Confronted with the news of Antigone's crime defying orders against the burial of her fallen brother, Polynices, the newly elevated king Creon asks his sentry, incredulously, “Exactly when did you last see the gods celebrating traitors? Inconceivable!” In that moment, Sophocles's tragic dilemma is fully entailed and embodied. Thebes was at war, and one of her attackers was a native son who had turned against his city. He would be dishonored and punished even in death for his act of betrayal. An oddly similar view was held by President Woodrow Wilson and much of America in the case of Prisoner No. 9653, Eugene V. Debs, at the time surrounding the First World War. In his wonderfully rendered history of the time and the players in this important, telling, and strangely perennial national drama, Ernest Freeberg deftly evokes the spirit of the classical poet while remaining true to the traditional, Whiggish sensibility that American readers continue to find comforting and comfortable.
Though Wilson as Creon can say in response to those demanding a pardon for Debs that “While the flower of American youth was pouring out its blood to vindicate the cause of civilization, this man, Debs, stood behind the lines, sniping, attacking, and denouncing them” (265–66), Freeberg can also state with evident sympathy that “Those working to liberate Debs and his comrades were engaged in ‘a new fight for old liberties’” (321). Agreeing with Eric Foner that the struggles of the postwar amnesty movement were responsible for the “birth of civil liberties” (322), Freeberg finds progress and hope for the fulfillment of the American liberal-democratic project even in the midst of a certain brand of tyranny, repression, jingoism, and mob rule. In an ironic twist that must certainly make Louis Hartz smirk from his grave, this moment of political grace is wrenched from the fiery pit by a ragtag group of American leftists working in collaboration with ACLU-liberals, the conservative labor leader Samuel Gompers and his AFL, as well as the bland and much maligned and conservative Republican, President Warren G. Harding. Strange bedfellows indeed.
Democracy's Prisoner is a book that works on numerous levels providing not only a fascinating and cogent view of the questions and tensions that emerged in the area of American civil liberties during and after the “war to end all wars,” but also of the complex interplay between ideas, interests, institutions, and individuals. One part biography of Eugene Debs, one part ethnography of the American Left, one part brief on behalf of liberal constitutionalism, one part cautionary tale, and, at least sub-textually, one part contemporary morality play, the book tells the story of an American regime engaged in a dangerous, acrimonious, and occasionally violent high-stakes struggle with what many would consider its better angels.
Although Debs is the moral center of the narrative, he is, in the end, but a knight to the First Amendment's grail for the author. Beginning with Debs's founding of the Socialist Party in 1901, Freeberg recounts the rise of the most important American socialist and his movement with evident sympathy for the man and his myriad virtues—faith, hope, charity, and courage—if only ambiguous support for his larger political cause. While the government was using the Espionage Act and the Sedition Act to suppress all opposition to the war through vigorous censorship of the progressive press and the imprisonment of the political opposition for supposed acts of incitement, and the Left was arguing that free speech was merely a bourgeois patina used to sustain the fiction of a democratic regime in the United States, Debs stood firm in his rejection of dictatorship in all its forms. For this, Freeberg argues, “Debs looked to many like a martyr for the cause of free speech, the embodiment of a sacred right of patriotic dissent” (214). While this is perhaps an apt description, it must be said that such a role was not the one Debs himself had chosen. Debs was a revolutionary—a revolutionary who believed in the ballot box, yes—but a revolutionary all the same. In his words, “I am not a Russian bolshevik in America … but an American bolshevik—fighting for what they have in Russia” (212).
It is that fight, and not some abstract defense of the principle of free speech, that drove the relentless Debs ultimately to his jail cell. As Floyd Dell, a prominent contemporary on the Left, put it, “Jesus was not crucified for being nice to people, nor is Debs in jail for being the kindest man alive” (247). While doing a solid job of unpacking the ideological and practical infighting that took place among the various groups of leftists, Freeberg does occasionally seem to downplay the overarching radicalism and true nature of the Debsian vision for the nation. Freeberg's note early in the text that “Though he [Debs] denounced the legal system as the handmaiden of capitalism, it granted him enough freedom to make a fair living as a professional revolutionist” (24) is a telling one. Embedded in such a sentence are the seeds of political domestication that one would imagine the man himself would abhor. Right or wrong, Debs had come to believe that American liberalism was the problem not the solution. Though he certainly played a clear role in exposing the American system's “shotgun behind the door,” this was only a necessary condition for the realization of his larger and perpetually unrealized political project of a socialist republic. Whatever comfort contemporary liberals might take from Debs's role in the return to “normalcy” his cause helped achieve, we should not lose sight of the fact that it gave Debs and his fellow-travelers little comfort as they watched the fire they hoped to ignite turn to embers.
Freeberg closes this fine and important book with the claim that “We find in the story of convict 9653 an important chapter in our own ongoing arguments about the limits of free speech in times of war, but not the last word” (327), and he is right. Since those fateful hours on September 11, 2001, old questions have emerged again and old liberties are again under siege in the minds of many. That there is no apparent Debs among us is not only ironic, given Freeberg's argument, but perhaps a cause for sadness for those who still believe that a strong democracy needs its gadflies.
