No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
Our knowledge of Ottoman social history has made great strides over the past quarter-century, and in most of this scholarship, urban history has led the way. Ottoman Syria has proved a particularly fertile field for investigation because of its unusually high rate of urbanization—upward of 15 to 20 percent of the total population—which made it one of the most urbanized regions in the Ottoman Empire. The scholarship has definitely had its preferences. Most authors, following the path of least resistance, have turned their attention to Aleppo and Damascus, the two biggest towns, which produced the overwhelming share of literary, legal, and administrative documents and have largely shaped our image of urban life. Yet in point of fact, most townspeople lived in the more numerous small towns (in the range of 10,000–30,000 inhabitants) such as Tripoli, Homs, Acre, Nablus, and Jerusalem, which despite their modest size are really more representative of the urban experience. James Reilly's fine study of Ottoman Hama, his small town of choice, advances our effort to create a more comprehensive view of urban life in Syria.
From the outset, Reilly's work takes a frankly local perspective, relying almost exclusively on local sources. Hama has bequeathed little of its literary and religious output and appears infrequently in travelers' accounts; moreover, European consular reports are not really abundant until the final decades of Ottoman rule. The bulk of his material must therefore come from the records of the Islamic courts, which have been so essential in the writing of other urban histories. His strategy, which aims at breadth of coverage, is to sample three volumes of cases from widely spaced points in time (1727–34, 1788–1800, 1849–52).
Reilly presents Hama as a “microcosm” of trends found elsewhere in late Ottoman Syria and sounds familiar themes from the historical literature. He finds broad similarities in social and economic structure, such as the near-universal practice of monogamy, the importance of craft corporations, and the adaptability of local industry in the face of international competition in the 19th century. Occupying center stage through most of the book are the urban notables, a small clique of wily and resilient families who stood at the summit of local society. They held property throughout the city; managed large pious foundations; engaged in money-lending; and enjoyed multiple links with merchants and artisans, who actively sought their protection and mediation. Most critical to the notables' success was domination of the surrounding hinterland, which in the 18th century was achieved mostly through the purchase of lucrative tax farms. In the aftermath of mid-19th-century land reform, they patiently exploited the new laws and accumulated the large estates for which they were later remembered (and reviled). As Reilly shows, their power went largely unchallenged. Peasants hardly ever brought lawsuits to the courthouse, which was tacitly recognized as the notables' domain. All these developments, he stresses, were not a feature of “traditional” society—an image so frequently associated with Hama—but an outgrowth of late Ottoman history.
In placing the accent on similarities to other Syrian towns, Reilly has less to say about the distinctive features of Hama and, more generally, of small-scale urbanism. This is surprising because he is certainly aware of these questions and scatters a number of tantalizing hints throughout the book. He notes that, in contrast to Aleppo and Damascus, in Hama very few women owned commercial property. He further finds, in a partial parallel to Nablus (as studied by Beshara Doumani), that women who belonged to the “elite”—(that is, military and administrative households—are curiously absent from the property records of the shari

a court. The latter observation rests on a refinement of the well-known “politics of notables.” Borrowing from Julia Clancy-Smith, he breaks down the urban leadership into “elite” and “notable” families, arguing that each group drew on fundamentally different sources of wealth and authority. “Elite” families such as the

Azms originated outside the city and owed their position primarily to the Ottoman state, which appointed them to tax farms and other offices deep in the city's hinterland. “Notables” such as the Kaylanis and

Alwanis represented leading ulema, Sufis, and ashrāf, who tended to own property near the city and enjoy a certain prestige and moral suasion among local townspeople. This subtle division of turf is quite interesting because it is not so visible in Aleppo and Damascus. In the case of Hama, one wonders whether it might help to explain the pronounced continuity and stability of local politics. The city suffered little of the factional violence that racked Aleppo and Damascus for much of the 18th and early 19th centuries.
One of the chief virtues of Reilly's book is that it helps to lay the groundwork for precisely the kind of comparative thinking that is so needed in Ottoman studies. He addresses key debates in urban history and adds to our knowledge of an overlooked city. His research is careful and detailed, and his presentation is clear and accessible. His book is recommended for all students of Ottoman and Syrian history and to anyone who has an interest in Middle Eastern towns.