Baseball fans are a critical lot. They also tend to be historically minded and to care deeply about “their” teams, often drawing on loyalties formed early in life. Yet some baseball universals transcend the biases of fanhood—“fan” is short for fanatic—and one example is the number generally accepted today as the game's theme song. “Take Me Out to the Ball Game” is a true American evergreen, known to fans and nonfans alike. Published in 1908, the song was a century old last year, and the U.S. Postal Service issued a stamp to mark the occasion. Now we have a book seeking to tell “the story” of an enduring musical composition.Footnote 1 How appealing or useful to readers of the Journal of the Society for American Music is this thirty-dollar item likely to be? My own short answer leans toward the positive. The main story offered here is neither clearly told nor musically engaging. Yet the book is pictorially rich, it brims with information about the song (endnotes provide documentation), the accompanying CD contains sixteen performances from different eras, and there are things here to admire and love.
Baseball's Greatest Hit is the work of three authors: Andy Strasberg, a California-based sports marketing consultant; Bob Thompson, a musician and associate dean of the Conservatory of Music at Purchase College, State University of New York; and Tim Wiles, a librarian and director of research at the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum in Cooperstown, New York. Printed on glossy paper in a large format (8 × 11) by Hal Leonard Books, the work amounts to a generously illustrated album: a miscellany of short articles, images, and lists relating to the origin and history of “Take Me Out to the Ball Game,” with words by Jack Norworth, music by Albert Von Tilzer, and first published by the York Music Co., a Tin Pan Alley firm managed by the composer.
The book belongs to no known genre of scholarship and comes with no statement of purpose except its title. The introduction, usually an author's chance to explain, is written by Allan H. “Bud” Selig, Commissioner of Major League Baseball, whose agenda is broader than the book's. Therefore, it is up to the reader to figure out the authors' strategy. The thirteen pages of front matter do not help much. Listing fifty-one individually titled sections, the table of contents begins and ends with standard rubrics—“Foreword,” “Acknowledgments,” and “Introduction,” as well as “Discography,” “Notes,” “Bibliography,” “Text and Image Permissions,” and “Index.” In between, however, headings consist of teasers that disguise their subject, apparently seeking a playful spirit: “Hit or Myth,” “Can Pigeons Carry a Tune?,” “Andy Plays Post Office,” and “Got 'Im, Got 'Im, Need 'Im, Got 'Im.” Yet even after the subjects are revealed, readers get little guidance about the book's ideas or its organization. One section reports, for example, that Harvard psychologist B. F. Skinner—a Red Sox fan, we learn—trained pigeons to “peck out such simple tunes as . . . ‘Take Me Out To the Ball Game’” as part of his study of reward and punishment (84). Were this fact linked to a clearer idea or narrative, it might prompt a sympathetic smile more readily than a cranky “who cares?”
The first page of the book proper (1) carries a facsimile of the lyrics (first stanza of the verse, plus refrain) in the hand of Jack Norworth, who wrote them. Two more sections intervene before an authorial voice is raised. The first (2–5), by sportswriter Ira Berkow of the New York Times, reflects on why “Take Me Out to the Ball Game,” traditionally sung during the seventh-inning stretch in ballparks across the United States, gave way to “God Bless America” in the wake of the September 11, 2001, attacks on New York City and Washington, D.C. Then comes a “Prologue” (6–7) recounting the death of Albert Von Tilzer, the song's composer, followed by a facsimile of his New York Times obituary.
On page 8 the authors emerge from the shadows. Their first section, headed “Unsung Heroes” (8–15), amounts to a joint biography of lyricist Norworth (1879–1958) and composer Von Tilzer (1878–1956), who seem to have had little personal connection, except in the writing of “Take Me Out to the Ball Game.” Each was a figure of some stature: Norworth as a songwriter and headline vaudeville and Broadway entertainer—he also cowrote “Shine On, Harvest Moon”—and Von Tilzer as a prolific composer and publisher. Yet each was overshadowed a bit by a talented counterpart: Norworth by popular singing star Nora Bayes (1880–1928), to whom he was married for several years and with whom he performed widely, and Von Tilzer by his brother Harry (1872–1946), also a successful composer of songs—he wrote the music for “Wait till the Sun Shines, Nellie”—and an even more prominent song publisher.
“Unsung Heroes” starts with a question fundamental to the book: “Who has done the most to popularize baseball in our culture?” The slate of possibilities points to where the authors' true interests lie. Only one player makes the list: Babe Ruth, the game's most fabled slugger. Other candidates include Henry Chadwick (“the first baseball writer”), cartoonist Charles Schulz (no less than 10 percent of his Peanuts strip is said to have been baseball centered), and Sy Berger (whose Topps bubble gum company “popularized baseball card collecting in the 1950s”). Here, then, is the authors' context for Norworth and Von Tilzer. As creators of the game's “greatest hit,” they are candidates for “a Hall of Fame for promoting baseball,” should such an institution ever materialize. The notion of their song as an advertisement for professional baseball, and for commercial products linked to the game, is the book's overriding theme. The unsung heroes who dominate Baseball's Greatest Hit made their mark through marketing accomplishments.
