Contemporary Directions in Asian American Dance is Yutian Wong's second field-defining contribution to a rapidly growing body of research at the intersections of dance studies and Asian American studies. Like her first book, Choreographing Asian America (Wesleyan University Press, 2010), this anthology grapples with the complex question of how choreographed movement articulates Asian American histories and contemporary experiences. Wong and the other eight contributors to this volume broach a wide range of performance modes—from avant-garde Kabuki Su-odori to taiko, contemporary dance to MTV hip-hop dance competitions—offering an introduction to the field of Asian American dance that is both accessible and open-ended. Where the book truly excels, however, is in not its breadth but its depth. With an evenness of quality that is rare for edited anthologies, each essay in this volume operates on multiple levels and poses questions genuinely new and challenging even for readers who specialize in this field. Angela K. Ahlgren's essay, for example, not only offers an ethnographic history of San Jose Taiko and its founders’ relationships to the Asian American movement, but also asks the larger question of what it means to generate embodied rememberings of Japanese American history that do not focus on internment and are not limited to Japanese Americans. Roko Kawai's essay, which is written autobiographically, operates on one level as a powerfully honest reflection on the awkwardness of negotiating cultural and national in-betweenness, while on another level it delves into difficult questions about personal trauma as an embodied context for living and art making.
As Wong asserts in her introduction, the goal of the book is not only to examine Asian American dance but also—perhaps even more important—to model critical methodologies for Asian American dance studies. As Wong explains, “[T]he essays should be read for their theoretical and methodological approaches to framing practices as Asian American” (19). One aspect of this critical methodology, which Wong demonstrates in the Introduction through her analysis of New York–based Shen Yun Performing Arts, is engaging the work of artists who actively reject the label of “Asian American” yet nevertheless demand Asian American critique. In other words, “framing practices as Asian American” as defined in this book is an operation enacted by a critic or scholar that can exist independently from an artist's autodescriptive account of her own work in relation to Asian American issues or identities. Another methodological practice that the book models extremely well is the importance of placing Asian American critique alongside and in conversation with the theoretical lenses and experiences developed and engaged in adjacent fields, such as African American studies and Native American studies. The essays of Brian Su-Jen Chung and Rosemary Candelario demonstrate the importance of this approach: Chung through his reading of neoliberal antiblack narratives within Asian American participation in America's Best Dance Crew; and Candelario through her exploration of the entangled relationships to nuclear weapons, reparations (or lack thereof), and racism that link Taos Pueblo and Japanese American histories as evoked in Eiko & Koma's Land. This approach reemerges in Wong's conversation with Denise Uyehara in the Afterword, where Asian American critique becomes further enriched through intersections with Mexican American studies and queer studies.
Leaving no issue exempt from critical intervention, the essays in this volume also tackle the structural frameworks that support much Asian American dance, including national funding schemes, discursive habits of critique and self-promotion, and communities of art making defined around or against specific types of Asian American identification or aesthetic approaches. Eury Colin Chang's essay, for example, considers how the explicitly political choreographies of artists like Jay Hirabayashi and Alvin Tolentino benefit from—and even become extensions of—state-sanctioned multiculturalist initiatives, such as Canada Council for the Arts’ Exploration Program and Section 3 of the Multiculturalism Policy of Canada. Additionally, Ellen V. P. Gerdes delves into the thorny issue of how orientalist and racializing discourses about Asian American choreographers—in this case Shen Wei and Kun-Yang Lin—are reproduced in feedback loops between dance critics and artists’ own self-promotional materials, often generating limited parameters for both the creation and interpretation of their work. Lastly, Maura Nguyen Donohue examines the provocative choreographies created by “ambivalent” artists such as Yasuko Yokoshi and Sam Kim, who move between avant-garde art communities traditionally interpreted as white spaces and others designated specifically as Asian American, and in doing so push the boundaries of both categories.
For a volume comprising only nine essays (including the Introduction and Afterword), Contemporary Directions in Asian American Dance addresses an astounding breadth of methodological issues and dance works, while holding together as a sustained, focused, and unflinching treatment of core questions in the emerging field of Asian American dance studies. This book will be a lasting and effective teaching tool for assigning students in dance, theatre, and performance studies and Asian American studies classrooms. Even more, it serves as an intellectual resource for scholars, choreographers, critics, presenters, and funders, who deal every day with the very real and exciting challenges of doing dance in twenty-first-century North America. The book rarely offers solutions to these challenges; rather, it guides us toward finding the right questions.
