Very few of the many scholars who have published on issues relating to Zimbabwe's controversial land seizures from white commercial farmers since 2000 have made as nuanced, historically-contextualised, and rich a scholarly contribution on the politics of land, identity, and belonging as Joost Fontein has done in Remaking Mutirikwi.
Much of the burgeoning literature on what became called the Fast-track Land Reform Programme (FTLRP) has had a somewhat confined focus on quantifying the outcomes of the land redistributions in terms of such factors as agricultural production, livelihoods, agrarian relations, job creation, and so on. Most works – for all their value – have consequently missed the opportunity to provide a more complicated picture of the ways in which recent struggles over land are entangled in longer, often contradictory, local struggles over identity, sovereignty, development, landscape, belonging, land, and water. Fontein's excellent and timely ethnographic-historical contribution suffers no such shortcomings.
Fast-track land reform, argues Fontein, has merely introduced the latest phase in a long history of complex local and wider struggles over such matters in one small but politically and historically significant area in southern Zimbabwe: the former commercial farmland, ‘communal areas’, and National Parks land around lake Mutirikwi. Lake Kyle, as it was called before 1980, was officially opened in 1961, a modernist colonial development project to supply water to the massive downstream lowveld sugar plantations at Triangle and Hippo Valley. Its ‘beautiful’ landscape also played a major role in white settler projects of belonging, aesthetics, and leisure (see Chapter Seven). The creation of Mutirikwi was one event among a number in the colonial era that contributed to the gradual removal of the area's inhabitants to make way for white farms, game parks, and the dam's impoundment.
Remaking Mutirikwi is based mainly on Fontein's in-depth ethnographic research around Mutirikwi in 2005–6. He also draws on insights from later field visits and on his previous work on nearby Great Zimbabwe. Furthermore, Fontein skillfully weaves history and historiography into his account, drawing on his thorough, and revealing, examination of archival sources. Yet he eschews a narrative form that assumes a conventional kind of temporality, presenting the history of the Mutirikwi area ‘backwards’, to ‘defy normative linear temporalities and the deterministic causalities they imply’ (289).
The first half of the book provides a detailed ethnographic exploration of recent (post-FTLRP) ‘politics of belonging, entitlement, and sovereignty involved in remaking Mutirikwi's landscapes in the 2000s’ (6). Fontein explores how, for the ‘new yet autochthonous farmers’ around Mutirikwi, post-2000s land invasions were part of a long history of occupations, protests, and claims in the area (31). War veterans, peasant farmers, spirit mediums, chiefs, headmen, state officials, and others were entangled in complex ways in the emerging local politics of belonging. Fontein shows how for those occupying former commercial farms, the invasions did not come at the cost of ‘modernising developmentalism’, but that land beneficiaries around Mutirikwi held diverse aspirations, including ancestral reclaim and livelihoods, and technocratic development and modernity (45).
In an astute micro- and macro-political analysis of the FTLRP, Fontein shows how it was a state-making process; a response to the frustrated ambitions of war veterans and mediums, chiefs and village heads; a reassertion of traditionalism in the rural areas, ‘revitalising the possibility, at least for some, of making the state work towards their interests’ (43). And yet, he shows, war veterans and the government, chiefs and mediums, manipulated and shaped each other as they pursued their distinct and overlapping agendas. The complex ‘micro-politics of belonging’ discussed in Fontein's analysis reveals the complex subjectivities of land beneficiaries, going beyond the usual simplistic understandings of who qualified for land under the FTLRP (52).
In another fascinating chapter (Chapter Three), Fontein convincingly shows how weather, and attempts to control the weather through rain making ceremonies, has been a key political tool – and index of power – in rural Zimbabwe as the state sought not only to use repressive, but also productive, mechanisms of power to win rural support. Chapter Five provides more detail on contested ‘history-scapes’ and the ‘genealogical geographies’ (139) invoked by local clans, a contestation which, argues Fontein, ‘points to the ongoing becoming of both landscape and the past’ (146).
The later chapters consider earlier remakings ‘before, during and after the dam was built, the traces of which continued to animate the events of the 2000s’ (6). Among other things, Fontein shows how, like rainmaking, dam building was a key index of state power, indicating both ‘a massive demonstration of sovereignty and a powerful appeal to legitimacy’ (175).
Remaking Mutirikwi is a highly recommended – if not essential reading – for anyone with an interest in Zimbabwe's rural history and contemporary sociology. Always theoretically sophisticated, it is nonetheless a lucid and accessible text, and is one of the most nuanced and valuable works of non-fiction to be written on Zimbabwe in the last decade.
