Yaron Shemer's new book on contemporary Mizrahi cinema in Israel is a thrilling addition to the revisionist literature within Mizrahi studies, and one that should serve theoreticians of third-world cinema, ethnic studies, Palestinian studies, and Middle Eastern studies. Reflecting its author's theoretical sophistication, his encyclopedic knowledge of Mizrahi literary and cinematic production, and his involvement in Mizrahi radical politics, this work will influence subsequent scholarship on identity politics, representation, spatiality, and subaltern studies.
One of the book's most important contributions is to shift our gaze from the representational realm, namely, how Mizrahi characters, narratives, themes, and spaces were represented in films created mostly by Ashkenazi Israelis, to the realm of agency, protest, and empowerment, in which Mizrahi filmmakers articulate their concerns to Mizrahi, Israeli, and global audiences. The new wave of Mizrahi filmmaking has taken shape as Israeli cinema, since the 1990s, experienced an unprecedented revival. Shemer's work, however, is by no means a naïve depiction of cinematic successes. He lists the many obstacles that stood, and stand, in the way of Mizrahi filmmakers (especially in his trenchant analysis of the ways in which the Israeli film and television industry funds Mizrahi works) by showing, for example, that certain nonradical films on the Arab-Israeli conflict receive more funding than radical works because of their supposed global marketability. The works he analyzes were mostly filmed in Israel, although some also take their protagonists to the Arab countries in which they were born and lived.
Through his deft analysis of Mizrahi documentaries in which auteurs reflect critically on their relationships with their parents—some of the latter prominent artists in Arab states prior to their arrival in Israel—Shemer conveys the ability of Mizrahi cinema to challenge hegemonic voices. He likewise underscores the power of what he calls “protest films” to tackle issues long neglected in Israeli history and historiography. This is particularly evident in his reflections on The Ringworm Children (2003), a film that exposed how the radiation “treatment” of hundreds of Mizrahi children against ringworm led to deaths of some children at the time and the later appearance of cancer in those who survived radiation. Furthermore, Shemer shows how protest was mediated not only through brave documentaries, but also through feature films, such as Sh’hur (1995), which focused on issues related to magic, class, and gender. Reading about the films—especially the documentaries—we also learn about their protagonists, including Mizrahi heroes such as the radical Iraqi novelist Sami Michael; the gay advocate of Palestinian rights Ezra Nawi; and former Black Panther member Reuven Abergil, who has remained committed to the movement's social justice agenda long after the movement was dissolved.
His attention to the processes of production and distribution causes Shemer to identify and analyze new phenomena, such as the role of the Sederot Film Festival in Israel, a new space for Mizrahi creativity. Commenting on casting choices, he highlights a fascinating phenomenon, namely, the casting of Palestinians to play the roles of Mizrahim, as a way of thinking about the possibilities this kind of “passing” opens up. I wish Shemer would have written more about the counterphenomenon, namely, Mizrahi actors who play Palestinians and Arabs in Israeli cinema; and yet his comments are in conversation with other explorations of performed ethnicity in Israel, including Eitan Bar Yosef's work on blackface in Israeli theater (where Mizrahi Jews, whose faces were colored black, frequently played the roles of Africans).
The book's insightful interpretations of many Mizrahi films make it a valuable intervention in the study of ethnicity in Israel. Shemer examines a series of ethnic relationships: between Arab-Jewish and Mizrahi identities; between the categories of gender, third-world feminism, and class; and between Mizrahi and Palestinian radicalism. When analyzing these relationships, Shemer underscores certain alliances (such as the one between the displaced Mizrahis and the Palestinians), but also tensions and ambiguities. This book's theoretical sophistication is noticeable in Shemer's highly interesting consideration of spatiality, where he illustrates how Mizrahi spaces are often constructed as Orientalized and desert-like realms from which one must escape. Another noteworthy case is Shemer's commentary on the connections between historiography, nationalism, and cinema in his analysis of Yizhak Halutzi's films on Iraqi Jewish history (Pigtails and the Farhud), which illustrates how Mizrahis themselves at times adopt Zionist narratives. Shemer suggests that Halutzi's films depict Iraq as a site of perpetual persecution so that Halutzi's Mizrahi protagonists could find a place within the Israeli hegemonic narratives, which perceive the state as rescuing Jews from global anti-Semitism. Social scientists who are familiar with this narrative will find very interesting parallels here between Israeli national memory construction and Israeli cinema.
