For years, education policymaking in the United States was distinctive in its governance. A strong tradition of local control vested most decision-making in the hands of local school boards and school administrators, who received strong advice from teachers’ unions and parents. Though not an “iron triangle” in the classic sense, it featured a relatively narrow and predictable group of participants.
But education policymaking has changed profoundly in recent years. In this well written and thought-provoking book, Jeffrey Henig contends that power has shifted from special-purpose governments (school districts) to general-purpose governments (cities, states, the nation). As this has occurred, politicians at all levels of government have come to play a much more significant role in education governance.
Henig cites considerable evidence to document these trends. He analyzes presidential State of the Union addresses and gubernatorial State of the State messages and finds that chief executives now devote more attention to education issues. He analyzes congressional hearings and bills enacted by state legislatures and finds that legislators focus more on education issues. He also cites similar evidence at the local level, relying especially on case studies of New York City and Washington, D.C.
It is rare to find a study of any public policy domain that pays close attention to all levels of government and all branches of government; yet Henig has admirably done exactly that. His discussion of the courts is especially important, because Henig believes that the courts have helped to make education policy “safe” for politicians who tend to be wary of “politically ticklish” issues. “By helping to cool down—if not necessarily solve—the inflammation around the thorn of race and integration, the courts cleared the way for general-purpose elected officials to enter an arena that they had regarded warily despite the substantial resources potentially in play,” Henig says (p. 93).
One might quarrel with this assertion, of course. Race simmers near the surface, if not above the surface, of many contemporary education policy debates, including vouchers, charter schools, merit pay, and high-stakes testing. Politicians who wade into the thicket of education policymaking can quickly find themselves discussing the black-white achievement gap or the special challenges facing English language learners. In fact, the No Child Left Behind Act explicitly drew our attention to such issues.
On the other hand, Henig is probably right that politicians can sidestep racially charged conversations by calling for excellence or accountability in education and embracing laws that promote these values. So long as the courts resolve tricky issues involving school finance, enrollment, and the drawing of school boundaries, politicians can eschew divisive controversies rooted in race.
Still, why should politicians get involved in education policymaking in the first place? One answer, according to Henig, is that politicians have discovered a connection between education and other issues. For example, many governors have reframed the education policy debate as a debate over economic development (p. 73). This helps to make the case for educational investments. Another answer, more or less from David Mayhew, is that politicians enjoy distributing goodies, and K-12 education involves a substantial pot of gold—$600 billion per year, according to one estimate (p. 93). To put it another way, the general public really cares about education, which is a good reason for politicians to care too.
One of the virtues of this book is that Henig helps us to understand not only the push towards general-purpose governments, but also the growing importance of centralization and privatization in education. In fact, Henig argues, these trends are mutually reinforcing. For example, as local autonomy recedes, decision-making increasingly shifts from special-purpose governments at the local level towards general-purpose governments at the state and federal levels. And privatization weakens the role of teachers’ unions, one of the pillars of the local education establishment.
One omission from the book is that Henig says little about how school boards, teachers’ unions, and parents have responded to the erosion of their political influence. Do they recognize what is going on? Or do they glimpse only a small sliver of the pattern Henig sees? Have they ratcheted up their own involvement? Or are they marginalized, traumatized, even paralyzed by these trends? It would be nice to know, for example, whether teachers’ unions have shifted lobbying resources away from special-purpose governments and towards general-purpose governments.
Another omission is that little attention is paid to the U.S. Department of Education. When thinking about education policymaking at the federal level, it is difficult to know who the prime mover is. But if federal secretaries of education are becoming more powerful, then perhaps their bureaucracies are too. Certainly, that is the criticism one hears from conservative critics of Arne Duncan and his staff. Ideology aside, an interesting question is whether the federal bureaucracy has become more influential while local school bureaucracies have become less influential.
These are quibbles, though, when one considers what the author has accomplished. Henig’s book is impressive in its scope, rich in insight, and chock full of relevant evidence. It is also an excellent example of how Baumgartner and Jones’ ideas on shifting venues and images can be used to illuminate important changes in policy subsystems. A recurring theme is that venue shopping and venue shifting produce policy innovations. Although Henig focuses more on venues than on images, he shows that they are interconnected and sees them as key mechanisms for achieving substantial policy change.
Henig’s analysis also helps us to understand why charter schools, performance pay for teachers, and high-stakes testing are flourishing today. Certainly, local school boards and teachers’ unions were unlikely to promote these ideas, if left to their own devices. For better or worse, these ideas are on the rise because chief executives and legislators at all levels of government are now actively engaged in education policymaking.
So, should we celebrate or deplore these trends? Henig worries that the end of education exceptionalism could erode a tradition of deference to expertise that led the Progressives to promote exceptionalism in the first place. He also worries that schools might suffer in a bare-knuckled battle for resources that includes multiple claimants for shares of the public purse.
On balance, though, Henig is optimistic. As exceptionalism ends, unconventional ideas are more likely to get a hearing. Also, we may witness new, broader coalitions that seek to tackle education deficits and income deficits simultaneously.
Although Henig’s book does not resolve all of these puzzles, it is well worth reading. Students of the policymaking process will find it a stimulating example of how non-incremental policy change can occur quite rapidly even in an age of partisanship and gridlock. Students of federalism will find it a cautionary tale of how fragile local control can be. And students of education policy will marvel at how several seemingly disparate trends point in the same direction—toward a strengthening of general-purpose governments. Education policy remains a subject of exceptional interest, even if the policy process behind it has become less exceptional.
