than imitating, foreign trends. Twentieth-century Brazilian cultural developments were increasingly public, allowing for wider circulation and larger audiences and resulting in a more confident domestic creation.
Tracing recent trends in popular culture, the epilogue leaves Brazil's future undefined, albeit in constant fluctuation, and shaped by the media. Highly politicised visual culture exerts a powerful influence on Brazilian and foreign audiences. Foreign persuasion was illustrated in the infamous 2002 ‘Blame it on Lisa’ episode of The Simpsons, for instance – harkening back to the savage imaginary that has plagued the country, the episode mocked stereotypes of US tourists abroad and brought stereotypes of Brazilians to the forefront. The result was anger among citizens, tourist agencies and political leaders in Brazil.
Appropriate for college level, Brazil Imagined presents a country whose national identity has developed internally and has been influenced from the outside. Highlighting dominant artistic and literary trends, Sadlier analyses competing images and oscillating themes from the colonial period to the present. Concluding that the legacies of colonialism continue to affect creative movements, this text highlights the contradictions of order and progress, arguing that poverty and its accompanying predicaments have produced a distressed population. At the same time, citizens have greater opportunities to participate in the production of culture and to influence the continually evolving sense of Brazilianness.
