In 2013, the European Union is planning to reform its bulky complex of agricultural and rural measures. Judging from the draft proposals issued by the European Commission in the fall of 2011, however, we should expect to see an increased emphasis on named public goods, such as environmental protection, food safety and quality products, and animal welfare—in short, a widening of the protection against “public bads.” Elisabeth Prügl's book enters a universe where some of these policy measures are translated into practice, and the book therefore arrives at a time when practitioners and policy experts might pick it up and learn. But the book will also have a longer shelf life, because it makes substantial scholarly contributions to our understanding of the ways that gender roles in the European countryside are negotiated and transformed in local settings.
Gender mainstreaming became an integral part of all EU policies at the turn of the century, particularly through the EU's rural programs—known under the acronym of LEADER—that since the 1990s have been implemented with the direct participation of local communities. The EU is portrayed as a spatially decentered state that is involved in the making, implementation, and translation of policies at multiple levels. The study compares the changes to women's rules of entitlements, labor control, and identities in two specific German Länder, namely, Saxony-Anhalt—formerly part of the German Democratic Republic (GDR)—and the southern state of Bavaria, ruled by the Christian Social Union. This research design is generally convincing, and makes the study relevant for several groups of scholars, particularly policy experts, students of gender studies, and those generally interested in the EU; this ambition is flagged in the book's subtitle.
Prügl explores three different phases of the transformation of social structures and gendered power relations in these two German lands. The Cold War division of Germany had separated the western part from its traditional breadbasket, with large farms in the East. Farming in Saxony-Anhalt and Bavaria subsequently faced very different agricultural policy regimes in the decades to come. In the 1960s, the Federal Republic of Germany (FRG) championed the creation and implementation of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) as a redistributive policy, whereby the independent farmer—as head of the family farm—gained rights of entitlements. In most cases, the farmer was the patriarch of the family. The work of the wife, however, was not recognized, and she received no entitlements under the CAP. She also stood in the shadow of her husband's entitlements to welfare provisions, such as pension and sick leave at the national level, and her lack of formal employment status meant that her rights to maternity leave were minimal. On a small family farm, as the majority of farms in Bavaria were, the wife would have long working hours, with no holidays. To make ends meet, many had to find incomes outside agriculture, as well as tend to the farm on a part-time basis. The moral economy of the family farm informing the CAP institutionalized what Prügl calls the masculine rule in the countryside. In the GDR, the situation was very different. Everyone involved with the large farms were considered workers; they had fixed working hours, there were child-care facilities, and there was, roughly speaking, equality between the sexes. The fall of the Berlin Wall, with the annexation of the GDR into the FRG and the EU, was to change this situation dramatically.
The fight for nondiscrimination and entitlements for women in farming was gearing up in the 1980s in the West, and feminist groups were, according to Prügl, vocal and decisive, even though what they gained was, at best, a piecemeal improvement. The LEADER program, with integral gender-mainstreaming components, opened a new set of opportunity structures in rural development. The author interviewed participants at various levels to examine its effects on the structure of masculine rule and gender roles. She found that while there are now more women in farming than previously, there was no convincing implementation of gender mainstreaming in either of the two states examined. In Saxony-Anhalt, several groups were inclined positively to adopt gender mainstreaming from the outset, but that changed. Bureaucratic proceduralism stood in the way, and Prügl found it “impossible to draw conclusions about the impact of the strategy” (pp. 129–30). Gender mainstreaming took the backseat where other state projects in rural areas existed. In the region of Bavaria explored, new jobs were created for women in the rural economy, but they were typically low paid, part time, and generally unattractive. Her conclusions are therefore bittersweet.
Too many studies of the EU are oblivious to long-term temporal processes of transformation, and therefore Prügl should be lauded for her sociohistorical literacy and nuance, a strength that is undersold in the book's title. Transforming Masculine Rule is not without limits, however, and I will briefly consider three of them here. Firstly, the book rightly approaches the CAP and rural policies as public policies. It aims to examine how feminists have contributed to the transformation of gender relations; it looks at activities by feminists, women's groups, and female participants and concludes that feminist engagements helped undermine—or at least transform—masculine rule in the European countryside. The question is, of course, whether it is sufficient to look at feminist activities, in a narrow sense, in what is otherwise characterized as a decentered, multilayered political system with a large variety of political actors involved. Prügl's conclusions may be correct, but they would have been more convincing to nonfeminists had she taken a step away from the normative feminist agenda. An alternative would have been to give voice to some of the women who were satisfied with life on the family farm and worked for its survival, and who essentially were part of the resistance to change—or to the male farmers who were having difficulty finding a wife willing to move to a farm, thereby imperiling the family's farm for generations. Both categories exist and will tell us different stories about the transformation of gender roles.
Secondly, the terminology derived from the concept of “liberal” is applied, well, liberally. Liberal is used to describe the regime of private ownership of land, and this is entirely fitting for comparisons between East and West. Liberalization is also used to characterize each of the phases examined. But while the periodization certainly makes sense, it is generally a misnomer for this most thoroughly regulated sector. The activities examined in the book, in fact, demonstrate elegantly that the political involvement stretches to the micromanaging of private enterprises and local communities. Perhaps that is why a paragraph can be found in the conclusion that alternates between “liberalization” with and without quotation marks (pp. 131–32).
Finally, one of the important features of the book is that it demonstrates how the EU has the capacity to transform people's lives. Yet it seems puzzling why Prügl does not connect more clearly to the emerging literature on the sociology of the EU. The biggest risk for a book like this one is that all the scholars of the EU who do not have an interest in topics relating to gender, agricultural policy, and rural development—and they constitute a clear majority—will not find the time to read it. But they should read it, for it offers a nuanced analysis of a very important theme that cuts across time and territory.
