Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T13:50:27.450Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Turbulence suppression in plane Couette flow using reduced-order models

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 July 2025

Igor A. Maia*
Affiliation:
Divisão de Engenharia Aeronáutica, Instituto Tecnológico de Aeronáutica, São José dos Campos 12228-900, Brazil
André Cavalieri
Affiliation:
Divisão de Engenharia Aeronáutica, Instituto Tecnológico de Aeronáutica, São José dos Campos 12228-900, Brazil
*
Corresponding author: Igor A. Maia, igoriam@ita.br

Abstract

We explore a reduced-order model (ROM) of plane Couette flow with a view to performing near-wall turbulence control. The ROM is derived through Galerkin projections of the incompressible Navier–Stokes system onto a basis of controllability modes. Such ROMs were found to reproduce key aspects of turbulence dynamics in Couette flow with only a few hundred degrees of freedom, and here we use them to devise a control strategy. We consider a ROM with an extra forcing term whose structure is given by a combination of eigenfunctions of a linear viscous diffusion equation, optimised in order to minimise the total fluctuation energy. The optimisation is performed at Reynolds numbers $Re=1000, 2000, 3000$, and produces a novel control mechanism wherein the optimal forcing leads the flow to laminarisation in all cases. The forcing acts by reducing the shear in a large portion of the channel, hindering the main energy input mechanism. The forced flow possesses a new laminar solution which is linearly stable at $Re=1000$ and unstable at higher $Re$, but whose transient growth of streaky structures is substantially lower than that of laminar Couette flow, leading the flow to full laminarisation when the forcing is removed. Forcings optimised in the ROM are subsequently applied in direct numerical simulations (DNS). The same control mechanisms are observed in the DNS, where laminarisation is also achieved. We show that the ROMs provide an effective framework to design turbulence control strategies, despite the high degree of truncation, which opens up interesting possibilities for turbulence control.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the flow geometry. The black curve represents the turbulent mean-flow profile. The red curve illustrates a generic body forcing term, whose radial structure is optimised following the method described in § 2.1. Here, $U_w$ is the wall velocity and $(x,y,z)$ correspond to the streamwise, wall-normal and spanwise directions, respectively.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Wall-normal structure of first four Stokes modes that compose the forcing term.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Optimisation of the forcing term at $Re= 1000$: (a) evolution of the functional with increasing number of iterations; (b) forcing structure, computed from (2.9), at the end of the iterative process.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Results of controlled ROM simulations at $Re=1000$, where forcing is turned on and off. (a) Time evolution of the model coefficients, $a_i$. The vertical dashed lines indicate time instants when the control is turned on and off; (b) time-averaged flow profiles corresponding to time segments I (——), II (– – –) and III ($\cdots\cdots$). (c) r.m.s. velocity profiles of $u$ (blue), $v$ (yellow) and $w$ (red). Line style is the same as in (b).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Snapshots of streamwise velocity in the $y{-}z$ plane taken at time instants within segments I, II and III, highlighted in figure 4: (a) $t=500$; (b) $t=2500$; (c) $t=3500$. The Reynolds number is $Re=1000$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Energy budget analysis for ROMs at $Re=1000$. Panels (a) and (b) show phase portraits in the input–dissipation subspace for uncontrolled and controlled ROM simulations, respectively. Input and dissipation are in balance on the dashed diagonal line. The blue and green dots in (b) indicate the laminar states for the controlled and uncontrolled flows, respectively. (c) Presents the time evolution of total inputs and dissipation terms as the forcing is turned on and off. Inputs and dissipation are normalised by the laminar values for Couette flow.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Modal distribution of energy input in uncontrolled and controlled ROMs. Panels (a) and (d) show averaged modal energy inputs, $\overline {I}_{i_1}$ and $\overline {I}_{i_2}$, ranked in descending order. Modes associated with the circled inputs in (a) and (d) are displayed in (b)–(c) and (e)–(f) in the uncontrolled and controlled ROMs, respectively. Contours correspond to the streamwise velocity component, $u$, and the arrows represent the wall-normal, $v$, and spanwise, $w$, components.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Linear stability characteristics of the new laminar solution obtained with the controlled ROM, compared with canonical Couettte at $Re=1000$. (a) New laminar velocity profile; (b) eigenvalue spectrum of the linear operator; (c) transient growth analysis.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Comparison of control results at $Re=1000, 2000, 3000$. (a) Wall-normal structure of the forcing term. Panels (b), (c) and (d) show comparisons between the new laminar base flows (dashed lines) and the turbulent mean flows (solid lines) without the forcing.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Energy budget analysis for ROMs at $Re=2000$ (a) and $Re=3000$ (b). Inputs and dissipation are normalised by the laminar values for Couette flow.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Transient growth behaviour of ROMs at different Reynolds numbers. (a) Comparison between laminar Couette flow and the new laminar (controlled) state at $Re=1000, 2000, 3000$; (b) zoomed view of the transient growth curves for controlled ROMs. Their maximum transient amplification is found to be almost constant, and close to that obtained with a laminar Couette profile at $Re=300$.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Net energy savings as a function of time for $Re=1000$ (a), $Re=2000$ (b) and $Re=3000$ (c). The dashed line marks the theoretical limit for energy savings, which occurs when the forcing is disabled and the flow returns to the laminar Couette state.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Robustness tests for controlled ROMS at $Re=3000$ to random initial conditions of different amplitudes. Panels show (a) $A=1$; (b) $A=10^1$; (c) $A=10^2$. The inset in (c) displays zoomed views. The forcing term is turned on in the beginning of the simulations.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Robustness tests for controlled ROMs to off-design Reynolds numbers: $Re=2100$ (a, d); $Re=2500$ (b, e); $Re=2800$ (c, f). Panels (a–c) display the time coefficients and panels (d–f) show statistics computed at controlled and uncontrolled segments of the simulations. Solid lines correspond to statistics computed in time segment I, and dashed lines to statistics of segment II. For all cases, the forcing term was optimised for $Re=2000$.

