Can unearthing histories of black resistance disentangle Classics from its complicity with white supremacy? This is ultimately what is at stake in asking about the relationship of African Americans and the Classics. Margaret Malamud's accessible and wide-ranging book examines how African American engagements with classical Greece and Rome became a means of political contestation in the period spanning the end of the American civil war and the early twentieth century.
Ch. 1, ‘Fighting for Classics’, examines the place of Classics in debates around education for newly free African Americans after the end of the civil war. M. explores how several African Americans such as Alexander Crummell (1819–1898), Anna Julia Cooper (1858–1964) and Fanny Jackson Coppin (1837–1913) developed curricula and institutions with an emphasis on classical learning as part of their opposition to ‘industrial’ forms of education that were advocated by other black leaders. William Sanders Scarborough (1852–1926) embodied the rebuttal to the grossly racist and exclusive notion of white Classics in becoming the first African American person admitted to membership of the American Philological Association. M. frames this struggle for classical knowledge as a rejoinder to the essentialising claims that only the (elite) white man could master the languages and texts of ‘civilization’.
Ch. 2, ‘Figuring Classical Resistance’, demonstrates how Rome and Greece respectively constituted rhetorical, visual, and ideological resources for African Americans attempting to make space for themselves in a hegemonic culture structured by racialised discrimination. The first half of the chapter focuses on the brave rebellion of the slaves aboard the Amistad in 1839. Led by Sengbe Pieh (1814–1879), the African slaves successfully defied their captors and petitioned for their return to West Africa. Pieh's portrait by white abolitionist painter Nathaniel Jocelyn (which furnishes the front cover of the book) caused a furore. While M. concedes that Jocelyn's intention was to represent Pieh in traditional Mende dress, she reads the portrait as classicising — Pieh a latter-day, toga-clad Cato. The discussion of Toussaint L'Ouverture (1743–1803), leader of a successful rebellion against (variously) British, French and Spanish rule and founder of independent Haiti, is intriguing but brief, especially since M. gestures towards his familiarity with classical texts. L'Ouverture was often compared in favourable terms to Spartacus; there is plenty of potential here for reckoning with L'Ouverture's self-fashioning with respect to classical models.
M. works out the inconsistencies in the discourse of American freedom between the ‘political and economic liberty of the free citizen’ and ‘the bodily liberty of the slave’. Ch. 3, ‘Ancient and Modern Slavery’, grapples with how the advocates of slavery, the abolition movement and slaves themselves used ancient Greek and Roman slavery to bolster their positions. M. explores how the white debate on slavery was organised by qualitative comparison: thus how some white slave-owners argued that their iteration of slavery was much more ‘humane’ than that of the ancients, or that the Greeks and Romans as slave-owning societies and creators of civilisational achievements provided justification for the modern practice. The abolitionists, conversely, claimed that slavery indicated a civilisation in decline, degrading to the humanity of all involved. The chapter concludes with an interesting coda on the classicising of public memory and how the civil war reverberates in contemporary American political discourse, for example in the invocation of Lucan's Pharsalia on the Confederate Soldier's Memorial at the Arlington National Cemetery in Virginia.
Ch. 4, ‘Constructing History’, focuses on how African Americans questioned the exemplarity of the Greeks and Romans altogether. Egypt therefore became a site for laying claim to historical authority for African Americans in various ways: for example, in turning the tables and insisting on an Egyptian- and Ethiopian-centric model of history in which the Greeks and Romans owed a debt to African civilisation(s). M. makes an interesting gesture towards the idea that the formation of the early Church in North Africa also supplied grounds for African American preachers such as Prince Hall (1738–1807) and Henry Highland Garnet (1815–1882) to argue against contemporary slavery. The chapter pivots to examine the ambivalent figure of the Pharaoh: either a symbol of an ancient and powerful black civilisation or the forerunner of the white slavemaster. M. explores how this ambivalence plays out in the visual representations of Cleopatra. Against the increasing moves to write civilisational stories that celebrated ancient African achievements and construe these as the patrimony of African Americans, certain parts of the American academy undertook vicious retaliation: nineteenth-century ethnology and pseudo-scientific racism attempted to ground itself in Egyptological research on the one hand, and on essentialised biological schema such as skull size on the other. The chapter concludes with the outright rejections of Eurocentric narratives of civilisation by W. E. B. Dubois (1868–1963). In the ‘Star of Ethiopia’ cultural pageant and the historical narrative of ‘The Negro’, Dubois celebrated Africa on the world historical stage and ushered the classical off it. Thus Malamud demonstrates how Dubois sidesteps a whole set of contradictions in African American classical receptions: ‘the paradox of appropriating the hegemonic discourse of American classicism in the struggle for abolition and equality was that it could yoke African American intellectuals to a culture that suppressed the fullness of their history and identity’ (5).
M. is clear that the racism (epistemic, scientific and otherwise) that underpinned the birth of the American nation and the American discipline of Classics is continuous with contemporary culture, for example in her discussions of Barack Obama's dilemma about whether to send a wreath to the Arlington war memorial, or of Spike Lee's Chi-Raq. It is striking that M.'s exploration of the complex and competing scholarly and popular African American receptions of antiquity gives a share of its attention to white supremacist scholars, politicians and thinkers. When we can tell a story focusing on the rich multiplicity of this tradition — that is, when we can respond to Shelley Haley's call to go beyond the ‘epistemology of the Middle Passage’ and posit blackness only in relation to whiteness — then we might be able to write a history of African American classical reception on its own terms.
