The Struggle for a Better World is the latest instalment in what is the remarkable scholarly career of Peter Boettke. Boettke’s work, some of which has appeared in this journal, has aimed to synthesize complementary insights within a tradition of scholarship referred to as the “mainline” of economic thought. The mainline expounds the notion that voluntaristic economic exchanges, conducted against the background of certain formal and informal institutional configurations, is conducive to a material prosperity progressively within the reach of all peoples. For Boettke, mainline economics is represented by a quartet of iconic figures—Adam Smith, Friedrich Hayek, James Buchanan, and Elinor Ostrom.
Presenting a judicious selection of addresses, lectures, and papers produced over the years, it is ill-conceived to adjudge Boettke’s Struggle for a Better World as a “greatest hits” collection disconnected from the currents of our age. The vital contribution of this book is that it pointedly addresses the contemporary challenges faced by scholars of economics, political economy, and, I would argue, the remainder of the social sciences. Some of the vexing matters that Boettke squarely confronts include: the hardships of economic and financial repression during crisis periods; subdued opportunities attributable to prolonged socio-political injustices; and exclusion that comes with discrimination and privilege. These interrelated problems represent departures from the promise of emancipation, itself a crucial socio-political commitment of mainline economists through the generations. The unifying position gleaned from this impressive collection of essays is that the operationalization of economic liberalism is an essential ingredient toward overcoming the travails presently gripping humanity. That is to say, an economy in which people are empowered to discover pathways toward mutually beneficial interaction is an economy compatible with promoting emancipatory objectives more generally.
The mainline economic position of Boettke provides a nuanced account of how it is that idiosyncratic individuals, with divergent capabilities, knowledge, and motivations, come to economically coordinate to produce small-scale mutual gains that ramify into large-scale, inclusive material prosperity. The incentive structure of the market, encapsulating “private property rights, the guiding influence of relative prices, and lure of entrepreneurial profits, and the discipline of losses” (p. 150), is pivotal. This is because instantiation of such incentives provides great impetus to a competitive interactional process that undermines domination. Specifically, Struggle for a Better World emphasizes how the dynamic effects of competition functionally serve to disempower incumbent economic privileges, and to open new and expanded opportunities within product and factor markets. In other words, allowing the freedom to produce and consume, and affording creative, enterprising individuals the dignity to pursue cooperative economic gains with their contemporaries, is critical to resolving many of the pressing issues identified by Boettke in his book. Fittingly in this respect, Boettke reminds us of the canonical Adam Smith quote, which I paraphrase, to the effect that no society may flourish should the great bulk of the population find themselves in a state of material deprivation and misery.
A broader institutional infrastructure is also deemed necessary to support the realization of market-tested betterments. Preferred institutions that motivate entrepreneurialism and the accompanying testing of innovative ideas would, themselves, encompass arrangements “that will check the ambitions of some against the ambitions of others to ward off predation by private and public actors” (p. 20). Of course, not all institutions are created equal. As Boettke notes, some institutions are more efficacious than others in structuring economic understandings concerning “how to learn, what to learn, and who is to take responsibility for learning” (p. 150), which, in turn, are pivotal to securing the means to material flourishing and poverty alleviation. A common perspective for adherents of mainline political economy, such as Boettke, is that political ethics, procedures, and rules ought to refrain from discriminatory treatment of all those subject to the strictures of public governance. To depart from the likes of constitutional limitations and the rule of law is to, disconcertingly, invite impoverishment wrought by “perverse incentives, economic inefficiency, political corruption, and regimes of ruthless brutality” (p. 85).
One of the highlights of Boettke’s Struggle for a Better World is the demonstration of deep knowledge and respect for the history of economic thought, and the relevance of past economic scholarship for today. The recitation of key elements in the history of thought serves a number of purposes in Boettke’s book. The first is that it draws the attention of emerging scholars to past debates concerning ventures to fundamentally recast economic institutions consistent with underlying political desires for economic and societal influence, if not control. An example of this is the socialist calculation debate of the 1920s and 1930s, lessons from which Boettke is eager to convey to emerging scholars during a period of great economic, political, and social tension and strain.
The second purpose for drawing upon the history of economic thought is to recognize that ideas have indelibly shaped the evolution of mainline economics and political economy. Drawing upon that aforementioned quartet of mainline economists, together with the likes of Ludwig von Mises, Frank Knight, and Milton Friedman, Boettke succeeds in tracing a congruent train of economic logic over the centuries. Essentially, this logic indicates that broad-based development and prosperity is associated with the institutional and ideational manifestations of the age-old liberal plan of equality, liberty, and justice. Ideas and institutions that unleash creative agency in the pursuit of productive specialization, and peaceable cooperation, not only deliver enrichment but, relatedly, defuse societal tensions as more people feel they can fairly and reasonably gain access to lucrative economic opportunities, without fear or favor.
Peter Boettke’s Struggle for a Better World is a deeply insightful, and profound, contribution. A serious reflection of today’s challenges, yet with strong connective roots to thoughts of the past, this book would be of immense value to historians of economic thought.
