How did the Ottomans’ traumatic experience of World War I, and their defeat in particular, affect the shape of Turkish national identity? How did World War I reshape Turkish nationalism? These general questions inform Yücel Yanıkdağ's original work, in which he focuses on two specific groups: Ottoman prisoners of war held captive during World War I in various camps in Egypt and Russia; and Ottoman-Turkish neuropsychiatrists who conducted medical examinations on them and on Ottoman-enlisted men in general. What brings these quite distinct groups, neither of which has received sufficient attention in the historiography of the Ottoman Empire and World War I, together in a monograph is not merely the fact that many prisoners of war were medically examined by the neuropsychiatrists after their repatriation. Rather, it is the author's interest in the similarity of their reactions to the threat of national decline and destruction because of the Great War. By analyzing the discourses surrounding these reactions, the book explores the strategies of national survival produced by these two groups. The main anxiety of both groups was to regenerate the declining nation. Confronted with the fear of losing their cultural and national identity in the prisoner camps (especially those in Russia where the POWs of different nationalities were imprisoned together), the prisoners of war developed a contentious sense of community and constructed a national identity based on a stark distinction between “us” and “others.” The Ottoman-Turkish neuropsychiatrists perceived a biological (both physical and mental) degeneration of the nation and proposed an intervention to halt further decline, which gave rise to eugenicist practices in Turkey in the post–World War I years.
The book is composed of two parts. The first part (Chaps. 1–4) deals with Ottoman POWs. Yanıkdağ begins with a discussion of statistics on the POWs. Statistics of Ottoman casualties during World War I have always been a problematic field due to insufficient, poorly compiled, and sometimes deliberately distorted data, but the total number of Ottoman POWs seems to be the most inconsistent category, with various published sources giving numbers as disparate as 66,000, 145,000, and 202,000. Yanıkdağ critically examines the available data in both the published and primary sources to make an informed estimate of a total number of 250,000 POWs, of which around 150,000 were held captive by the British in the Egyptian camps (p. 20).
Among the many significant details that Yanıkdağ supplies about the difficult living conditions in the camps in Egypt and Russia, the most striking one is the existence of widespread diseases (both contagious and noncontagious). While typhus and tuberculosis were the most deadly diseases in the Russian camps, pellagra and trachoma were more prominent in Egypt. We learn that in both Egypt and Russia, the death rate among Ottoman POWs was always higher than that among German and Austro-Hungarian POWs in the same camps. As the POWs began to be gradually repatriated from Egypt to Turkey beginning in 1919, their poor health and the diseases they carried (especially trachoma) alarmed the Turkish authorities, giving rise to official protests against the British authorities, which turned the POWs, as the author puts it, into “contested political and medical objects” (p. 154). During the Turkish War of Independence (1919–22), the newly founded Ankara government jumped on this issue in order to strengthen its own legitimacy in Anatolia and prepared a resolution in 1921 relating to the repatriated prisoners blinded due to trachoma. The resolution claimed that, “English doctors, commandants, and officers had purposefully invalided 15,000 prisoners” (p. 154). In this politicized medical contestation (from which no considerable outcome emerged), the Turkish argument was that the neglect of British authorities caused many Turkish deaths in the prison camps and that trachoma and other diseases associated with the POWs came from the outside and threatened general health conditions in Anatolia.
Some exprisoners contributed to this protest by making their own accusations in captivity narratives. For example, Eyüp Sabri Bey, who was imprisoned in Egypt, made a highly speculative claim (in congruence with the post-1915 nationalist atmosphere) that Armenian doctors in the Egyptian camps collaborated with the British in “removing” the eyes of Ottoman prisoners. The British, however, insisted that Ottoman prisoners’ diseases stemmed from poor health conditions in their own country and that they were already infected or prone to be infected before their arrival to the camps. This discussion is equally important for revealing how the medical profession could be politicized and act in congruence with nationalist ideology.
