It is clear from the acknowledgements that Marni Gauthier's first monograph has had a lengthy gestation: it began life as her PhD dissertation at the University of Colorado at Boulder in 2001 and was finally published in its present form ten years later. Over this period, it has become more sharply focussed, more ambitious in scope and more explicitly political: it has evolved from a discussion of the ways in which a range of late twentieth-century American novels “critique and rewrite myths that underpin America; myths of innocence, including the American West as ‘virgin land’; myths of America as paradise; myths informed by the discourse of ‘free enterprise’; and myths of American exceptionalism and Puritan origin” (25) to encompass the ways in which twenty-first-century fictions have responded to historical traumas such as 9/11.
Identifying a “corpus of contemporary fiction that … articulates a politics of truth” (2), Gauthier argues that this corpus constitutes “a new genre of historical novel” that “performs a vital cultural work: telling the truth in an age of amnesia and redress” (3–4). She differentiates this historical novel from its precursors, arguing that whereas “the traditional historical novel” constructed a “faithful historical ‘type’” and “historiographic metafiction” merely problematized “the nature and status of our information about the past,” these texts “present counterhistories to received versions of the American past” (19). Divided into six chapters, bookended by a prologue and epilogue, Amnesia and Redress in Contemporary American Fiction explores the ways in which a range of authors, from the canonical (Toni Morrison and Don DeLillo), to the semi-canonical (Bharati Mukherjee), to the marginal (Julie Otsuka) “challenge notions of what constitutes collectivity,” “by depicting peoples who represent the point of fracture between America as a homogeneous, consensual community and the forces that arise out of contentious, unequal interests and identities within the population” (39). Combining thoughtful, attentive close readings of her key texts with a wide-ranging theoretical consideration of the fraught relationship between truth, fact, fiction, myth, history and narrative, Gauthier steers a skilful course between the Scylla of “tendentious postmodernism” and the Charybdis of “platitudinous humanism” (35). In this sense, the book clearly benefits from the decade of research and revision that Gauthier has put into it. In other ways, however, the fact that it has clearly been redrafted a number of times creates certain structural and stylistic tensions.
For example, in the Prologue Gauthier explains that the book “illuminates the incongruity between denial and a particularly American forgetting on the one hand and recent international concern with public acknowledgement and official apology on the other” (3), only to repeat this formulation almost verbatim twenty pages later, in the first chapter: “Amnesia and Redress illuminates the incongruity between the recent international concern with public acknowledgement and official apology – and denial and a particularly American forgetting” (23). On the one hand, Gauthier has taken great pains to ensure that the book takes into account recent developments in scholarship: what she describes as the “new hemispheric writing” (102) and “the new spatial imaginaries of trans-American studies – the borderlands/la frontera, the Black Atlantic, and the circum-Caribbean,” to which, she argues, “Mukherjee adds the Indian Ocean” (123). On the other hand, there are conspicuous gaps in the bibliography, most notably of recent work on 9/11 literature by critics such as Richard Gray, and much of the book's considerable energy, particularly in the earlier sections, is devoted to detailed discussions of discourses and concepts that were vital in the 1980s and 1990s but arguably rather less so today: the “Foucauldian approach to history” (34); “Homi Bhabha's concept of the nation as narration” (23); debates about definitions of, and distinctions between, post-structuralism and postmodernism. When Gauthier announces that “Amnesia and Redress takes up where Linda Hutcheon's and Frederic Jameson's respective seminal studies, A Poetics of Postmodernism (1988) and Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism (1991) leave off” (4), she runs the risk of both overstating the importance of the book (by placing it in such august company) and selling herself short (by implying, misleadingly, that it is simply an intervention in debates that have now run their course). The book's graduate-school origins are perhaps visible here, and certainly in the curious reference to Norman Mailer's first novel as the “top-ranked The Naked and the Dead” (45) and the claim that “the historical novels The Sun Also Rises, Absalom! Absalom!, and Beloved (concerning World War I, the Civil War, and slavery, respectively), among others, show us … [that] writers have an especial capacity to articulate, expose and reckon with large-scale traumas to which victims can seldom fully testify or convey” (168).
In spite of these flaws, however, overall Amnesia and Redress is a perceptive, invigorating and thought-provoking book – not perhaps one that will redefine its field but certainly one that responds sensitively to the “the paradigmatic shift in American studies to a transnational perspective of history and a broader collective sensibility that reflects this” (151), and one that will prove very valuable to students and scholars of contemporary American fiction.
