In 1894 Captain Alfred Dreyfus, a talented young Jewish officer serving on the General Staff of the French army, was accused of selling military secrets to the German embassy in Paris. Despite the lack of evidence and motive, Dreyfus was prosecuted, convicted, and sentenced to life imprisonment. Over the next decade the Dreyfus affair emerged as a pivotal event in French history, as first Dreyfus's family and then an increasing number of republican politicians and intellectuals fought to correct an injustice, opposed by a coalition of army officers, Catholics, and monarchists. Dreyfus was eventually exonerated, with the guilty verdict of 1894 finally overturned by the Cour de Cassation, the French Supreme Court, in 1906.
There is, unsurprisingly, an enormous literature on the Dreyfus affair, which is both a compelling story on its own terms, and an incident that illuminates many of the political and social divisions that tore apart not only France but Europe in general in the late nineteenth and the first half of the twentieth century. Anti-Semitism, virulent nationalism, and the fragility of democratic institutions and the rule of law were all on display in the Dreyfus affair, foreshadowing many of the toxic events that devastated Europe for the next several decades. In the past few months two other books on the Dreyfus affair have appeared: For the Soul of France: Culture Wars in the Age of Dreyfus, by Frederick Brown (Knopf, 2010) and Dreyfus: Politics, Emotion, and the Scandal of the Century, by Ruth Harris (Metropolitan Books, 2010). Brown situates the affair in the political context of Third Republic France, divided between those who were nostalgic for a Catholic monarchy and supporters of a secular republic. Harris emphasizes the historical and psychological complexity of the affair, and moves away from the simple categorization of heroes and villains that frequently shapes historical accounts. Of the recent books, Louis Begley's is the most concise treatment, commendable for its narrative clarity. But Begley's account is unusual in its straightforward claim for the contemporary relevance of the Dreyfus affair. A lawyer by profession, but also a highly respected novelist, Begley sees the Dreyfus affair as an instructive lesson for Americans concerned about the issues of due process and abusive treatment of prisoners raised by the American-run prison in Guantanamo.
Chapter 1 reviews the prosecution of Dreyfus in 1894 and the atrocious conditions of his imprisonment on Devil's Island, off the coast of French Guiana, from 1895 to 1899. Begley has not uncovered any new material on these matters, but his narrative is valuable because of its focus on the numerous illegal maneuvers at the highest level of the French army that led to Dreyfus's conviction. Secret evidence was presented at the trial, with no opportunity for defense counsel to review and evaluate material that included forged documents. The incarceration of Dreyfus, held in solitary confinement and shackled for long periods to his bed, violated the law on deportation, which called only for prisoners to be prevented from escape. At the conclusion of his first chapter (28–45), Begley turns his attention to the legal issues and the court cases arising from the imprisonment and attempted prosecution of detainees captured during the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. For Begley, the Dreyfus affair matters first of all because it mirrors the violation of due process and the abuse of prisoners that occurred at the Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo prisons in the wake of the attack of September 11, 2001.
Begley turns to the international and domestic contexts for the affair in his second chapter. The anxiety that followed the defeat of France in the Franco-Prussian War of 1870–71 generated a defensive mood and a search for scapegoats, as well as a blind commitment to the army, understood as the key to French recovery, an institution beyond criticism. Begley sees Dreyfus as captured in part by this mood, for he was fully committed to the French nation, which had granted Jews civil rights at the time of the Revolution, and to the army, which he always believed would act to correct an obvious injustice. The anti-Semitism that Dreyfus sought to deny still operates in France, as documented in Begley's account, which reviews recent incidents of violence and desecration. In chapters 3 and 4 Begley turns to the struggle to free Dreyfus; like other scholars he places the figure of Major Georges Picquart at the heart of this effort. After assuming a position in the army office of intelligence Picquart realized that secrets were still being passed to the Germans and came to suspect a Major Esterhazy of the crime. Despite the growing evidence of Esterhazy's guilt and Dreyfus's innocence, a cabal of officers consistently obstructed Picquart's investigation and instead turned on him, accusing him of forgery and conspiracy. Begley sees the actions of the army as a classic cover-up that once begun assumed a momentum of its own, leading those involved to ever more numerous and egregious violations of law and morality. Picquart's battle from within the army was matched by a growing campaign in the press, with the notable participation of Emile Zola, and his public accusation of crimes at the highest level of the French army. Begley emphasizes, however, that even as the pressure for a reconsideration of Dreyfus's conviction grew, the army and its political supporters on the right continued to fight hard. Zola, despite his iconic status, was prosecuted for libel and forced to flee the country. At a second court martial in 1899 the military judges, refusing to acknowledge past errors, found Dreyfus guilty again, with the absurd qualification of “extenuating circumstances” (161). A presidental pardon spared Dreyfus from further punishment, but it took another seven years before all charges against him were dismissed. The injustice of Dreyfus's treatment may seem clear to us now, and his eventual exoneration can make it seem that truth must inevitably prevail in such cases. Begley's account provides no such reassurance, for he shows us instead the power and intransigence of those convinced that the nation and the army were at risk and their willingness to violate the law in order to defend them.
Begley's work can serve as an excellent introduction to the Dreyfus affair, particularly for its careful attention to the legal issues involved. Most professional historians would hesitate to bring together past and present in the forthright fashion that he adopts. Begley is not simplistic in his comparisons, and he acknowledges that while Dreyfus was clearly innocent this may not be the case with all of the detainees in Guantanamo. Nonetheless, he has no compunction about drawing lessons from the Dreyfus affair, which shows us the fragility of respect for human rights, even in constitutional regimes ostensibly dedicated to the rule of law and to basic human decency.
