In Shakespeare and the Materiality of Performance, Erika T. Lin moves between prevalent cultural practices and theatrical spectacles to analyze the attitudes and traditions that informed modes of spectating in early modern playhouses. Lin engages the new materialist tradition in order to develop a “materiality of performance” for the early modern stage; in so doing, she aims to illuminate the ways in which spectacular performances became legible to early modern audiences (7). Although she acknowledges materialism's Marxist roots, Lin turns to Judith Butler's theory of performativity and weaves in the Foucauldian notion of the historical a priori with the hope of analyzing “the process through which performance actively produces the historical a priori” (8, original emphasis). For Lin, performance is “material” in two key ways: first, the theatrical signifiers that make up performance (chairs, handkerchiefs, bodies) are inherently material; second, the fiction of onstage theatrical conventions have offstage social repercussions. In part by challenging the ways in which we understand “materiality,” Lin uncovers the complex picture of life inside and outside the playhouse.
Drawing from both historical phenomenology and historical formalism, Lin brings critical theory, print culture studies, and theatre history together in order to analyze performance elements of early modern plays within the public playhouse and their relationship to popular cultural practices. Because Lin's work is ultimately theoretical, she does not pursue a comprehensive list of examples from early modern dramatic literature and performance. Instead, she limits her focus to works that she takes to be representative and accessible to a wide readership; as such, Lin's case studies are canonical early modern plays, including Shakespeare's Love's Labours Lost and Macbeth, Kyd's The Spanish Tragedy, and Marlowe's Doctor Faustus.
The book is divided into three parts. The first, “Performance Effects,” lays the groundwork for Lin's argument, acting in effect as a supplementary introduction to the following two parts. The single chapter in Part I, “Theorizing Theatrical Privilege,” establishes Lin's historical lens by arguing that although Robert Weimann's concepts of locus and platea are still hugely influential in scholarly conceptualizations of early modern playing spaces, we need an “alternative model for understanding the authority of performance in early modern drama” (23). Lin problematizes naturalized assumptions about early modern stage geography and social privilege within the fiction of a play and maintains that moments in early modern plays that “foregrounded the process by which elements presented onstage came to signify within the represented fiction were theatrically privileged” (37, original emphasis). The rest of her study analyzes some of these “theatrically privileged” moments.
In Part II, “Theatrical Ways of Knowing,” Lin reconstructs the epistemological framework(s) within which early modern audiences were embedded. Chapter 2, “Staging Sight,” considers visual archetypes in science, religion, and art to argue that these early modern ocular paradigms affected the staging of early modern plays, thereby shaping “not only what playgoers saw but also how they saw” (43, original emphasis). The following chapter, “Imaginary Forces,” juxtaposes moments of metatheatricality with early modern accounts of supernatural events in an attempt to reconstruct the epistemological complexity of interpreting these moments in the playhouse. With respect to the multiple layers of theatricality in Kyd's Spanish Tragedy, Lin argues that metatheatrical moments were not a commentary on “art as a reflection of life” as many scholars maintain. Rather, they were an articulation of the “spiritual implications of negotiating theatre as a semiotic system” and the anxieties associated with “interpreting seemingly real sensory experiences” (73). Through an examination of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century treatises on demonic and ghostly visions in relation to metatheatrical moments onstage, such as those in Spanish Tragedy, Lin argues that modes of seeing, interpreting, and knowing had spiritual and moral repercussions for early modern spectators.
In her third and final part, “Experiencing Embodied Spectacle,” Lin continues to develop ideas about the moral implications of spectatorship wherein she discusses both “feats of activity” (107) and acts of dismemberment in the playhouse. Lin observes that early modern forms of entertainment not only included plays and bearbaiting but also unscripted inset spectacles. Among these “extratheatrical” forms of entertainment were dances, displays of acrobatics, and other performances of physical prowess. Throughout Part III, Lin engages scientific treatises that describe sight not only as a participatory activity, but also as a penetrating act. Physical spectacle presented onstage before early modern playgoers pulled audiences into the action of the play, implicating them in sensual acts of physical performance and violence. Here Lin argues for an active audience that produced cultural beliefs and practices through acts of spectatorship; early modern performance media “did not simply reflect existing cultural practices but contributed to them” (148–9).
Because Lin seeks to situate early modern staging practices within their historical performance traditions and cultural contexts, a clearer identification of her study's periodization would serve her purpose well. Although her monograph “centers on the decades immediately before and after the turn of the seventeenth century” (10), Lin never explicitly states why; the designation thus comes off as arbitrary rather than purposeful. Nevertheless, Lin's reading of early modern performance traditions and spectatorship serves as a valuable working model for scholars of drama seeking to marry rigorous historical investigations with critical theory. For those interested in reception theory, material studies, and early modern stage practices, Shakespeare and the Materiality of Performance can be read productively alongside other studies in historical phenomenology as well as early modern audience and reception studies.
