In recent years, there have been an increasing number of published works on the South Vietnamese state, its military, and its people. These include several excellent historical works and a growing body of memoirs and edited syncretic collections of essays written by former officials from the Republic of Vietnam (RVN). Ship of fate: Memoir of a Vietnamese repatriate by Trần Đinh Trụ is an important and welcome addition to this growing trend.
Like so many Vietnamese who came of age in the mid-twentieth century, Trụ's life was not just profoundly shaped, but largely defined by the conflicts that wracked his nation between 1940 and 1975. Born to a Catholic family in the northern province of Ninh Bình in 1935, Trụ professed hatred for the French as a child and little knowledge of the Viet Minh when they appeared in his province. Four years later, when Vietnamese paratroopers fighting alongside France landed near his village, the youthful Trụ expressed ignorance of the larger political issues of the Franco-Vietminh War, and he considered the Viet Minh and the ‘Nationalist’ soldiers to both be good because they were Vietnamese. In 1954, after the Geneva Accords and national partition, Trụ and his family fled south and settled near Saigon. Like many of his co-religionists, Trụ's family left because they feared the Democratic Republic of Vietnam (DRV) would not allow them to practice their faith.
Trụ developed a love of seamanship as a young boy, admiring the riverboats as they travelled to and fro near his village. As a young man, he joined the South Vietnamese navy and became an officer. Shortly thereafter, he married and had two children. Trụ was deeply committed to his family, to the nation he served, and to the cause of preserving the RVN against Hanoi's designs for unifying Vietnam under communist control. Forced to flee Saigon in April 1975 without his wife and children, Trụ was taken by ship to a refugee camp on Guam. There, he and 100,000 or so Vietnamese refugees waited transfer to the United States. For most, emigrating to the United States was the only option, this despite the fear and uncertainty of starting a new life in a foreign land. For Trụ and others whose families were unable to escape, there was no choice but to return to Vietnam, this despite the likelihood of imprisonment and perhaps even death at the hands of the Hanoi regime.
Thus began a tense, sometimes violent, struggle to negotiate passage back to Vietnam. Trụ and the other Vietnamese repatriates demanded a ship and a prompt return to Vietnam. The United States wanted the refugees resettled — anywhere but preferably in the United States — and feared communist reprisals against the repatriates. Hanoi, for its part did not want the refugees to return and warned they were not welcome back in Vietnam. Concerned for the welfare of family members and anxious to return home as quickly as possible, the process was painfully slow for Trụ and the others. His meditations on his experiences during this period reveal several themes, including a deep religious faith, pride in his military service, a hatred of communism, and a mixture of gratitude and resentment toward the United States. After six agonising months of negotiations, punctuated at times by demonstrations and hunger strikes by frustrated refugees, the United States offered a ship, the Việt Nam Thương Tἱn, to bring the refugees back to Vietnam. Because he was an experienced former naval officer, Trụ was chosen captain. In October, the ship set sail with approximately 1,600 on board, and arrived in Vũng Tàu after a six-day voyage. Taken into custody, Trụ was interrogated for three months and then sent to a prison camp. Six years passed before Hanoi permitted Trụ to see his family. He spent another seven years in various camps before being freed in February 1988, largely under pressure from the United States and other international agencies working for the release of political prisoners. In 1991, despite fear and anxiety over an uncertain future, Trụ and his family emigrated to the United States.
As a former RVN naval officer who escaped Vietnam in 1975 yet willingly returned, Trụ's story is unique. However, like millions of South Vietnamese whose lives were shattered and who in the blink of an eye suddenly found themselves orphaned, dispossessed, and adrift in a liminal world, the narrative reflects a tragic tale of suffering, loss, and existential crisis shared by many. Ship of fate captures the raw and often conflicting emotions of people whose universe had collapsed and who were robbed of those fundamental elements that are crucial to a sense of self: profession, family, and homeland. This loss of self-determination, purpose, and identity among the living is a tragic aspect of the post-1975 Vietnamese diaspora. Thus, despite the story's upbeat ending (freedom and opportunity in the United States), the journey taken by Trụ and by millions of Vietnamese is tinged with sadness. ‘The past was filled with sorrow, and the present was laden with bitterness. As for the future, we did not know where it would take us’ (p. 208). Powerful and eloquent, Ship of fate is a necessary and important book that enriches our understanding of the Second Indochina War by focusing on the Vietnamese who have largely been written out of the history of this momentous conflict: those who awoke on 1 May 1975 to find their life and homeland had vanished.
