Laura Robson's Colonialism and Christianity in Mandate Palestine offers a welcome and overdue consideration of British policy toward Arab Christians in Palestine. Covering the entire Mandate period, this well-written book explores how British colonial policies contributed to sectarianism in Palestinian politics and how Arab Christian leaders reacted to their resulting marginalization from the nationalist movement.
Robson's concentration on the Christian community's place in Palestinian nationalism naturally (and consciously) challenges the claim by nationalists that their movement was nonsectarian. Rashid Khalidi, Muhammad Muslih, and Yehoshua Porath have argued that Palestinian nationalist politicians made a point of being communally inclusive during the Mandate era, going as far as creating Muslim–Christian associations to speak for all Palestinian Arabs. Robson clarifies this argument by showing that this period of inclusivity was brief, lasting no more than a few years at the beginning of the Mandate. Much more significant for Palestinian politics, as she points out in this book, was the emergence of a sectarian divide in the 1920s and the consequent control of the nationalist message by Muslim organizations.
The first part of the book traces this shift by comparing the more inclusive politics of the late Ottoman and early Mandate periods (Chap. 1) with the communal politics that emerged in the initial years of British rule (Chap. 2). This comparison demonstrates that sectarianism was not inherent in Palestinian politics but was produced by colonial policies such as the identification and enumeration of the local population according to religion, the recognition of communal rather than national institutions, and the promotion of religious leaders as representatives of the Arab population. Particularly important here was the creation by the British of the Supreme Muslim Council headed by the mufti of Jerusalem, Hajj Amin al-Husayni, a development that Robson rightly identifies as contributing to an “Islamization” of Palestinian politics and the marginalization of Christian voices in the nationalist movement.
The rise of communal politics has been discussed in previous scholarly works, such as Rashid Khalidi's The Iron Cage: The Struggle for Palestinian Statehood (Boston: Beacon Press, 2006), but with little consideration of how it affected Muslim–Christian relations or the position of the minority Christian community. Robson's work fills in these gaps by investigating how the rise of an Islamic political nationalism excluded Christian intellectuals who had “previously participated with enthusiasm in the multi-religious discourse of various nationalist organizations” (p. 63). In doing so, she offers an alternative to Khalidi's argument that communalism was fatal for the nationalist movement simply because it was nonsecular. She suggests that the problem was not the presence of religion in national politics but the use of an Islamic language that excluded certain groups from participating fully in the national movement. This is a subtle shift in the analysis of communal politics but offers a useful corrective to the Andersonian model of nationalism that has often been misapplied to the Palestinian situation.
The second half of the book, which considers the fortunes of the Christian community in Palestinian politics, is its most original historiographical contribution. Whether discussing the emergence of an Arab Orthodox movement (Chap. 3), Pan-Christian communalism (Chap. 4), or the fate of Arab Episcopalians (Chap. 5), Robson presents Christians creatively working to find a place in a political system that was squeezing them out in various ways. Arab Christians faced three main political challenges: the aforementioned rise of Islamic national politics; an imperial power that was predisposed to ignoring their political concerns; and a Zionist movement that was constantly working to take over Arab Christian land and positions on local councils. In straightforward and clear prose, Robson describes the intricacies of these challenges and the various ways in which Christians responded to them. Her view that the local Orthodox community's movement to Arabize their church was part of the nationalist struggle is persuasive and helps to broaden our understanding of Arab nationalism during the Mandate period. She also writes convincingly about how the promotion of Pan-Christian communalism by Arab Christian politicians in the 1930s was an appropriation of the sectarianism pushed in British policymaking. Robson is to be commended for her care in showing how each of the political strategies adopted by Christians was contested and debated at length. For in recreating the debates over Arabization, communalism, and Pan-Arab Protestantism she uncovers much of the vibrancy of Christian politics that has been lost in historiography of the period.
That these movements failed to create a strong political position for Christians had little to do with the capacity of Christians to reinvent their politics for a changing Palestine. As Robson shows, the power of the colonial state (aided and abetted by its Zionist advisors) to shape and control politics was ultimately the undoing of Christian politics. This conclusion complements Khalidi's argument about the “Iron Cage” of British rule and adds to a growing body of literature that suggests the impotency of the Palestinian nationalist movement was based not so much on internal division as on the fact that the rules of politics were stacked against it.
Colonialism and Christianity in Mandate Palestine is not without its problems. Robson's idea that the British approach to religion was influenced by experiences elsewhere in the empire, particularly in India, is intriguing but underdeveloped. Her discussion of British policymaking is certainly an advance upon the trite observation that the British were applying a “divide and rule” strategy, but it could have traced out the connections to Indian or African policy in more detail. Robson could also have said more about the impact of imperial policymaking in London on local politics. While figures such as Herbert Samuel and Norman Bentwich were influential in the construction of the Palestine government's approach to religion, they are given perhaps too much of a starring role. If the sectarianism encouraged in Palestine was part of an empirewide promotion of communalism, as Robson rightly suggests, it would have been better to foreground the colonial discourse and practices of governmentality that informed local policymaking rather than the individual prejudices of such figures.
Robson's book also concentrates exclusively on the actions and thoughts of elite male Christian figures. Such a focus is typical for books on nationalism but may raise questions among readers about how representative these elite voices really were. There is also little consideration of the social life of Christians, intracommunal politics, or the ritual life of Christians under British rule. Robson's book seldom deviates from its concern with politics and leaves the reader, despite the book's title, with only a partial understanding of Christianity in Mandate Palestine. A longer book would have allowed Robson to explore these other aspects of Christian life though perhaps at the expense of the incisiveness of her arguments about colonialism and Christian politics. As it stands, this well-written book is a strong contribution to the study of Palestinian politics and is recommended for anyone interested in the origins of Palestinian nationalism, the place of Christians in the national movement, and the British colonial treatment of religion.
