These two books present a systematic study of the main institutional features of eighteen Latin American legislatures. The first contains a detailed comparison of electoral laws and national constitutions, while the second analyses how those institutional frameworks shape legislative activity in each country. Together the books provide a great deal of data and discussion about legislative politics and the constitutional and legal factors that potentially influence them. The data and theoretical overviews are welcome and useful, providing much needed information for future theorising about and testing of the suggested relationships.
The first book, El poder legislativo en América Latina a través de sus normas, contains a well-organised comparison of the main features of Latin American legislatures. For each of the eighteen countries, the authors detail the legal framework governing the legislatures with regard to five main themes. The first chapter covers the composition of the legislature (i.e. electoral laws), formal powers, immunity and other general characteristics. The second theme is representation. Here the authors consider public legislative sessions, minority representation, and provide detailed data about parties and their legislative contingents. The other chapters focus on the legislative process, oversight of the executive, and the legislatures' organisation. This last chapter is particularly notable, as it has extended information about committees, an important topic that has escaped much academic scrutiny.
While this first book is primarily a compilation of legal factors affecting legislative processes, it is a very valuable research tool. It will aid future theorists in two important ways: First, the authors' exhaustive compilation of information allows institutional theorists a solid database from which to develop analytical comparisons. In addition to constitutions, the authors compiled information about electoral laws, party rules, and legislative rules that are not easily obtainable. They have thus provided much grist for future researchers. Second, the types of information that the authors have compiled should generate multiple theoretical questions. By providing details about house rules, for example, future studies can test theories about the importance of these types of institutions on legislative behaviour. The information on committees, likewise, can lead to studies about the inner workings of the legislature.
The second book, Funciones, procedimientos y escenarios: un análisis de poder legislativo en América Latina, explores how the different institutional frameworks of each legislature affect legislative functions, performance, and the relationship with the executive branch. Using the vast empirical data from the companion volume, the authors break these issues into six chapters with the following themes: presidentialism; the legislative process and functions; oversight; representation with a base on territoriality; the role of the legislature in dealing with the budget; and legislative committees.
The authors begin their analysis by focusing on presidentialism and executive-legislative relations. The first chapter provides a useful theoretical overview of the debate supplemented by their large database. Their data allows them to speak to questions about legislators' ambitions, the timing of elections, and the relation of presidents to multi-party legislatures and other themes. The second chapter seeks to relate legislative processes to the strength of legislatures. They thus provide an extensive review (and data) of the factors influencing the legislative process, such as the constitutional limitations on the legislature and how bills are assigned to committees, and interesting comparisons about legislative success and other aspects of the dependent variable. The discussion is useful and the data revealing, although the chapter is limited because the authors are unable to provide a test relating institutional variation to legislative behaviour.
The third chapter explores different ways that legislatures can influence governments and presidents. The authors present a detailed analysis of the Latin American legislatures' different oversight mechanisms and use these indicators to construct an index to identify the potential control capacities of individual legislatures. Among the variables the authors consider are investigatory committees, votes of confidence regarding ministers, rules regarding questioning the executive and soliciting documents, censure and impeachment. The resulting index is very novel and, like Shugart and Carey's (1992) coding of presidential powers, could be a very useful independent variable in further study.
The fourth chapter turns to representation in terms of what the authors call ‘territoriality’. This unique chapter is based on concerns with ethnic and regional representation and political identities. Again the data yields an interesting discussion, here surrounding two main issues: the nationalisation of parties and legislators' survey responses to the importance of regional versus provincial issues.
The fifth chapter introduces the different mechanisms for elaborating and approving the budget, mainly answering the who and how questions of the process. The authors supplement their descriptions with empirical evidence to demonstrate a direct relationship between budget size and the number of congresspersons, as well as between budget size and national GDP. As in other chapters, the authors provide extensive information about how the different presidential regimes in the region affect the budget-making process but do not attempt to develop and test a thesis.
The last chapter of the book presents a detailed description of legislative committees. Here the discussion includes data about the types of committees in each country (permanent, specialty, investigatory, etc.), the committees' mandates, party control of committee membership, and committee size.
In sum, these two volumes provide much grist that future scholars can mill. The authors provide extensive data about the formal institutional differences among the Latin American legislatures, suggesting that these differences affect executive-legislative relations, representation and the policy process. What remains, however, is careful testing to see when and how these institutional differences contribute to the legislatures' functions and practices.
