Across the Anglophone world and beyond it, the year 2020 saw the widespread removal of public monuments, which fell to actions both authorized and extralegal. The imbroglio over monuments reminds us that it is still valuable to reflect on the lasting power of the figural image to make meaning, to manifest presence, and to arouse emotion. Examined in the context of nearly a millennium and a half of Buddhism in Japan, these topics receive a masterful treatment in James C. Dobbins's welcome Behold the Buddha: Religious Meanings of Japanese Buddhist Icons. This book distills decades of Dobbins's close contemplation of Japanese Buddhist images into a compact manual, easily consulted and sumptuously illustrated. It will adorn the shelves of serious scholars of Buddhism in Japan, and it will be carried to Japan by grateful exchange students.
Three main parts make up the body of this manual. The introduction and first part, “Making Sense of Buddhist Images,” sketch ways in which Buddhist images have been viewed and treated outside Japan—as spoils for seizure or idols for demolition; as symbols, for decoding; or as art, for aesthetic appreciation. The second chapter in this part, “The Buddhist Image as Sacred Story,” summarizes the life of the Buddha Śākyamuni (Japanese: Shaka). It proposes that life story as a prototype for Buddhist images more broadly: “Behind every icon lies the story of the Buddha” (p. 49). The third chapter, “The Expressive Detail: Buddhist Symbolism and Iconography,” discusses the meanings of the physical features of images of buddhas, the functions they serve, and the multivalent meanings in which they are imbricated.
Part two, “The Proliferation of the Sacred: A Buddhist Gallery,” echoes the hierarchical arrangement typically found in popular introductions to Buddhist images in Japanese, whether in print or electronic media. At the highest rank sit the “Fully Enlightened Buddhas” of chapter 4; the next lower level is inhabited by the “Miraculous Bodhisattvas” of chapter 5; and lower still, among the “Other Mythic Buddhist Figures” of the sixth chapter, do we find the wrathful vidyārājas (Japanese: myōō), as well as guardian figures, and lesser but nonetheless formidable gods or devas (Japanese: ten), some inherited from continental Asia, and others distinct to Japan.
Laudably, Behold the Buddha does not merely explain and catalogue images. Part three takes up “Buddhist Images in the World.” Here, the guide investigates the ontological status of those images. It discusses why those images have traditionally been considered to be alive, where they reside, how they are venerated, and what is sought through such veneration. Chapter 8, “Beyond the Buddha Image,” takes up Buddhist objects that are, perhaps, ontologically adjacent to figural images in Japan. Śarīra relics (Japanese: shari) may be enshrined like icons but have other functions as well, including the legitimization of royal rule. Copies of religious texts are venerated in their own right in Japan, stimulated by Mahāyāna notions of the merit of reproducing scriptures. Calligraphic inscriptions are represented by the Daimoku in Nichiren Buddhism, the Myōgō Honzon in Japanese Pure Land Buddhism, and Zen bokuseki “ink traces.” Portraits of Japanese Buddhist masters, sculpted or painted, are another kind of figural image, not uncommonly revered alongside images of Buddhist deities. Finally, the very landscape of Japan is dotted with countless temples, cemeteries, nameless roadside shrines, and stone images, worn and weathered, as if having grown from the earth itself.
The afterword to Behold the Buddha returns readers to the setting of the museum, with which the book's introduction began. The afterword mentions that twenty-first-century Japan has seen its own “boom,” or long-running fad, for Buddhist images. It suggests that even as artifacts displayed in museums, Buddhist icons in Japan may yet retain their numinous status. Perhaps there could be a merging of the art museum and the temple: even outside Japan, museums “have the capacity to accommodate temple-like experience” (p. 213). The scholarly apparatus includes addresses for the Buddhist institutions discussed in the main body; illustration credits on par with a museum exhibition catalogue; and a bibliography thoughtfully organized by subject, including a list of English translations of religious texts (pp. 245–46).
In effect, Behold the Buddha has reinvigorated a subgenre of scholarship too long neglected in English: the encyclopedic survey of Buddhist images.Footnote 1 This guide would be valuable in the undergraduate classroom, where its already rich assortment of images could be supplemented with various online materials.Footnote 2 Despite Dobbins's claim that the book “does not seek to propose any new scholarly theory” (p. 8), it may do something tantamount to that, by treating the story and the image of Śākyamuni as models for other icons in the Buddhist pantheon. To be sure, in some cases, this claim has already been directly articulated within the premodern tradition. That the life of the Buddha Śākyamuni directly informs—and is in some sense continued by—the celebrated Seiryōji Buddha, for instance, is a claim made in a narrative scroll, Origin Tale of the Hall of Śākyamuni (Shakadō engi, also known as Seiryōji engi, ca. 1515). Future scholarship might well consider in more detail the extent to which the “threefold paradigm of quest, enlightenment, and compassion intersects [with] or underlies” other characters in the great pageant of Japanese Buddhism (p. 144). For not only informing us, but also posing such provocative interpretations as this, we are beholden to the author for this fine guide.
