When a commercial tractor trailer ploughed into comedian Tracy Morgan's limousine in June 2014 the accident was almost fatal, and it is a cautionary tale that underscores the danger of “sleep-deprived driving.” Despite new federal work rules that pare the maximum working week down to seventy hours, mandate a thirty-four-hour rest break and specify uninterrupted nighttime rest, employers have mobilized to stop any implementation of these rules. Under pressure to deliver the goods, drivers themselves balk at such regulation. As one admitted to the New York Times, “I'm still always moving, and when I'm sleeping, I'm usually sleeping in my truck. But I enjoy it.”Footnote 1 In nonchalantly displaying manly bravado, he joined a long line of men whose “dreams of individual freedom” historian Alan Derickson reveals “meant a nightmare of sleeplessness for others, and for many of the dreamers themselves as well” (141).
Concluding with these trucking regulations, Derickson has produced a timely study that historicizes the bodily consequences of our 24/7 society where getting by and making a profit promote constant wakefulness. His is an important contribution to the history of health as well. In five crisp chapters, Derickson explores the association of sleeplessness with manhood, the regulatory neglect of overwork, and the perilous practices of three male-dominated occupations: steel's shift rotation, Pullman porters' “on-call” status, and trucking's long haul. The right to labor without limits stood as a counterpart to man's freedom of contract. Steel men celebrated the long turn as expressive of their “virile toughness” (54), though it led to “equal sharing of the misfortune of fragmented daytime sleeping and diminished social life” (82). Uninterrupted sleep time and private resting spaces became major demands of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters, whose African American membership fumed at the indignity of being always available as male servants. In contrast, authorities cast women as unable to labor endlessly, but it was the fear that overwork would harm generative capacity that rationalized job discrimination. Wakefulness for women supposedly would destroy their greatest asset: their beauty. In parsing the gender, class, and race assumptions behind the development of work time, Derickson illuminates the power of cultural analysis for labor history.
Colorful vignettes capture the valuing of work over rest. The “discourse of heroic wakefulness” (2) idealized the shop culture of Thomas Edison's Meno Park laboratory, where continuous activity promised efficiency, invention, and reward. Sleeping in the mill invited ruder awakening from fellow workmen. As well as Edison, Derickson introduces a cast of characters familiar to scholars of American studies: Benjamin Franklin, who equated sleep with sloth; Charles Lindbergh, who “linked sleep deprivation to daredevil adventure” (12); William Whyte, who promoted “The ‘Well-Rounded’ Man” (19) over overwork; and Donald Trump, who connected “his own brand of alertness” with “brash aggressiveness and unblinking vigilance” (26).
Dangerously Sleepy is also a story about expertise – medical, scientific, and legal – and public policy. It foregrounds a central theme in labor history: the battle over working time, including night work for women and a day of rest for all. State regulation only occurred to guard public safety or protect workers judged vulnerable, such as women and children. Cases for shortening hours were made by those coming from radically different positions. Whereas the Railroad Brotherhoods fought overwork, politicians worried about passenger protection. But laws on working hours ultimately traded off time for money, enshrining overtime payments as a cornerstone of US labor practice. This has had the effect of promoting overwork instead of spreading available employment, as New Dealers had originally hoped would be the outcome of legislating for maximum working hours. For Derickson, one upshot of the anti-discrimination promise of Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act was for women “the freedom to work all night, all day, all week … without any concomitant informal equality in the sharing of work at home” (46). Double days, indeed! Now consumer convenience overrides worker health, global competition demands constant presence, and nonstandard work schedules usher in an era of sleep inequality under the banner of flexibility.
Despite the findings of Congressional commissions and the efforts of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), shift work grew – and so did sleep disorders. Today residents and interns petition in their own name for shorter hours, while nurses continue to emphasize the benefits that their rest brings to patients. But the lobbying of such workers provides one of the few glimmers of hope in this generally bleak tale of life lost to labor. After reading Derickson, however, we might not just be ready to question our love affair with work, but perhaps we will also be mobilized to act to ensure that long-haul truckers can be manly because they are rested.