The first part of the book also devotes substantial analysis to understanding how the Ottoman POWs developed a national identity in the prison camps. This process is particularly detectable in the Russian camps, where the Ottomans had to share the same camp with German and Austro-Hungarian POWs. Referring to the “narcissism of minor differences” (p. 47), Yanıkdağ argues that fear of assimilation and anxiety over imitating others (i.e., Europeans) compelled imprisoned Ottoman officers to emphasize their cultural distinction and to “imagine” their national identity. By using previously untapped sources such as camp newspapers and ego documents (diaries and memoirs) written mostly by officers, Yanıkdağ traces how this identity construction revealed itself in the daily lives of prisoners, arguing that “national culture is also rooted in ‘trivial’ or banal aspects of identity and identification” (p. 70). In this sense, the officer prisoners behaved as if they were representatives of the state and the nation in a foreign land, a microcosm of a national elite in the camp context. In their idealized construction, the main obstacle to regenerating the nation was ignorance, which they perceived as the most notable feature of the peasant soldiers whom they had the opportunity to closely observe in the camps. Their obsession with educating the simple peasant so that he might join the civilized nation, as the author aptly implies, probably had repercussions for the early Turkish republican elite's emphasis on education as a panacea. This important discussion on how Ottoman POWs imagined the nation and national identity would be more complete had the author made an attempt to analyze how the precaptivity experience of nationalism among these officers, many of whom were members of the Young Turk generation, affected their sense of national identity in this process.
In the second part of the book (Chaps. 4–5), Yanıkdağ presents a pioneering analysis of Ottoman-Turkish neuropsychiatrists from World War I through the early republican years. Followers of the current medical practice in Europe, these doctors diagnosed Ottoman soldiers who experienced nervous breakdowns on the front as “hysterics” and “malingerers,” and repatriated POWs as “schizophrenics.” In their treatment, they insisted that the war was not responsible for the men's mental illness, but only served to reveal the dormant pathologies already existing within them. Despite the sizable number of war neurotics among the Ottomans (the author estimates roughly 39,000 permanent and 117,000 temporary cases [p. 179]), the neuropsychiatrists still denied a connection between war and mental illness not only because of their participation in a militaristic culture, but also, and perhaps more importantly, because they regarded themselves as servants of the military and the nation through their profession; they perceived “degeneracy” as the biggest danger to the collective national body.
The Ottoman neuropsychiatrists did not necessarily act out of racist assumptions and Yanıkdağ did not find any evidence of ethnic discrimination in their treatment of war victims. However, they feared that if unchecked, “degenerates” would multiply and put the health of the nation in danger. As this fear grew in the later 1920s and early 1930s, they turned to eugenics for national regeneration or rebirth. In an effort led by Mazhar Osman Uzman, the doctors tried to convince those in power of the necessity of eugenicist practices. For example, in order to “reduce the number of insane people,” Mazhar Osman declared that psychiatry needed to “intervene in matters of marriage”: because mental illnesses were hereditary, “the marriage of nervous people” had to be prevented (p. 228). While not all such proposals were accepted by state officials, the doctors’ efforts, according to Yanıkdağ, resulted in the adoption of such practices by the republican state as official policy. But here one could perhaps ask whether the author attributes too much agency to the neuropsychiatrists and does not sufficiently take into account the nationalist ideology of the Kemalist elite, especially during the 1930s. Did the early republican regime decide to embrace eugenics only because the doctors convinced the power elite to do so, or was a eugenicist perspective already regarded legitimate in the ideology of that power elite?
Healing the Nation is especially notable for its incorporation of rich and unique archival sources. However, despite the author's appreciable effort to tie them together, the book still gives the impression that it is a compilation of two different research projects (on the POWs and on the neuropsychiatrists) brought together in a single volume. This dual character of the text does not diminish the book's originality, but it may cause some important analyses in the first part on the POWs to remain somewhat isolated. For example, considering the amount of empirical research the author devotes to analyzing Ottoman prisoners’ national identity construction in the camps, one would expect a more thorough discussion, albeit speculative in nature, of whether the prisoners’ experience with imagining the nation and national identity played any determining role in shaping Turkish nationalism after their repatriation. What possible influences did this captivity experience, which apparently produced a strong sense of distancing oneself from “the other,” exert on Turkish nationalism in its nation-state form during the early republican years? Although such questions await answers, this book, through its focus on the role played by POWs and the medical profession, broadens our understanding of how World War I reshaped Turkish nationalism.
