The success story of the People’s Republic of China (China), in becoming the world’s most favoured foreign direct investment (FDI) destination has attracted a lot of scholarly and academic curiosity and resulted in a number of studies on the topic. The contribution of bilateral investment treaties (BITs) in spurring the influx of FDI in China is now well recognized. Chinese Investment Treaties: Policies and Practice co-authored by Norah Gallagher and Wenhua Shan, is an instructive treatise on the topic of Chinese investment treaties. The book underlies some important policy concerns and also elucidates some interesting pragmatic treaty formation, interpretation, and implementation issues.
The book can be divided into three parts. In the first part the authors attempt to provide a general background to the BIT programme. This part provides an interesting historical overview of China’s economic policies and discusses the various forms of foreign investment available for a business in China. Since 1982, China has signed 126 BITs, and here the authors attempt to explain the trend of investments, by examining the first generation of BITs from 1982–1989 and then the second big wave of BITs which was a result of China’s accession to the World Trade Organization (WTO). The first part forms an insightful introduction to the other two parts and the historical overview is useful in understanding the current form and model of BITs.
The second part of the book is more specific. It deals with specific clauses in the BITs such as the “fair and equitable (FET) clause”, non-discrimination clauses, such as most favoured nation (MFN) clause, national treatment (NT), type of payments, dispute resolution, expropriation, and some umbrella clauses. Would courts apply the plain meaning standard or the IMS standard while interpreting the FET provision in a treaty? What is the role of MFN and NT clauses in investor disputes in Chinese BITs? What are the modes of dispute resolution under the model treaty? The authors analyse such questions by examining actual signed BITs and assess such questions based on interpretations provided by domestic and international courts.
In the final part, the authors conclude by discussing the future of Chinese BITs. The authors present a compelling case for China to adopt a more balanced model BIT, which balances the interests of the investor and the host state. The authors also argue that in addition to existing clauses, the BITs should contain clauses which impose “corporate social responsibility”. The author provides model BITs signed with Korea, Japan, and Australia in appendices.
The book provides an interesting read for those who are interested in the area of Chinese foreign investment or BITs. This book can serve as a useful handbook for practitioners. From a policy perspective, the book also presents some interesting concerns and debates. The book is well researched and provides clarity on issues. The book can serve as a useful guide for those trying to orient themselves with China investment-related issues.
