Explaining the rise of far-right parties throughout Europe has been a key challenge facing many political scientists in recent years. A wide range of factors that contribute to the electoral successes of those parties has been identified, but many of them are disputed in the scholarly literature. Antonis Ellinas contributes to this ongoing discussion by providing an analysis of the ways in which far-right parties reach an electoral breakthrough and how they remain successful afterwards. The explanations offered are not new, but the specific mechanisms he identifies, as well as the detailed historical analysis he presents from various parties in Europe, make his argument convincing.
In short, Ellinas argues that for a far-right party to reach an electoral breakthrough, two criteria have to be met. First, mainstream parties need to “play the nationalist card”—for example, by taking a tough stance in public debates or proposing strict legislation on immigration and citizenship—and then subsequently retract the card, by softening their positions or withdrawing legislation. In that way, mainstream parties create political opportunities for a far-right party by initially making the nationalist issue salient and later creating room for the far-right party to profile itself and occupy a unique position in the political space. Second, the media need to devote attention to the far-right party, thereby legitimizing its claims and underlining its political relevance. While the electoral breakthrough is thus determined by factors that are largely exogenous to the far-right party, sustaining support after such a breakthrough depends more heavily on the party itself and the extent to which it is able to organize itself effectively.
The theoretical argument is supported by a detailed analysis of the historical trajectories of far-right parties in four Western European countries: Austria, Germany, Greece, and France. Each of the country chapters offers a clear and detailed analysis of the trajectories of far-right parties since World War II. The chapter on Austria, for example, analyzes how the Freiheitlichen Partei Österreichs was able to profit from intensified discussion on Austria's Nazi past due to the Reder and Waldheim affairs. After the party had obtained considerable media attention in mainstream media, it reached a great electoral victory in the 1986 national elections. Also in (West) Germany, political opportunities for far-right parties seemed to be present in that period. In several instances, the main conservative party, the Christian Democratic Union/Christian Social Union, politicized the issue of minorities, and, due to electoral considerations and internal struggles, softened its position afterwards. Here, however, parties such as the Deutsch Volksunion, Nationaldemokratische Partei Deutschlands, and Republikaner were not able to obtain a lot of media attention, blocking strong increases in support for those parties.
As compelling as the argumentation is, it is unfortunate that the role of the media remains underdiscussed both in theoretical and empirical terms. There are three points on which Ellinas can be criticized here. First, while he provides detailed descriptions of the debates relating to national identity that took place in the various countries, his actual analysis of the media coverage received by far-right parties is ad hoc and rather limited. Instead of providing a systematic and comparable content analysis of coverage for those parties in the various countries, he relies on analyses of limited time periods (e.g., Austria) or even solely on secondary data (e.g., France). While these analyses indeed demonstrate that in the period before an electoral breakthrough far-right parties received considerable media attention, we can not be sure whether that was not also the case at other moments when this breakthrough was not reached.
Second, the conception of media coverage is very limited. Ellinas basically relies on the notion that media visibility as such is key and that in (almost) all instances for fringe parties, “bad publicity is better than no publicity at all” (p. 206). He does not engage with the large amount of literature that discusses the effects of media coverage on electoral preferences and party support. This literature shows that not only the visibility matters but also the level of negativity, as—and this is acknowledged by Ellinas—does the extent to which parties are able to express their points of view (p. 206). If visibility were to be the most crucial factor, one does wonder about the case of Belgium, which is not analyzed in the book. Here, one of the most successful far-right parties in Europe, the Vlaams Blok, was able to obtain high levels of support in the 1990s despite the presence of a cordon sanitaire by media that deliberately ignored the party to a large extent. As Stefaan Walgrave and Knut De Swert (“The Making of the Issues of the Vlaams Blok,” Political Communication 21 [December 2004]: 479–500) demonstrate, the media did contribute to the electoral success of the Vlaams Blok, not by granting the party visibility but by covering the issues with which it is associated, primarily crime and immigration.
Third, it remains largely unclear why media actors decide to start paying attention to far-right parties. Ellinas mentions several factors that might offer an explanation (pp. 211–17): commercialization, the influence of ownership, and professional norms. The difficulty with those explanations lies in the fact that these are all long-term factors that change only gradually. It is difficult to envision how those structural elements can account for heavy fluctuation in the visibility of political parties in the media. If one wants to fully understand the role of media, the reasons behind coverage need a more elaborate discussion and investigation. Reading the separate country chapters, it seems to be that key events—such as the Reder and Waldheim affairs in Austria, the Macedonia issue in Greece, and an intervention by French President François Mitterand urging public television to provide airtime for the Front National leader, Jean-Marie Le Pen—affect not only the behavior of political parties but also the media coverage directly, and in a rather long-term perspective. This is in line with extant research into news values and gatekeeping processes.
Yet despite the abovementioned limitations, the book offers an excellent account of the ways that political opportunities, media coverage, and internal party organization can explain the rise (and decline) of far-right parties throughout Europe. Its theoretical basis might still offer possibilities for refinement, but the analyses contribute to an understanding of one of the most important political phenomena in Western Europe.