Figure 14

Table 1.List of parameters for DNS of forced Couette flows. Here, $N_x$, $N_y$ and $N_z$ are the number of grid points in the streamwise, wall-normal and spanwise directions, respectively, $\Delta x^+$ and $\Delta z^+$ are the grid spacings in the streamwise and spanwise directions, in wall units and $Re_\tau$ is the Reynolds number based on the friction velocity. The values of $Re_\tau$ indicated in the second column correspond to a time average computed in the first part of the simulation, when the forcing is off.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Couette flow statistics at $Re=3000$. (a) Mean-flow profiles; (b) second-order statistics. Solid lines: data from Pirozzoli et al. (2014); dashed lines: DNS case C3; dash-dotted lines: DNS data from C3_LargeBox; dotted lines: ROM.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Pre-multipled spanwise spectrum, $k_z E_{uu}^{+}$ as a function of wall distance, $y^+$. Panel (a) refers to flow case C3 ($L_x = 2\pi h, L_z=\pi h$), and panel (b) refers to flow case C3_LargeBox ($L_x = 4\pi h, L_z=2\pi h$). Dashed lines correspond to data from the present study and solid lines are data from Lee & Moser (2018) for $Re_{\tau }$, $L_x = 20\pi h, L_z=5\pi h$. The vertical dashed line marks the cutoff wavelength of the present DNS. Nine contour levels are shown, between 0.34 and 3.08.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Energy budget analysis computed for DNS and ROMs at $Re=1000$, (a), $Re=2000$ (b) and $Re=3000$ (c). Inputs and dissipation are normalised by the laminar values for Couette flow.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Time history of the friction Reynolds number computed from DNS.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Time histories of spatially averaged cross-flow velocities $\langle v^2 \rangle$, $\langle w^2 \rangle$, computed from DNS at $Re=1000$–$3000$.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Laminar flow profiles obtained in the controlled DNS (solid grey lines), compared with the turbulent mean flow (solid black lines) and the laminar flow from the controlled ROMs (dashed line) for cases C1 (a), C2 (b) and C3 (c).

