In Everyday Piety, Sarah Tobin explores how the “aspiring cosmopolitans” of Western Amman negotiate being “better Muslims.” Findings from her two-year fieldwork in Jordan expose the various ways Ammani Muslims reflect on anxieties over not practicing “real” or “authentic” forms of Islam.
Tobin's ethnography stands out for its discussion on the economization of everyday life and piety. Amman's integration into the global market and transformation into an “unrecognizable Amman” (23), discussed in the more historical chapter 2, did more than introduce new modes of consumption. It also economized ways of assessing moral dispositions, assisted by the use of a fiscal vocabulary of risk management, profits, rewards, and calculation. The “economy” in the book's title, therefore calls for an understanding that reaches beyond an economic exchange, and entails a process that involves Ammanis “justifying and showcasing their piety through complex constructions of authentic Islamic piety that inform both their professional and personal lives” (21).
Tobin chooses three sites where this process takes place: Ramadan (chapter 3), the hijab (chapter 4), and an Islamic bank (chapters 5, 6, and 7). Ramadan entails a month of modesty in practice and heightened piety. However, in Amman, claims to moral righteousness are attained not only through the embodiment of modesty. The Ramadan experience is authenticated through consumption, that is, active participation in Amman's neoliberal market economy. This transforms Ramadan into a site of pious, yet neoliberal display. What happens to those who have neither interest nor the means to participate in this economy remains a theme to be further developed.
The hijab provides another site through which to analyze economizing practices. For Tobin, women wear the hijab not only for pious reasons, but also to meet “actor-centered or actor-oriented ends” (77). Some wear it to present themselves as appealing candidates to future husbands, to avoid gossip, or to get a job. However, the hijab is also a long-term commitment, and women who “de-veil” or “downveil” are not spoken of favorably. Negative connotations of moral decline are ascribed to such women, making their piety questionable. Yet, the same conversation also brings into discussion a range of norms, such as jurists’ perception of how much flesh can be exposed; everyday conversations about hadiths governing the covering of all but the hands and face, which some of Tobin's informants consider “weak” hadiths; and conflicting interpretations of suras, such as An-Nur, verse 3. These discussions certainly play a role in shaping how women cover, what types of jeans they wear (tight versus loose), and what cosmetics they use. Tobin argues that these discussions are situated within a larger conversation about ways that “personal styles and interests that lend themselves to experimentation with various normativities” (97), which, in turn, engenders consideration of what type of dress renders a woman sufficiently Islamic, authentically Islamic, or un-Islamic.
The rest of the book is devoted to Islamic banking practices. Chapter 5 provides a brief overview of Islamic banking, the different methods of engaging in financial transactions in Islam (mudaraba, musharaka, murabaha), and commonly accepted ethical standards that “adequate” business transactions. What also matters, Tobin argues, is how employees and customers perceive banking practices. Building on a five-week internship in different departments at one of Jordan's four Islamic banks, Tobin, in chapter 6, investigates how bank employees question the compatibility of their banking practices with Islam. While some employees claim that Islamic banks can abide by shariʿa-based norms to regulate transactions (such as offering interest-free credit options, and not charging late fees), and that this helps to attract “‘real’ Muslim clients” (133), others remain cautious. Some even question the “self proclaimed Islamicness” of the bank as Islamic banking is “ultimately a business” (140, 150).
Transactions in an Islamic bank require a sense of accountability from both the bank and its customers. Individual and institutional morals are assessed in light of compliance with rules and regulations. For the customers, this means paying the fees on time. For the bank, it means offering products that comply with shariʿa, and employing workers who embody Islam through their dress code and demeanor.
The bank is under scrutiny by both its internal mechanisms (the shariʿa compliance committee), and its customers. However, to retain a competitive edge in a market saturated with non-Islamic banking, compromises are made “in the name of good business” (141). The discussion on whether an Islamic bank can fund a restaurant where alcohol is served is useful here. An Islamic bank may not invest in a business that sells alcohol, but can fund the non-alcoholic ventures undertaken by the same business. These practices risk leaving the bank open to criticism and rendering it “just a name” rather than a truly Islamic institution (162). Despite shariʿa compliance committees which screen new initiatives, individuals also base their impressions on affective responses (how banking experience in an Islamic bank feels), and on their general satisfaction with the services offered. The customer side of the story is explored in chapter 7. Like the employees, customers lack a consensus over the “Islamicness” of the banks. Reflecting on an account of an Islamic banking customer, Tobin argues, “there is always debate, contention and negotiation at play” (178). Despite the best efforts to offer a shariʿa compliant banking experience, and despite the eagerness of the Ammanis in using Islamic banking, cynicism pervades.
There are a growing number of ethnographies on financial institutions. Few focus on the Islamic world and practices. Despite problems with access, which restricted Tobin from conducting extended research in an Islamic banking branch, and which would have provided more material on the inner complexities of Islamic finance, Tobin's reflection on Amman is a welcome addition. Some scholars of Islam may find discussions on the hijab and Ramadan repetitive. It is nonetheless useful to rethink these discussions through Tobins’ lens of economization, critically considering how neoliberal economics shape the ways in which Muslims think about Islamic performances and how Muslims, as calculative agents, assess themselves and each other as authentically pious.
Accusations of moral decline and deviations from orthopraxy are constantly debated in Muslim societies. These debates, today, are greatly influenced by neoliberal logics. Tobin's ethnography provides one snapshot, leaving the door ajar for other scholars to follow.
