A practicable method of exploiting the uniqueness of individual genomes for the purpose of forensic identification was first proposed in 1984 by Dr Alec Jeffreys. Jeffreys has since been knighted for his services to genetics, while genetic profiling has become an indispensable tool in the forensic armamentarium. In Truth Machine, Michael Lynch and his distinguished team of co-authors provide an incisive analysis of the steps by which forensic DNA profiling was transformed from a tentative new technology into today's gold-standard arbiter of personal identity. The story they tell is complex and multidimensional, involving innovations in the organization and management of forensic practice and in the way evidence is presented and interpreted in court, as well as in the more obviously technical aspects of DNA analysis.
The authors' aim in telling this story is in effect to write a sociotechnical history of scientific credibility – specifically, the legal credibility of a certain kind of scientific evidence – and to show how that credibility was ‘achieved as a practical, rhetorical, and administrative matter’ (p. xvii). They fulfil their aim admirably. Particularly impressive is the clarity with which they explain a number of technically difficult and quite disparate topics, including the different methods by which DNA profiles have been obtained from crime-scene samples; statistical debates about the probability of obtaining false matches between crime-scene DNA profiles and those of named and unidentified suspects; the increasingly complicated bureaucratic procedures for logging and keeping track of DNA samples and profiles as they move between police, forensic scientists and lawyers; and legal disputes over the admissibility and authority of different kinds of evidence in the courts. The reader is left in little doubt that the credibility of forensic DNA profiling is contingent on the careful management of procedure and perception in all these areas of activity.
The implications of this analysis of the credibility of DNA evidence are not merely academic. Lynch et al. seek to challenge what they see as the excessively authoritative status granted to forensic DNA profiling in legal proceedings. Underlying their analysis is a concern that ‘DNA evidence [is seen to have] attained a level of “mathematical certainty” that transcends the merely subjective status of eyewitness testimony, confessions, and older forms of forensic evidence’ (p. xi). In both common and legal parlance, DNA evidence is often held to be irrefutable and unchallengeable, grounded not in the fallible testimony of witnesses but in infallible scientific truth. The purpose of Truth Machine is therefore to show that ‘the probative value of DNA evidence rests on practices, circumstantial knowledge, and administrative assurances that are not essentially different from those that support other, less glamorous, forms of evidence’ (p. xiii). Moreover, DNA evidence must itself be ‘delivered through testimony: verbal and written accounts of what various specialists saw, said, and did as they worked with evidence samples’ (p. 336). Consequently, DNA evidence is in principle open to precisely the same kinds of challenge and demonstration of fallibility as any other sort of evidence. Insofar as the courts neglect to mount such challenges, there remains a serious risk that unquestioning acceptance of DNA evidence will lead to unsound conviction and consequent miscarriages of justice.
But then, why should this peculiar expectation of infallibility have been invested in a form of evidence that Truth Machine clearly shows to be no less fallible, in principle, than earlier forms of forensic proof? Lynch et al. go some way towards addressing this question in their discussion of the relationship between DNA profiling and the earlier forensic technique of latent fingerprint analysis. In a separate historical study (Suspect Identities: A History of Fingerprinting and Criminal Identification, 2001), Cole has already shown that fingerprint analysis previously carried many of the same connotations of infallibility as are currently ascribed to DNA profiling. In Truth Machine, Lynch, Cole and their colleagues show how DNA profiling came to replace fingerprint analysis as the preferred means of forensic identification by providing evidence of the fallibility of fingerprints while simultaneously offering itself as a new and supposedly more reliable alternative. By examining legal debates around what was taken to count as scientific evidence, Truth Machine goes a long way towards explaining just how that inversion of credibility was achieved. What it still does not tell us, however, is just why those concerned with identifying offenders and assigning guilt should have been disposed to invest such authority in a particular forensic technique, be it fingerprint analysis or DNA profiling.
Evidently, there is still more to be said about just how forensic DNA profiling acquired the status it currently possesses. Lynch et al. opt for a narrative of extreme contingency, in which the present system emerged as the outcome of a series of local negotiations over the practice, management and language of forensic science. But other kinds of stories suggest that more systematic factors may also have been important. The politically motivated reform and reorientation of policing, for instance, has plainly played a vital role in the expansion and valorization of searchable forensic DNA databases, as shown for the UK by Robin Williams and Paul Johnson in their Genetic Policing: The Use of DNA in Criminal Investigations (2008). So too, it seems, has a widely held assumption that the biosciences can help to define those sections of the population who will incline towards criminal behaviour. As an account of the resistible rise of DNA profiling, then, Truth Machine does not tell the whole truth. But the truth that it does tell, it tells very well indeed. In clearly demonstrating the unavoidably contingent and fallible character of DNA evidence, it provides the foundations on which any future analysis and evaluation of forensic DNA profiling will need to be based. Truth Machine is not just scholarship of the highest order; it is also a fundamental contribution to a topic of pressing importance.