The next article, “Hit or Myth?” (16–23), centers chiefly on Norworth's original manuscript of the words. Interviewed later in life, he reported that, while riding the New York subway, he had “spotted an ad for the Polo Grounds advertising a ball game that day” and, inspired by the moment, promptly composed the words to “Take Me Out to the Ball Game.” Von Tilzer told a different story. He remembered the idea being planted by the notion of “one, two, three strikes you're out.” Sensing that this concept “had sock,” he recalled, “I finally worked it into a song and Jack wrote the lyrics.” With conflicting tales of origin before them, Strasberg, Thompson, and Wiles push back a bit against Norworth's claim that the firm calligraphy of his “original draft” could have been executed on a moving train. They also offer period pictures of the Giants' home field, the Polo Grounds, and rail schedules to suggest how the 1908 subway system served the ballpark.
At this point, having uncovered conflicting stories about the song's origins, the authors move on to their main business, which is tracing its path to cultural significance. Before addressing that issue, however, we should note the book's appeal to the eye. Although the front matter is printed on conventional white paper, the first pages of the book proper begin a mix of white with sepia, gray, or off-white pages, many embellished with multiple images, that continues through the next 150 pages. Pictures of people and artifacts are superimposed on these changing backgrounds. On the opening of pages 2 and 3, for example, a baseball card of the star Giants' pitcher Christy Mathewson and a period ad for baseball gloves—“The Ball Sticks Every Time”—from P. Goldsmith's Sons of Cincinnati contrast with a 45-rpm recording from 1983 and a 1997 picture of Chicago Cubs broadcaster Harry Caray, brandishing a microphone as he conducts the Wrigley Field crowd in singing “Take Me Out to the Ball Game.” A shadowy, slightly askew violin part of the song's orchestration forms the sepia-colored background.
Not only do the images appearing on these pages vary, but the way they are placed also tends to give each page a look of its own. Beyond that, the book's visual mode enhances its historical impact. Here and elsewhere, images of past and present confront each other in ways that suggest both baseball's evolving look and the timelessness of the game's ever-present struggle between pitcher and batter. Yet, although the back matter cites the provenance of the images, little is said about what they signify, or how they were chosen. Are they intended as decoration? As substance? As both? Nor does the text say anything about the designer, identified on the copyright page as Damien Casteneda. (The dust jacket credits him with the design too.) Yet nowhere else—not on the title page, nor in the separate authors' acknowledgments, nor even in the lengthy list of people who are collectively thanked—does his name appear, nor is his contribution recognized.
Like any popular song that survives its first burst of fame, “Take Me Out to the Ball Game” has left behind a myriad of connections, and Baseball's Greatest Hit pursues them with due diligence, if without a clear roadmap. The process starts (unannounced) on page 24, mixing miscellaneous bits of data about the song and its times with a larger agenda. “A Bit of a Stretch” takes up the custom of fans rising in the middle of the seventh inning before the home team takes its turn at bat (38–39)—which leads to a team-by-team census of “How the Seventh-Inning Stretch Is Observed Today” by the thirty existing major league franchises (40–45).
After more fugitive facts, including “Dame Yankees,” about women ball players of yore (56–60), Strasberg, Thompson, and Wiles double back to the history that seems to intrigue them most: the evolution of “Take Me Out to the Ball Game” from song hit to component of a baseball ritual. As discussed here the process moved haltingly, from the song's first known performance in a big-league ballpark (at a 1934 World Series game), to its playing on the PA system during the seventh-inning stretch (said to have been standard in the Pacific Coast League in 1945, but then apparently dropped), to fans today singing it regularly in most major league parks at that point in the game. The authors report that the push toward the current practice started in 1976, with Harry Caray, then the Chicago White Sox broadcaster, as the prime mover and shaker, supported by then–White Sox owner Bill Veeck. Thus, “Harry Goes Electric,” (62–65) summarizes the trend in narrative prose, and “Time Line” (66–83), with documentary support, pulls together song-related events that can be dated, from Thomas Edison's invention of the phonograph (1877) to the 2008 postage stamp.
Along the way, the authors test the proposition that the music of “baseball's greatest hit” may help to explain its century-long appeal. For this they call in a specialist: Dave Headlam, professor of music theory at the Eastman School of Music. In several paragraphs couched “in layman's terms,” Professor Headlam offers a down-to-earth analysis of the song adjacent to a reprint of the original sheet music so that his points receive musical illustration (86–87). As he explains it, the song's popularity owes much to three traits: the familiar, infectious rhythm (a waltz in 3/4 time); the easy-to-sing melody, sparked by invigorating octave leaps; and clever uses of repetition. Over and above these points, he also shows why the “melodically disruptive” refrain-ending climax—the “ONE, TWO, THREE strikes you're out” part—is the song's money moment.
