Traditional wisdom has it that historians should not take up a topic for study when archives are still in the making and actors are still alive. In contrast, the essays collected in this volume edited by Ronald Doel and Thomas Söderqvist forcefully make the case for the value of contemporary history of science, technology and medicine. They deal with the challenges as well as the rewards of writing history as it happens, while at the same time probing the specificities of post-Cold War technoscience and (to a lesser extent) medicine and the questions these pose for historians. The book follows a related volume published in the same series about a decade earlier, The Historiography of Contemporary Science and Technology (ed. T. Söderqvist, Amsterdam, 1997). With the exception of the two editors, who also contributed to the first volume, there is no overlap of authors. Essays in the second volume were selected to address topics distinct from those raised in the first. When similar themes are picked up, as for instance the questions surrounding commissioned histories or the challenges of oral history, they are approached from a fresh perspective. Written by established researchers and drawing on their personal scholarly experiences, many essays are autobiographical in style and provide a backstage view of the work that has gone into the production of key publications in the field. Together these highly readable essays offer a first-hand and highly instructive view into the toolbox of recent historians.
The fifteen essays (including a succinct introduction) are loosely subdivided into six parts. Under the heading ‘Where are we now?’, Keay Davidson offers a self-critical account of his career as a science journalist and his eventual illuminating encounter with Thomas Kuhn and the history of science, while Bruce Lewenstein reflects on the complexities of creating an archive of science and technology in the making that serves current as well as future users. The three essays in Part Two focus on legal and ethical issues. David Cantor writes on the pitfalls of commissioned history and the legal challenges a critique of such work can encounter – and indeed did in his case. In an intriguing view from ‘behind the fence’, Anne Fitzpatrick lays out how, despite all its burdens, the demand of security clearance for historians working on classified material – a phenomenon in itself unique to recent science – can facilitate research, by providing access not only to material but also to key scientists. Lastly, Lene Koch reflects on the tasks and obligations of historians writing on politically and ethically charged topics such as the sterilization laws that were in place in her native Denmark until the late 1960s.
In Part Three Thomas Söderqvist, building on his two-decades-long involvement with the life and work of the Danish immunologist Niels Jerne, eloquently defends biography as a genre in the history of science, while Alfred Tauber, also a Jerne scholar, retraces the reflection of his personal intellectual pathway in his scholarship. Part Four includes two essays dealing more specifically with the meaning of the Cold War and how it affects historical scholarship. In his ‘Cold War fable based on facts’, tracing the experimental use of phosphorus-32, which was shipped from the US for the treatment of the brain tumour of a crane operator in occupied Trieste in the late 1940s, John Krige attempts to capture the everyday meaning of Cold War politics. In the following essay, Michael A. Dennis compellingly argues that secrecy in military and industrial research settings does not just raise questions of access, but represents an intimate aspect of the knowledge produced and of knowledge more generally.
Part Five provides a closer look at two key approaches in the history of modern science. Drawing on her extensive experience with oral history, Lillian Hoddeson presents interviewing techniques aimed at reaching beyond the standard accounts given by interviewees and, in collaboration with the scientists, at resolving the common conflicts between memories and documents. In the second essay Doel and Pamela M. Henson survey the challenges and opportunities offered by the use of photographs as historical evidence and the need for historians of science to learn to ‘read’ them. In the final set of papers, Alexis de Greiff and Mauricio Nieto Olearte argue for the importance of science studies' taking up the topic of South–North technoscientific exchanges and thus recovering their original political aspirations. Tilli Tansey discusses the awards and problems of witness seminars, a novel approach to oral history involving numerous participants. In a final essay, Arne Hessenbruch presents the opportunities that the Web has created for dealing with the abundance and complexity of twentieth-century records.
A common theme in Hessenbruch's and other essays is the call for collaborative efforts – in the form of teams of historians or of multidisciplinary teams, including scientists – to capture adequately the scale and broad political, economic and social ramifications of recent technoscience, as well as to make historical research more relevant to different constituencies. The relationship of historians with scientists and other participants is an ever-present concern in the study of recent science, raising questions that bear directly on the very identity of the historian, and in ways that are relevant for the profession as a whole. Thus these essays provide stimulating reading for everyone involved in the study of recent science as well as for anyone interested in historiography more generally. Singly or together, the essays also provide an excellent point of departure for researchers contemplating entry into the field of recent science or getting involved in interviewing, archiving or writing a commissioned history.
