No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
Racial Revolutions comes at a crucial time for indigenist policy in Brazil. Newly elected president Luís Inácio Lula da Silva takes over with several orders for the permanent protection of Indian reserves on his desk, completed but left unsigned by outgoing president Fernando Henrique Cardoso. Lula's party, the Workers Party, has a strongly progressive social platform on issues of racial discrimination but no track record or firm positions on Indian issues. Fundamental changes in Brazilian Indian law have been proposed and may come before Congress early this year. Three fatal attacks on Indians occurred in January 2003, the first month of Lula's presidency. One of these cases, the murder by youths of a seventy-seven year-old Indian man in Porto Alegre, recalls the fatal 1997 immolation of a visiting Pataxó leader while sleeping at a bus stop in Brasília, a well-publicized case with which Jonathan Warren opens his book. Finally, anthropologists who work with Indians in Brazil are still dealing with the repercussions of serious ethical charges involving research among the Yanomami Indians raised against senior Amazonianists by journalist Patrick Tierney in his book Darkness in El Dorado (2000).
Racial Revolutions comes at a crucial time for indigenist policy in Brazil. Newly elected president Luís Inácio Lula da Silva takes over with several orders for the permanent protection of Indian reserves on his desk, completed but left unsigned by outgoing president Fernando Henrique Cardoso. Lula's party, the Workers Party, has a strongly progressive social platform on issues of racial discrimination but no track record or firm positions on Indian issues. Fundamental changes in Brazilian Indian law have been proposed and may come before Congress early this year. Three fatal attacks on Indians occurred in January 2003, the first month of Lula's presidency. One of these cases, the murder by youths of a seventy-seven year-old Indian man in Porto Alegre, recalls the fatal 1997 immolation of a visiting Pataxó leader while sleeping at a bus stop in Brasília, a well-publicized case with which Jonathan Warren opens his book. Finally, anthropologists who work with Indians in Brazil are still dealing with the repercussions of serious ethical charges involving research among the Yanomami Indians raised against senior Amazonianists by journalist Patrick Tierney in his book Darkness in El Dorado (2000).
Warren's provocative ethnography of newly resurgent Indians in Brazil's Northeast region, based on his 1997 doctoral dissertation in sociology at the University of California, Berkeley, goes straight to the heart of these issues: the semiotics of indigenous identity; discourses on indigeneity among the Brazilian public at large; and efforts by Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs), the federal Indian agency (FUNAI), and Brazilian courts to define “Indian” and adjudicate legal claims. The focus of Warren's book is the unexpected rise over the last several decades in the number of self-identified Indians, defying longstanding predictions of Brazilian intellectuals, including even many sympathetic anthropologists. The best-known cases of indigenous movements are in the Amazon basin, involving culturally distinct and often well-known tribes. Many of these have become better organized and have recently won legal victories over ranchers, state police forces, and even the Brazilian military. Warren's research is with the most improbable and interesting cases of this demographic trend: Indians in the states of Minas Gerais, Bahia, and Espírito Santo in eastern Brazil. They constitute communities considered “assimilated” for many decades, phenotypically and often culturally indistinguishable from the mixed-race rural caboclo masses. These groups include the Canoeira, Kaxixó, Krenak, Maxakali, Pankararu, Pataxó, and Tupinikim tribes.
Despite loss of language and cultural practices that would distinguish them from their non-Indian neighbors, memories of genealogies and common oppression have lingered on and, with the encouragement and material assistance of Church-based NGOs, been translated into assertion—so far with mixed results—of legal rights to land under the progressive 1988 Constitution. Horrific massacres of Indians at the hands of miners, ranchers, local police, and—as in some of the recent cases—bored upper-class youth still occur, but the federal government offers more protection than it used to, and public attitudes have generally shifted to widespread condemnation of violence against Indians. Warren argues that long-suppressed Indian identities are tentatively reemerging as the dangers of such self-identification diminish. Even more important for this unlikely resurgence, in Warren's view, is the fact that the bureaucratic gatekeepers of indigeneity have finally begun to catch up with the great sea change of thinking about ethnicity that swept through anthropology and sociology in the 1960s. Gone are checklists of genetic and cultural markers, replaced by the flexible criteria of self-identification and recognition of distinctiveness by others. Many of these new, “post-traditional” Indians, as Warren calls them, have borrowed languages from neighboring groups and (re)invented religious rituals without thus automatically disqualifying themselves from legal recognition.
