The debate over the relative roles of the state and the private sector was current in Latin America during the twentieth century and, especially, since the 1980s, stimulated by the impact of the international debt crisis. The end of the century was marked by a new paradigm based on a different role for the state and new ways in which both parties – the state and the private sector – could get together to undertake investment projects and supply public goods.
In some countries the role of the state as ‘regulator’ was now preferred to that of ‘entrepreneur’ and led to a wave of privatisation of state companies, particularly in the energy, the utilities and the banking sectors. Some proceeded quicker than others, depending on the political conditions; some went slowly. But all of them worked out ways to enhance the role of the private sector as an engine to speed up economic development. And, of course, there was an intense political and ideological public debate when a company was offered to private investors or as a new collaboration mechanism between the two parties was proposed. The debate has continued in the twenty-first century. In Colombia, for instance, one state owned enterprise – a national power generation company – was privatised at the beginning of 2016 in the middle of a very aggressive political debate which conveyed high costs for the president of the country.
The change to liberalised economies in Latin America was very positive for the development of the region as Mauricio Font's The State and the Private Sector in Latin America demonstrates. The investment figures are clear: ‘Between 1990 and 2003, more than US $380 billion public–private investment went to Latin America and the Caribbean, but this seemingly impressive figure fell short of what was needed to lower transportation and transaction costs and become more competitive' (p. 10). This figure was impossible to foresee before 1990, when Latin America was relatively closed to foreign investment. And, on the other hand, previous investment being insufficient, transport infrastructure continues today to demand very high levels of investment; but the existing backwardness imposes high logistic costs and restricts the increase in exports out of the region.
In the environment surrounding the development of Latin America since 1990, the behaviour of transnational actors and the performance of the international economy are very important. They also imply heavy requirements over macroeconomic management and the private and public sector actors of the different countries. For policy-makers it was evident, in 1990, that the fiscal constraint made it very difficult for the state to undertake, with its own financial resources, the construction of transport infrastructure, roads, railroads, airports, ports, and so on. But, according to Font, ‘need alone has not guaranteed adoption or success … State strength is a key variable in the success of both democratizing and liberalizing reforms … Inadequate institutional strength often leads to disaster’ (p. 99).
To partner with transnational companies implied, then, a strong degree of trust between the actors involved, including the authorities of a country, the institutions – especially legal security (rule of law) considerations – and the strength of the private sector companies that often become partners of the foreign ones.
Font's book explores and discusses all the above mentioned issues in an orderly and systematic manner. Its aim is to clarify the extent to which the changes in Latin America of the last 25 years are sustainable and durable. He worries about the eventual political changes in the different countries given the stability record of Latin America. But the book ends with a realistic view of the future, when the author recognises that, ‘in general, Latin American societies are experimenting with partnerships between the public and private sectors, but this process needs to be nourished. A next big step is to expand norms, organisations and practices favoring transparency and openness, civil service development, clear property rights, and more effective rule of law to regulate interactions between economic and political actors’ (p. 184).
The book analyses reform cases in four experiences – Chile, Mexico, Argentina and Brazil – providing excellent information about the way in which each of these countries undertook reforms and expanded public–private collaboration. Each case was different from the other, given the strategies of economic development adopted and the political conditions of each country or city. But some general conclusions were derived from the four cases. For instance, that ‘successful cases have sustained a reform trajectory in which divestiture, concessions and partnerships have come in that order’ and that ‘the adoption of more complex and demanding partnering programmes has built on prior experience with simpler forms of public–private collaboration’ (p. 56). This is interesting. To be successful, the programmes have to build on pre-existing reform processes in a kind of a cumulative learning path.
The final chapters of the book study in detail three cases of infrastructure development, two in Brazil (the North-South Railway (FNS), and the São Paulo Rail Bypass) and one in Chile (Transantiago) and assess the positive and negative elements in the execution of the projects. Again the analysis shows the importance not only of technical and economic factors but of political leadership at the highest level and the design of the contracts between the parties involved.
Mauricio Font's book has information and analysis until 2014. The changes in Latin America of 2015 and 2016, originated in the fall of the international prices of commodities – oil, coal, copper, and so on – could not be included. This change could have a negative impact on the perception of the region by transnational investors and affect private-public partnerships. If this happens, it could slow down the pace of investment in transport infrastructure in Latin America. What will happen in the near future would be crucial to test the relevance of the exhaustive work contained in this book.
