A class hamster. A windowsill garden. A shelf exhibiting student-contributed shells, leaves, mosses and skulls. These elements, found in many contemporary elementary classrooms, share a common, under-recognized origin: the early twentieth-century nature study movement. This sweeping push for curricular reform, launched at the end of the nineteenth century, promoted hands-on learning, engagement with the interests and abilities of young children, and the development of sympathy for nature.
Sally Gregory Kohlstedt's new work, Teaching Children Science: Hands-On Nature Study in North America, is foremost an explicit corrective to more than fifty years of derision and dismissal of the nature study movement in historical treatments of education and science at the turn of the twentieth century. In 1941, Samuel R. Powers's preface to Orra Ervin Underhill's The Origin and Development of Elementary School Science dismissed nature study teachers as ‘poorly educated in science’ and ‘emotional rather than scholarly’ about natural phenomena; later scholars seem to have most often accepted this assessment without further analysis. Kohlstedt's book copiously shows that nature study instruction in the United States warrants a much closer look; indeed, that the movement for nature study is the crucial link between a rote curriculum of reading, arithmetic and classics and one where an understanding of the natural world was considered basic for even young children.
Kohlstedt's argument centres on the many ways in which nature study was malleable: in fact, even defining the term proves a slippery task. While the curriculum maintained certain key elements wherever it was practised, it was the adaptability of nature study that let it take root in so many places, and with such varied champions, producing genuinely nationwide changes. Urban reformers saw it as a way to connect inner-city children with nature in order to develop community and moral values, while rural advocates hoped variously for an increased sympathy for nature, for improved farming skills, and to stem the tide of outward migration from country farm communities; educational philosophers saw an opportunity to implement German psychological ideas about a child-centred curriculum; while normal-school faculty implemented new programmes integrating theory and practice. Had the programme for nature study been more proscriptive, Kohlstedt suggests, it would not have been adopted so readily nationwide. But wherever they were, nature study educators relied on their local physical environments for inspiration and instructional materials, teaching children careful observational skills. And everywhere it took root, nature study endured through the better part of thirty years as an explicit part of public school education, and strongly shaped even the educators who rejected it in the inter-war period.
The heart of Kohlstedt's work, and its greatest strength, is the exhaustive research on which it is built. In sources ranging from government documents, to long-out-of-print textbooks, to limited-distribution pamphlets, to the letters and diaries of nature study teachers, Kohlstedt is clearly a master of her material. In fact, the copious sixty-eight pages of notes are, at times, as engaging as the text itself, and the two appendices and the lengthy bibliography will serve scholars well as they seek to engage with, and expand upon, Kohlstedt's treatment of this topic.
In spite of the title's implication, scholars of North America outside the United States will find little here. There are a few pages on nature study's adoption in Ontario, but not enough to justify any claim of coverage; a title indicating that the breadth of this study is national, not continental, would have been more accurate. In addition, the work examines only public school curricula, noting the difficulty in finding records for parochial and private institutions. Finally, the treatment of nature study in the American south, which seems to have existed only in programmes for African American students sponsored by northern philanthropists, is unfortunately thin, and grouped awkwardly with a similarly brief treatment of the role of nature study in schools for American Indian children. Each of these topics, treated in greater detail, could provide insight into the deeper values and goals of the more mainstream current of the nature study movement. However, these shortcomings in coverage do not detract from the coherence of the work, and should be considered opportunities for further research into this fascinating and under-studied era.
Teaching Children Science is necessary reading for historians of the Progressive Era, for historians of science interested in the relationships between national institutions and local practice, and for anyone interested in the radical changes in American education as the nineteenth century gave way to the twentieth. Educators working in elementary science instruction will also find rich material in this book, as school gardens and a focus on human relationships with the environment have returned to educational prominence.