As an “addendum” the book also offers a longer, more technically oriented analysis by Professor Headlam (151–54). Here the authors would have done well to steer their specialist away from the song as it was published in 1908, and toward a music theorist's conception of one or more of the oral approaches behind the performances on the CD. Most of the latter, in fact, are in duple time, not triple; only three include the verse, which the analysis keeps as part of the composition; and most of the performers and arrangers have recast Von Tilzer's harmonies in their own ways. In fact, the song's dual identity—as a prescriptively notated composition, and as a musical outline in the manner of a lead sheet to be filled in by performers—creates a disparity that the book seems not to recognize. (According to U. S. copyright law, Norworth and Von Tilzer's song entered the public domain in 1983, seventy-five years after its original copyright, thereby clearing the way for its unlimited use free of royalty costs. One would expect the time line to address this point, but it carries no entry for the year 1983.)
Once the music has been introduced and analyzed, various aspects of its legacy in performance follow: one article on the variety of performance venues (88–91) and two on the royalty income it has produced (92–95). At this point, the focus moves away from the game's “greatest hit” to more general aspects of music and baseball. A section on ballpark organists appears (98–100), and then a miscellaneous section apparently inspired by “the thick file of clippings labeled ‘music’ at the National Baseball Hall of Fame Library,” including information about ballplayers who have sung and played music (101–105). Pages 106–19 encompass two sections about other baseball songs, one a chronological list, from 1858 to 1991, of titles from the Library of Congress in Washington. In 1969, we learn, organized baseball commissioned a new song to recruit new fans—a flat failure (96–97).
If pages 120–47 reflect a change in authorial tone, the responsible party is Andy Weisberg, a man so “obsessed with collecting” baseball artifacts that “his doorbell plays ‘Take Me Out To the Ball Game’ and his kitchen cabinets are filled with Cracker Jack” (140). Weisberg, it turns out, was the driving force behind the 2008 stamp; in “Andy Plays Post Office” he explains how he closed the deal with a letter to the Postal Service signed by fifteen members of the Baseball Hall of Fame (120–21). Perhaps it was also he who, in 2007, convinced “over fifty” members of the Baseball Hall of Fame to “sing and record” baseball's greatest hit (128–30). A section on Weisberg's own baseball artifacts includes the revelation that Norworth, himself a collector (134–36), was also an avid self-promoter (122–24). Could “product placement” have been in Norworth's mind when he named in his song the confection called Cracker Jack, which dates from 1893? According to Weisberg it was not, for this practice “didn't begin in earnest until post-World War II” (126). The refrain's popularity also made it a target for parody, and five examples are published (131–32), including “Take Me Out to the Seder.” (In this book, as in baseball lore, the notion of “trivia” is not pejorative.) Finally, readers interested in music about baseball will find examples on pages 137–47, where each of the three authors shares and explains his own “top ten baseball songs,” and a pair of collectors answer questions about “Take Me Out to the Ball Game” recordings. The last thirty pages of the book, back matter excepted, are devoted to a discography of such recordings. The format—artist, title, label, catalog number, recording format “(inches/rpm),” time, year, and “note,” all on one line—falls short of a professional standard. Yet, with more than 650 entries, it provides more information about a song that won its spurs in the marketplace, survived there for many decades, and now belongs to urban folk tradition.
As for things in the book to love, this reviewer nominates three examples, each of which cuts through promotional sensibilities to fundamental matters: (1) the epigraph, (2) a historical document, and (3) the music on the CD. The epigraph, attributed to “Brooklyn Dodger pitching ace” Carl Erskine, points to the battle at the heart of the game: “One, two, three strikes you're out? This is a pitcher's song.”
On the second front, I found nothing else in the book to match the visual impact of page 1: the facsimile of Norworth's “original words” for the song's first stanza and refrain, written in pencil in full caps, complete with a misspelling or two, several crossings-out, and two cartoon-like sketches. (Norworth was better at verse than at drawing.) Here is an artifact that, even if not written on a subway train as the writer claimed, gives readers a glimpse of the catch-as-catch-can circumstances in which the popular song trade of the day did its creative business.
Finally, on the music front, the performances range widely, from Fred Lambert's 1908 vocal to an undated performance by Harry Caray leading fans from the broadcast booth at Wrigley Field. In between are several novelty performances: an orchestra led by Arturo Sandoval with fortissimo trumpets and Latin rhythm, a 1982 vocal in the manner of Bruce Springsteen, an eerily virtuosic rendition on the musical saw by David Weiss, and a bluesified version from 1994 by Dr. John of New Orleans. Moreover, two very different kinds of jazz ensemble drew some especially beautiful music from the old chestnut: the 1920s-style National Pastime Orchestra, who in 1989 recorded a loosely swinging version with both fire and soul, and the Ray Brown Trio (with the leader on bass, Gene Harris, piano, and Jeff Hamilton, drums), with a 1992 rendition so delicate that the drummer, who alone plays the four-plus-minute track from start to finish, uses only brushes. Thus, Norworth and Von Tilzer's extroverted waltz number moves from the stadium to the intimacy of a space where, rather than joining in, the audience becomes a coterie of rapt listeners.