Warren's book is at its best when he lets his post-traditional Indian informants speak for themselves about these matters. The book is structured around a defense of their rights against those who claim they have cynically adopted Indian identities as a way of gaining access to the resources such recognition offers. The chance to carve out communal lands from the vast, fiercely defended private fiefdoms of the Brazilian interior is obviously very attractive, and Warren admits to the significance of this opportunity as a factor in the resurgence. Indian rights granted by the 1988 Constitution theoretically make the return of certified lands to indigenous communities uncontestable, but an apparently contradictory 1997 decree signed by former President Cardoso has in fact opened each indigenous land claim to charges of “racial hucksterism,” in Warren's words, and years of debilitating litigation. Warren's case is convincing, not least because his informants speak eloquently of their collective memories of expulsion and impoverishment, as both Indians and rural landless Brazilians.
The strength of his argument is marred somewhat by confusing jumps to North American material, unhelpful and misleading neologisms (“state exorcism,” “Indianing”), and errors of Portuguese. The major weakness of the book lies, however, in the title and the secondary argument of the book, which is that the renascent forms of Indian identity represent an important and overlooked force in the struggle against “white supremacy” in Brazil. Warren fails to acknowledge, even minimally, that the fight over “racial politics” in Brazil centers on the question of whether there are indeed racial politics in Brazil. The last ten years have seen Brazilianist social science caught up in a polemical debate about the meaning of “racial democracy.”
On one side are political scientists, sociologists, and—recently—some cultural anthropologists who argue that the “myth” of racial democracy is an iron-fisted ideological formation that has allowed whites to exclude blacks from the middle and upper classes all the while denying that they are racist and enjoying the hegemonic complicity of the racial “subalterns,” in the current lingo adopted by Warren (see, for example, Hanchard [1999], Sheriff [2001], Twine [1998]). The mixed-race categories that so markedly distinguish Latin American social formations from the North American model are seen as mystifications and instruments of oppression. The failure, by and large, of political movements aimed at fostering non-white ethnic and political solidarity, is attributed to a pervasive racial false consciousness.
The other side, argued principally by historians and anthropologists (see, for example, Fry 1996, 2000; Norvell 2001; Maggie 1991; Sansone 2003), builds on ethnographic and sociological research from the 1950s that emphasizes the fluid and transitory nature of racial identification in Brazil, overall low rates of social mobility in an economy historically built on personal networks, and pernicious “social” discrimination based on a complex blend of markers of social class, including education, grammar, regional background, and an aesthetics of skin color and other putatively “racial” features. They argue that Brazilians of all hues and social classes are being basically honest and accurate when they say that they enact or experience discrimination along nonracial lines, even though sociometric data, when forced through the crude numerical sieve of the federal census, manifest aggregate effects that seem “racially” structured.
In labeling Brazil's social formation “white supremacy,” Warren and his wife, France Winddance Twine (with whom he carried out parts of his fieldwork and whose work on racial identification [Twine 1998] he frequently cites), have pushed the first position to an extreme. That Warren does not even hint at this larger debate and his position with respect to it is a serious flaw, especially considering its crucial and obvious implications for the future of “race” as a category of comparative analysis.
Putting to the side this polemic in the arena of white/Afro-Brazilian relations, the attempt to pull the politics of indigeneity into the politics of “race” is doubly problematic. Despite his persuasive analysis of these new forms of Indian identity in the terms of ethnicity laid out by the “Barthian break” (215), Warren argues that race—defined as “phenotype/genotype” (241)—is a fundamental element of Indianness, despite strong evidence to the contrary in the words of his own informants. He ends up hastily dismissing the statements of many anthropologists and indigenist activists on this point. A worrisome re-essentialization of race is epidemic in the Brazilian “race relations” field, and there are hints of it in Warren's book as well.