Through an exploration of the multidimensional characteristics of Mizrahi cinema, the book gives voice to second-generation Mizrahis trying to make sense of the experiences of their parents, to Mizrahi feminists, and to Mizrahi activists who deconstruct the state's hegemonic institutions. The book also integrates written texts (interviews, articles, reviews, and essays) of the most important Mizrahi actors, filmmakers, and activists, such as Ron Chachlili, Sami Shalom Chetrit, and Hannah Azoulay-Hasfari, in which they comment on issues of reception and representations. Shemer thereby gives readers a sense of the wider radical Israeli Mizrahi scene. The subject of Shemer's book is not merely academic for him—it is deeply personal. Shemer, a Jew of Iraqi descent, a member of an important radical organization, the Mizrahi Democratic Rainbow, and a contributor to the Mizrahi film industry, offers us his vision of the politics, radicalism, and theory informing his critiques of Ashkenazi Zionism.
My only criticism of the book is that at times it deploys a binary of Ashkenazi/Mizrahi that seems too rigid, and in its drastic modes, silences other voices in Israeli society, most notably that of the Palestinian. In his review of the film Cut by Nizar Hassan (2000), Shemer suggests that Hassan, because he eventually comes to see Mizrahi Jews as right-wingers with whom he has difficulty identifying, subscribes to an Arab national narrative. A more generous reading of Hassan's work could speak about Hassan's disappointment that displaced Mizrahi Jews who came from Arab countries did not struggle with him as a Palestinian whose nation was displaced by Israel. The binary of Ashkenazi-Mizrahi also leads to a greater focus on the Israeli context, as opposed to the broader Middle Eastern context.
A case in point is Shemer's beautiful analysis of The Band's Visit (2007), in which he indicates that “the cosmopolitan” and “the European” are represented in the film not by Ashkenazi Jews but rather by a cosmopolitan group of Egyptians who get stuck in a southern development town (towns in the periphery of Israel built to absorb Mizrahi newcomers) and charm its underprivileged Mizrahi inhabitants. Shemer then proceeds to call them Ashkenazi-fied Arabs. I see the innovative theoretical intervention here: culture still comes to the development town from the outside and not from the inside. But I wonder if by attaching the title “Ashkenazi” to Arabs we are not, in some way, accepting the assumption that “Ashkenazi” equals “European,” and neglecting the fact that the film invites its viewers to think about what would have happened if Jews could have stayed in such global cities as Alexandria or Beirut. Similarly, Shemer quotes Sami Shalom Chetrit's provocative critique of the film Desperado Square (2001), which celebrates the love of a Mizrahi family for Indian movies, where Chetrit asks why the representation of Mizrahi identity focuses on faraway India but not the Arab culture of most Mizrahi Jews. I completely agree with this critique, and yet, historically, Indian cinema has been adored by Arab audiences all over the Middle East. Limiting the love of India to the Israeli context, and to an alternative to Arab culture, does injustice to the rich cultures—Arab, Indian, Persian, and Turkish—that Mizrahi Jews were forced to forsake when they came to Israel.
These minor critiques aside, this is a groundbreaking work in its scope and original analysis. The book leaves its readers torn between sadness and despair, on the one hand, and modest hope, on the other. Sadness comes with the stories of displaced Mizrahi communities and their sufferings, in transit camps, in development towns, and in a society that relegated their Arab and Middle Eastern cultures to the undesirable exilic realm of the enemy. But the book is also about hope, agency, and the ability of the Mizrahim to reclaim their culture and call for protest, social change, and social justice in a neoliberal, and rather callous, society. At the core of these endeavors stand Mizrahi cinema, with its gifted filmmakers, and the broader community of Mizrahi activists and critics, as well as Yaron Shemer himself, who has so insightfully brought to our attention their efforts and successes.
