Following the end of Britain's wars against France in 1815, a large number of officers in the Royal Navy found themselves without occupation as annual naval expenditure was reduced in the following ten years by more than 70 per cent. It quickly became clear that one way for officers on half pay to gain peacetime employment and possibly command was by undertaking scientific research – a position that was publicly acknowledged in the Admiralty's Manual of Scientific Enquiry published in 1849.
John Franklin (1786–1847) joined the Navy in 1800, serving at the battles of Copenhagen and Trafalgar. After a brief period on land he joined various Arctic expeditions in search of the North-West Passage and as a result was promoted captain in 1821, commanding further expeditions later in the decade for which he was knighted in 1829. From 1837 he served for six years as governor of the penal colony of Van Diemen's Land.
Had Franklin died shortly after his return to England he would be recognized by historians as a significant figure in Arctic exploration and probably rate a footnote to imperial history. However, his permanent reputation as a household name was secured when he was appointed in 1845 to command HMSs Erebus and Terror, both very modern ships powered by high-pressure steam engines driving propellers, on a further Arctic expedition. On 26 July 1845 the expedition was seen in Baffin Bay and was never heard of again. In 1847 the search for Franklin began and in the following twelve years at least thirty expeditions were mounted to discover what had happened. By the end of that period the broad outline of the disaster that had overcome the ships, together with strong evidence of cannibalism amongst the survivors, had been pieced together. The grisly story gripped the public imagination in Victorian times and continues to do so. Expeditions, the most recent in 2010, to fill in the details, and more particularly to locate the wrecks, continue to provide good newspaper copy – although issues relating to Canada's claim to sovereignty over this part of the Arctic also play a significant role in encouraging further searches.
Much of this is well known and what Andrew Lambert, professor of naval history at King's College London, has done is to reinterpret Franklin's career in terms of imperial science and especially geomagnetism. He argues, convincingly in my view, that the key figure in this was Edward Sabine and that it is he who should be seen as the proper successor to Joseph Banks in using science to sustain and expand the British Empire. One thing this book has done is to confirm my long-held view that we desperately need a proper study of Sabine – the only person ever to have held all four officer positions of the Royal Society cannot be a negligible figure – and the materials do exist.
Lambert shows that during Franklin's term of office as governor of Van Diemen's Land he wanted to turn the colony into a major scientific site with its own institutions, observatories, botanic gardens and societies. To further this aim he started to use the name Tasmania (although not officially adopted until 1856), to play down the general perception that its main function was as a convict colony. The establishment of the geomagnetic observatory at Rossbank in Hobart in 1840 was part of Franklin's plan for the colony and also brought him into contact with the project, masterminded by Sabine, to establish such observatories, funded by the British state, across the empire. This link was probably one of the reasons why Franklin was chosen for the command of the 1845 Arctic expedition, which, as Lambert shows, was closely linked to the ‘magnetic crusade’, rather than the search for the North-West Passage.
As with all revisionist history of a well-known episode, one does have to ask how it was that the received version of events came into existence and was sustained. Lambert deals with this by analysing, in the final section of this book, the statue of Franklin by Matthew Nobel unveiled in Waterloo Place on 15 November 1866. This was an integral part of a sustained effort to heroize Franklin and his expedition and to deflect attention away from its more grisly aspects. To what extent this effort was successful is not clear, but Lambert makes a valiant effort at linking it with the heroic, but foolhardy, Antarctic expedition led by Robert Scott in 1912. While this is plausible, I do have problems with Lambert's extension of the argument to the equally misplaced heroism displayed during the Great War in its early stages.
This quibble aside, this is a fine reinterpretation of a figure whose fate frequently recurs in Victorian letters, diaries and newspapers from the mid-1840s onwards. Lambert has provided an exemplary study of how science continued to be used in the first half of the nineteenth century to further the interests of the British Empire and contributes significantly to our understanding of why the government invested so heavily in certain areas of science and not in others.