Figure 21

Figure 21.Three-dimensional streamwise velocity snapshots taken from $Re=3000$ simulations at selected time instants before, during and after application of the forcing. Panels (a)–(e) correspond to DNS and panels (f)–(j) to ROM simulations. The colours correspond to ten velocity contours, equally spaced in the range $-1 \leqslant u \leqslant 1$.

Figure 22

Table 2.Parameters of ROMs with different sizes. Here, $N_c$ represents the number of controllability modes taken for each wavenumber pair and $N$ is the total number of DoFs.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Flows statistics at $Re=1000$ obtained with ROMs of different sizes, compared with DNS data. Panels (a), (b), (c) and (d) correspond, respectively, to profiles of mean flow, r.m.s. streamwise velocity, r.m.s. wall-normal velocity and r.m.s. spanwise velocity.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Flows statistics at $Re=3000$ obtained with ROMs of different sizes, compared with DNS data. Panels (a), (b), (c) and (d) correspond, respectively, to profiles of mean flow, r.m.s. streamwise velocity, r.m.s. wall-normal velocity and r.m.s. spanwise velocity.

Figure 25

Table 3.Error in estimation of TKE levels by the $N=900$ ROM at different Reynolds numbers.

Figure 26

Figure 24.Linear stability of the forced laminar state for the wavenumber pairs described in the ROM, computed with the Orr–Sommerfeld–Squire equations for $Re=1000, 2000, 3000$. Panels (a)-(d) show eigenvalue spectra for four wavenumber pairs: (a) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (0,1)$; (b) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (0,2)$; (c) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (1,1)$; (d) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (1,2)$.

Figure 27

Figure 25.Neutral stability curves computed for the forced base flows obtained at $Re=2000$ (a) and $Re=3000$ (b). The corresponding spanwise wavenumber is fixed, $k_z=0$. The shaded area corresponds to the region in the $k_x$–$Re$ space where unstable solutions exist.

Figure 28

Figure 26.Transient growth curves for the laminar Couette flow and the laminar state of the forced flow, computed with the Orr–Sommerfeld–Squire equations for four wavenumber pairs: (a) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (0,1)$; (b) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (0,2)$; (c) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (1,1)$; (d) $(k_x/\alpha, k_z/\beta) = (1,2)$. The inset in panel (a) shows a zoomed view of the curves corresponding to controlled cases. Legend is the same as in figure 11.

Figure 29

Figure 27.Profiles of turbulent kinetic energy production. The solid lines correspond to data from the present study: C1 (red); C2 (blue); C3 (black). The symbols are data from Orlandi et al. (2015) for different Reynolds numbers: $Re_{\tau }=180$ (squares), $Re_{\tau }=250$ (circles), $Re_{\tau }=500$ (triangles) and $Re_{\tau }=1000$ (downward-pointing triangles).

Supplementary material: File

Maia and Cavalieri supplementary material movie 1

Animation of controlled DNS simulation at $Re=3000$ . The contours represent 3D streamwise velocity snapshots. Ten velocity contours are shown, equally spaced in the range $-1 \\leqslant u \\leqslant 1$ .
Download Maia and Cavalieri supplementary material movie 1(File)
File 8.9 MB
Supplementary material: File

Maia and Cavalieri supplementary material movie 2

Animation of controlled ROM simulation at $Re=3000$ . The contours represent 3D streamwise velocity snapshots. Ten velocity contours are shown, equally spaced in the range $-1 \\leqslant u \\leqslant 1$ .
Download Maia and Cavalieri supplementary material movie 2(File)
File 8.1 MB